Second GM corn set for EU approval after Court ruling

October 31, 2013
A second genetically-modified corn crop looks set for authorisation in the European Union unless there is a sudden change in the positions of divided governments or official scientific advice, EU sources said Thursday

A second genetically-modified corn crop looks set for authorisation in the European Union unless there is a sudden change in the positions of divided governments or official scientific advice, EU sources said Thursday.

A 12-year-old filing for permission to cultivate TC1507 corn by Dow-Pioneer is back at the top of bloc environment ministers' in-tray at their next meeting on December 13, after the European Court of Justice found there had been an unjustified delay in examining the application.

Ecologists say the crop exudes toxic chemicals that harm insect pests, thus removing the need for farmers to buy chemical pesticides but creating knock-on risks for bees and ecological stability.

But the European Commission says experts from the European Food Safety Authority have given it a clean bill of health, hence the judicially-ordered return to consideration of its authorisation for use.

Currently, just one GM crop—Monsanto's MON810 maize—is allowed to be grown in Europe, and this only in small quantities in Spain and Portugal.

A second permitted crop—BASF's Amflora potatoes—has been abandoned by its makers.

The 28 EU ministers need to decide by qualified majority voting—weighted to take account of member states' size—whether to approve or reject the application.

A failure to reach a conclusion—which has been typically the outcome on an issue of high legal as well as political tension—would leave the Commission forced to take a decision.

The Commission would likely approve because of EFSA's findings and the threat of European Court fines if it didn't, sources said.

Greenpeace campaigners said the Court decision criticises the procedures followed, but does not prevent the Commission from taking a definitive stand based on alternative scientific reports.

However, the Commission says that it is trapped by a positive recommendation as the Court requires it follow rules in force when the application was submitted.

That obliges the EU executive to follow the EFSA's recommendation in the absence of a clear majority among states.

Commission spokesman Frederic Vincent said its hierarchy would decide next Wednesday "what judicial route to take following the Court's ruling."

Austria, Bulgaria, France, Greece, Hungary, Luxembourg and Romania have each invoked safeguard measures to block MON810 cultivation on their territories.

In August, however, France's Council of State ruled that the French moratorium going back to March 2012 failed to uphold EU law.

President Francois Hollande subsequently said the ban nationally would remain.

Explore further: French court lifts ban on growing Monsanto GM corn

Related Stories

EU freezes approval of GM crops to 2014

January 22, 2013

The European Commission has decided to freeze the approval process for genetically modified food crops through the end of its mandate next year while it works towards an agreement with EU member states.

Italy asks EU to halt GM maize cultivation

April 4, 2013

The Italian government has asked the European Commission not to renew authorisation of a key genetically-modified corn, according to a letter seen by AFP on Thursday.

France asks EU to suspend GM crop authorisation

February 20, 2012

France's ecology ministry said Monday it had asked European regulators to suspend authorisation for the use of genetically modified MON 810 maize crops from US company Monsanto based on new studies.

Recommended for you

New gene catalog of ocean microbiome reveals surprises

August 17, 2017

Microbes dominate the planet, especially the ocean, and help support the entire marine food web. In a recent report published in Nature Microbiology, University of Hawai'i at Mānoa (UHM) oceanography professor Ed DeLong ...

Researchers describe gene that makes large, plump tomatoes

August 17, 2017

Farmers can grow big, juicy tomatoes thanks to a mutation in the Cell Size Regulator gene that occurred during the tomato domestication process. Esther van der Knaap of the University of Georgia, Athens and colleagues describe ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1.4 / 5 (10) Oct 31, 2013
This is yet another example of utter biased madness. Anything that kills insects will kill bees. Have they forgotten how seriously depleted the population of bees and other pollinators has become as a result of intensive and unnecessary industrialisation of agriculture? Such short memories will lead to long term nightmares.
Besides there is actually no need to be meddling with DNA to produce food. The planetary total food production is well in excess of what the population needs to feed it. Its just that there is no regulation of food so speculators make profits from starving millions who cannot afford the inflated prices. Even though they could all be fed a healthy diet without any genetic modification.
But then at isn't profitable and it doesn't create the control of the food chain that the governments and corporations want and so desperately desire.
Talk about corrupt.
1.4 / 5 (10) Oct 31, 2013
I don't mind GM for making foods resistant to disease, but when they put genes in crops to make them create poison to kill insects, I think that is going too far, and this stuff will eventually accumulate in human tissue and in livestock tissue.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.