Is comet ISON disintegrating?

October 6, 2013

Astronomer Ignacio Ferrin, FACom researcher, analyzed the most recent observational data of Comet ISON and has identified clear signatures of what he has called an "impending demise." The so-called light-curve of the comet shows features previously observed in disintegrating comets.

Since his previous announcement, the predictions of Prof. Ignacio Ferrin concerning the uncertain future of Comet ISON are being if not definitively confirmed at least supported by the most recent optical observations. Despite the generalized skepticism and claims about the fact that the rumors of Comet ISON "fizzling" were greatly exaggerated, the is still showing an unexpected behavior that cometary specialists are fighting to explain.

"Comet ISON has presented a peculiar behavior," said Prof. Ferrin while confirming what he already stated in the previous FACom press release. He continues by saying that "the light curve of the comet exhibited a slowdown event characterized by a constant brightness with no indication of a brightness increase tendency." This slowdown began around January 13, 2013, and, according to Prof. Ferrin, it continued up to the latest available observations at the end of September 2013. The brightness has remained practically constant for more than 270 days or 9 months, a behavior without any precedent in cometary astronomy. This evidence has led Prof. Ferrin to conclude that it is probably that the comet is dying.

In a recent letter posted to Cornell University arXiv preprints repository (, Prof. Ferrin presented and discussed what he identified as a peculiar photometric signature previously observed in disintegrating comets. In his own words "when I saw this signature I immediately went to my database of comet light curves, and found that two comets had also presented this signature: Comet C/1996 Q1 Tabur and Comet C/2002 O4 Hönig; to my surprise these two comets had vanished turning off or disintegrating." According to Prof. Ferrin this observation is irrefutable evidence that Comet ISON is following the same path of those defunct comets. The following few weeks will reveal the real fate of weird Comet ISON.

Interestingly a comparison between the light curves of ISON and eight previously disintegrating comets is allowing Prof. Ferrin to predict that the object has already entered into a sort of "danger zone" using his own words. No theoretical model exists capable of explaining all the observed phenomena with those defunct comets.

Several well known facts about the strange behavior of Comet ISON should be widely recognized. It was expected that the comet would bright up after passing the "frost line," a distance at which comets tend to turn on water production. Some astronomers locate this line between 2.5 and 3 AU. But the comet has already passed that line and almost none has occurred. This was the last chance of the comet to exhibit some healthy activity but ISON has surprised experts by maintaining almost unmodified its photometric behavior. Additionally ISON faces other challenges as it approaches to the inner solar system. First, the comet will reach perihelion very near the Sun, where Prof. Ferrin has calculated a temperature of 2,700 degrees Celsius, high enough to melt iron and lead. Second, besides this trial by fire, the comet will penetrate the solar Roche limit. Any object penetrating this forbidden limit will experience solar tides that may tear apart the nucleus of the comet. The combination of temperature, radiation and tides may prove too much for the comet, which may not survive the encounter with the Sun.

Explore further: Changes in comet rotation may be predicted with greater accuracy

More information:

Related Stories

Preparing for comet ISON

September 24, 2013

( —ESA's space missions are getting ready to observe an icy visitor to the inner Solar System: Comet ISON, which might also be visible in the night sky later this year as a naked eye object.

Hubble brings faraway comet into view

April 23, 2013

( —The NASA Hubble Space Telescope has given astronomers their clearest view yet of Comet ISON, a newly-discovered sun grazer comet that may light up the sky later this year, or come so close to the Sun that it ...

A new view of comet ISON

May 3, 2013

Here's a new image of Comet C/2012 S1 ISON, as seen on May 1, 2013 by Ernesto Guido and Nick Howes of the Remanzacco Observatory. They used the 2 meter La Palma Telescope. Their initial approximation of the tail length is ...

Comet ISON shaping up to be a spectacular display

January 15, 2013

(—Excitement is mounting for astronomers and star gazers the world over as word spreads that Comet ISON may go down in the history books as one of the flashiest ever. First discovered in September of last year ...

Recommended for you

Evidence found of white dwarf remnant after supernova

August 18, 2017

An international team of space scientists has found evidence of what they believe is a remnant of a type Iax supernova—a white dwarf moving in a way that suggests it was blown across part of the universe by the power of ...

Scientists improve brown dwarf weather forecasts

August 18, 2017

Dim objects called brown dwarfs, less massive than the sun but more massive than Jupiter, have powerful winds and clouds–specifically, hot patchy clouds made of iron droplets and silicate dust. Scientists recently realized ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (18) Oct 06, 2013
Despite the generalized skepticism and claims about the fact that the rumors of Comet ISON "fizzling" were greatly exaggerated, the comet is still showing an unexpected behavior that cometary specialists are fighting to explain.

Fighting to explain is a trait when you models are as pathetic as comet theory.

No theoretical model exists capable of explaining all the observed phenomena with those defunct comets.

No theoretical model based on the "standard" model, however there is a model which explains it, the electric comet theory does splendidly.

Everything is strange when your worldview is as utterly myopic as those tasked with observing these phenomena.
1 / 5 (12) Oct 06, 2013
this thing is 5km in diameter. it is dynamic. the sun , too , with constantly changing solar activity, both in magnitude and more importantly direction of solar wind,--------one probably directed small solar burst would most likely set this comet in a totally different superheated state.

i don't believe the predictions. first, we were told it would be the most spectacular comet seen in centuries. now, we don't know, because it hasn't met expecations. how about we try and just observe it. and not predict. that , in any case, is the essence of good science. unbiassed observation without desire for a predicted outcome of any sort. just watch.

and enjoy the show. the best part is yet to come in the next few months.
3 / 5 (2) Oct 07, 2013
Long period comets are so rare that we have very few examples of their behavior, and since it takes tens of thousands of years for them to return, we've never seen the same one pass twice.

Since it came from deep space, beyond the orbits of Neptune and Pluto, the interior must be near absolute zero. It may just take a lot more energy to heat it up than we thought. There is probably a refrigeration effect as the surface sublimes too. That might explain why it isn't producing water vapor as we expected. Short period comets are quite different since their interiors are much warmer, due to the fact that they've had hundreds of thousands of years to warm up.

The story above is a bit over dramatic when it say that we don't understand how these things work. We do in broad strokes, just not in detail. That's mainly because we just don't know what they are made of exactly.

A mission to rendevous with a long period comet would be very ambitious and revealing.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.