Japan, West clash over 'cultural' whale hunts

October 26, 2016 by Mariëtte Le Roux
All whaling other than for aboriginal subsistence or for scientific research is banned under an IWC moratorium introduced 30 years ago

Japan pleaded with the world's whaling watchdog Wednesday to allow small hunts by coastal communities, arguing that for three decades these groups had been unjustly barred from a traditional source of food.

The issue of "small type coastal hunting" is a key dispute between pro- and anti-whaling nations gathered in Slovenia for the 66th meeting of the International Whaling Commission (IWC).

As in other years that the issue has come up, Japan's ambitions were backed by fellow whalers Norway and Iceland, and vehemently opposed by the United States, Europe, Australia and others.

All whaling other than for aboriginal subsistence or for scientific research is banned under an IWC moratorium introduced 30 years ago.

"There is this perception that we are asking (for the) total lifting of the moratorium, that is not the case," Japan's commissioner to the IWC, Joji Morishita told delegates .

"We are just asking for a small quota based on science, and of particular species in particular water. That's it."

Japan seeks a quota for minke whales in the West Pacific, and argues that stock numbers can sustain small hunts.

The takings would be "exclusively for local consumption" by four , it said.

"I'm not asking other countries to change their basic positions," said Morishita, nor "to eat whale meat."

South Korean activists portraying Japanese fishermen spear a "whale" during a protest against Japan's whaling fleet outside the Japanese embassy in Seoul

He urged other nations to look beyond their "principled position against whaling under any circumstances" in the quest for a compromise on this and other deeply divisive whaling questions.

Not bad vs good

"It's not like one side is bad and one side is good. This is not a dichotomy or a black and white situation," the commissioner said.

Along with Norway and Iceland, which argued the IWC was "held hostage" by anti-whalers, Japan's position was also supported by Russia.

"I think that we all have to remember that those four communities in Japan that have been asking for quota, they have a 5,000-year history of whaling," said Russia's deputy IWC commissioner, Valentin Ilyashenko.

"Our task is not only to conserve biodiversity but also to conserve culture and traditions."

The European Union and United States spoke out strongly against the proposal.

In 2014/15, Japan caught 196 whales with the meat ending up on supermarket shelves and in restaurants in line with an IWC stipulation whales taken for science must be eaten
"We can only reiterate our stong support for the maintenance of the global moratorium on and our serious concerns about the impact of small type coastal whaling on whales," the Dutch commissioner Roel Feringa, said on behalf of the EU bloc.

For the US, commissioner Russell Smith said it was also an issue of values.

"Those values for the US include ensuring that our subsistence farmers have their right, have the access to the whales that they need, but they also include the value that we at this time should not be engaged in commercial whaling."

The disagreement sets Japan up for an even bigger clash later this week, about its annual whale killings in the name of scientific research—which other nations claim is a cover-up for commercial hunting for meat.

New Zealand and Australia have submitted a proposal to the IWC for scientific hunts, which are allowed under a loophole in the moratorium, to be much more closely scrutinised.

If countries cannot agree on a compromise on the proposal, a vote will be held, probably on Thursday.

Norway, too, came under fire on Wednesday—from conservation groups which accuse the IWC of giving the world's biggest whale hunter, a free ride.

An anti-whaling protestor holds up a leaflet outside the Norwegian embassy in central London

Norway, which conducts commercial hunts under a formal objection it had lodged to the moratorium, took 736 in 2014, according to IWC numbers, compared to Japan's 196—81 minke, 25 Bryde's whales and 90 sei whales.

With a dwindling appetite for in Norway, as in Iceland, much of the Norwegian catch is exported to Japan, and some used as animal feed, said Sandra Altherr of Pro Wildlife.

"Commercial whaling and trade is ongoing, and Norway is a huge part of that," she said. "But we don't see any diplomatic measures on Norway."

Explore further: Whalers in crosshairs at international huddle

Related Stories

Whalers in crosshairs at international huddle

October 22, 2016

More than 80 nations square off in Slovenia next week over the fate of the world's remaining whales, facing a multitude of perils from meat hunters and ship strikes to getting snared in fishing gear.

Battle lines drawn fast at global whaling huddle

October 24, 2016

A key meeting on whales opened to early confrontation Monday with Japan seeking an end to a 30-year moratorium on whale hunting, and others proposing an Atlantic cetacean sanctuary.

Iceland ups 2014 whaling quotas

December 13, 2013

Iceland announced Friday it has increased its 2014 quotas for whaling in a move likely to intensify international condemnation of the practice.

Iceland resumes controversial fin whale hunt

June 17, 2013

Iceland has resumed its disputed commercial fin whale hunt, with two vessels en route to catch this season's quota of at least 154 whales, Icelandic media reported on Monday.

Recommended for you

Fish-inspired material changes color using nanocolumns

March 20, 2019

Inspired by the flashing colors of the neon tetra fish, researchers have developed a technique for changing the color of a material by manipulating the orientation of nanostructured columns in the material.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.