Anthropologist suggests Mediterranean islands inhabited much earlier than thought

NASA photograph of Crete. Credit: NASA

(—Anthropologist Alan Simmons of the University of Nevada has published a perspective piece in the journal Science suggesting that the Mediterranean islands were inhabited far earlier than has been thought. Rather than the first inhabitation of such islands as Cyprus and Crete occurring roughly 9,000 years ago, he suggests it might have been as many as 170,000.

Modern science has held that islands such as Cyprus and Crete were first inhabited by seafaring humans approximately 9,000 years ago by agriculturists from the late . Simmons writes that research over the past 20 years has cast doubt on that assumption however and suggests that it might be time to rewrite the history books. He cites evidence such as pieces of obsidian found in a cave in mainland Greece that were found to have come from Melos, an island in the Aegean Sea and were dated at 11,000 years ago as well as artifacts from recent digs on Cyprus that are believed to be from approximately 12,000 years ago. He adds that some researchers have also found evidence that something, or someone caused the extinction of pygmy on Cyprus around the same time.

Simmons also suggests that the first inhabitants of many of the Mediterranean islands may not have been modern humans at all. Instead, he says evidence has been found that shows that they might have been , or . Recent excavations on Crete have turned up artifacts that are thought to be 110,000 years old, for example, and a was found that is believed to have been made on the same island as far back as 170,000 years ago. Since modern humans are believed to have come into being roughly 100,000 to 200,000 years ago, the possibility exists that such artifacts were left behind by an early ancestor or cousin.

Simmons also notes that evidence is mounting that indicates sea travel was occurring many thousands of years before modern humans arrived on the scene. He notes that it is commonly accepted that Australia was colonized approximately 50,000 years ago, and fossils (of an ancient lineage that went extinct) found in Indonesia have been dated to 1.1 million years ago.

All of the evidence put together, Simmons says, points to the very real possibility that it was Neanderthals or Homo erectus that first settled the Mediterranean islands and that they did so by building boats and navigating them indicating they had cognitive abilities far beyond what has traditionally been assumed by modern scientists.

Explore further

Evidence suggests Neanderthals took to boats before modern humans

More information: Mediterranean Island Voyages, Science, 16 November 2012: Vol. 338 no. 6109 pp. 895-897. DOI: 10.1126/science.1228880

Some of the classical world's most innovative cultures developed on Mediterranean islands, but their earlier human use is poorly known. The islands, particularly those further from the mainland such as Crete and Cyprus, were thought to have been first colonized about 9000 years ago by late Neolithic agriculturalists with domesticated resources. Until about 20 years ago, claims of earlier, pre-Neolithic occupations on any of the islands did not stand up to critical scrutiny (1), but current investigations are challenging these perceptions. Discoveries on Cyprus, Crete, and some Ionian islands suggest seafaring abilities by pre-Neolithic peoples, perhaps extending back to Neanderthals or even earlier hominins. In Cyprus, Neolithic sites have been documented that are nearly as early as those on the mainland.

Journal information: Science

© 2012

Citation: Anthropologist suggests Mediterranean islands inhabited much earlier than thought (2012, November 16) retrieved 15 July 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Nov 16, 2012
Sea level was 120 meters lower 170,000 years ago. Maybe walked to Crete?

Nov 16, 2012
This fits in with the account found in Plato of the bellicose descendants of Atlas roaming the world at will by ship until their island nation sank 12000 years ago.

It also casts an interesting light on Theopompus Chios' account of possibly the same people who he calls the Meropi who supposedly lived on Tough Guy Island and were said to grow to twice the size of normal men suggesting they may've been close relatives or descendants of something like Homo heidelbergensis.

Nov 17, 2012
Sorry to bust bwvandorn's bubble, but a check on sea depth around Crete shows it surrounded by water from 650ft deep to over 2000 ft deep. The 'Med' is actually part of what is left of the Tethys Ocean. So no, the ancient republicans...neanderthalers...did not walk there. They built boats or rafts and likely came from Greece to the north....closest route...although once on a raft, and many rafts..and a bit of luck, someone from Egypt or Libya areas could bloody well have hit the jackpot.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more