Math key factor in career fields where women are underrepresented

Math – not college faculty's belief that female students lack brilliance – points to why fewer women are in STEM fields, research at the University of Kansas shows.

The findings challenge a study published earlier this year in the journal Science that concluded women were underrepresented in academic fields where faculty believe success is dependent on "raw, innate talent," which faculty chronically stereotype as a shortcoming for women.

Recent research at KU shows when GRE scores are factored in, female representation correlates with the amount of in the field, making faculty beliefs about a student's ability irrelevant.

"To me it is all about the mathematical content of the field. Girls not taking math coursework early on in middle school and high school are set on a different college trajectory than boys," said Donna Ginther, KU professor of economics and director of KU's Center for Science, Technology & Economic Policy at the Institute for Policy & Social Research.

Ginther and Boston University economist Shulamit Kahn's technical comment challenging the Jan. 16 article, "Expectations of brilliance underlie gender distributions across academic disciplines," will be published Friday, July 24, in Science.

Ginther noticed that a graph from the Jan. 16 article showed similar results to a graph that she and a team of researchers compiled for a study on science's gender gap.

The faculty beliefs study correlated academic fields by the percentage of females who earned doctoral degrees and faculty beliefs about innate ability. Ginther's graph correlated academic fields by percentage of female doctoral degrees and average GRE math scores. Both showed the most math-intensive fields had the lowest percentage of female doctoral degrees.

"Their results didn't add up," Ginther said of the faculty beliefs study.

Combining data from the faculty beliefs study with GRE scores, Ginther and Kahn found the higher the field's GRE math requirements, the fewer women in the field. The research also found the larger the gap between a higher math and lower verbal score, the more likely someone was to enter a math-intensive field, which favored men.

"What we are saying is very similar. They say the attitude of the people in the field is preventing women from getting a Ph.D. We are saying those attitudes may or may not be a factor, but really it happens a lot earlier than college," Ginther said.

The research supports Ginther's earlier study on the gender gap in math-intensive STEM fields. In that study, the main policy recommendation was to provide intervention programs as early as elementary school to improve young girls' math skills.

"If you want to increase women's participation, you have to really target your intervention at the source, and that source is young girls, not women in college," Ginther said.

Explore further

Gender fairness prevails in most fields of academic science

Journal information: Science

Citation: Math key factor in career fields where women are underrepresented (2015, July 24) retrieved 22 August 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Jul 24, 2015
If you read Science you will find Cimpian and Leslie made a strong response that answered the above: "Ginther and Kahn claim that academics' beliefs about the importance of brilliance do not predict gender gaps in Ph.D. attainment beyond mathematics and verbal test scores. However, Ginther and Kahn's analyses are problematic, exhibiting more than 100 times the recommended collinearity thresholds. Multiple analyses that avoid this problem suggest that academics' beliefs are in fact uniquely predictive of gender gaps across academia."

Jul 24, 2015
As a student I learned algebra when I was 8 years old - in the 4th grade - thanks to a teacher who didn't believe in the standard 'clock' for education. Delaying math education does a disservice to the young student.

Jul 28, 2015
This comment has been removed by a moderator.

Jul 28, 2015
Computers were once rooms of (mostly) women who performed calculations.
What happened to female math abilities?
I can only blame math professors.

Jul 28, 2015
Computers were once rooms of (mostly) women who performed calculations.
What happened to female math abilities?
I can only blame math professors.

Not in actuarial or accounting firms pre WWII; maybe some starting in the US. Pre WWI, not anywhere.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more