Delhi's air as dirty as ever despite some reforms

December 16, 2011 By KATY DAIGLE , Associated Press
In this Thursday, Dec. 15, 2011 photo, India Gate, the war memorial, is seen through haze in New Delhi, India. A decade ago, plans for a metro and clean-fuel buses were hailed as New Delhi's answer to pollution. But air in the Indian capital is as dirty as ever - partly because its continued development has brought skyrocketing use of cars. (AP Photo/Saurabh Das)

(AP) -- A decade ago, plans for a metro and clean-fuel buses were hailed as New Delhi's answer to pollution. But air in the Indian capital is as dirty as ever - partly because breakneck development has brought skyrocketing use of cars.

Citywide pollution sensors routinely register levels of small airborne particles at two or sometimes three times its own sanctioned level for residential areas, putting New Delhi up with Beijing, Cairo and at the top of indexes listing the world's most-polluted capitals.

Sunrises in India's capital filter through near-opaque , scenic panoramas feature ribbons of brown air and everywhere, it seems, someone is coughing.

"My family is very worried. Earlier, the smoke and dust stayed outside, but now it comes into the house," said 61-year-old shopkeeper Hans Raj Wadhawan, a one-time smoker now being treated for at the Delhi Heart and Lung Institute.

"I can see the air is bad again, and I can feel it in my chest."

New Delhi could lay some of the blame on its own success. Its recently minted middle class adds 1,200 cars a day to the 6 million on roads already snarled with incessantly honking traffic. Generous diesel subsidies promote the use of diesel-powered SUVs that belch some of the highest levels of carcinogenic particles, thanks to their reliance on one of the dirtiest-burning fuels and low Indian .

"The city has lost nearly all of the gains it made in 2004 and 2005," said Anumita Roychowdhury, executive director of research at the Delhi-based Center for Science and Environment.

New Delhi has undergone head-spinning expansion as Indian economic reforms in the 1990s ushered in two decades of record growth. Once a manageable capital of 9.4 million where cows, bicycles and bullock carts ruled the road, New Delhi today is a gridlocked metropolis and migrant mecca now home to 16 million. Authorities have scrambled to deal with everything from rocketing real estate prices to overflowing garbage dumps.

Efforts to clean the air, it seems, have only just begun.

The capital saw some success after a 1998-2003 program removing power plants from the city center and adopting compressed natural gas, CNG, for running buses and rickshaws. The buses had run on diesel, and the rickshaws on gasoline and highly polluting kerosene. Of all possible fuels, CNG releases the smallest amounts of particulate matter.

But just a few years later pollution levels are back up, with levels of smaller than 10 micrometers - called PM10s - often near 300 per cubic meter, three times the city's legal limit of 100 - and well above the World Health Organization's recommended limit of 20.

The tiny particulate matter, sometimes called black carbon or soot, is small enough to lodge in people's lungs and fester over time. WHO says the stuff kills some 1.34 million people globally each year.

Studies on the Indian capital put the number of such deaths in the thousands.

It worsens in the dry winters, as winds die down and pollution pools over the Delhi plains. Vehicular smog mixes with smoke from festival-season fireworks as well as countless illegal pyres of garbage burned by homeless migrants to stay warm as temperatures near freezing. And the booming construction scene, free for a few months from monsoons, sends up clouds of dust.

"Our biggest challenge is the vehicles, but building roads is not the answer," Roychowdhury said. "We badly need second-generation action to restrain this increasing auto dependence."

But so far India's diesel subsidies, billed as aid for poor rural farmers who need the fuel for generators and tractors, have only boosted its market for vehicles, and the worst-polluting kind.

Diesel cars, which in 2000 accounted for 4 percent of India's market, now make up 40 of new car sales, and are soon expected to hit 50 percent.

It's an odd automotive trend for today's world. In the United States, where markets set fuel prices, the popularity of diesel is nearly naught. China taxes diesel and petrol fuels at the same rate, while neighboring Sri Lanka sets high duties on diesel cars.

Indian car owners now spend more on diesel than the agricultural sector and benefit from 100 billion rupees, or about $1.86 billion, in direct diesel subsidy, according to the Center for Science and Environment.

Environmentalists call the diesel policy an incentive to pollute. And with the capital's 16 million residents now living on some of the world's most lung-challenging air, city authorities seem to agree and say more action is needed to clean up the air.

The city recently proposed a raft of reforms to bring down PM10 levels by boosting public transportation and discouraging drivers from taking out their cars. Ideas floated include taxing diesel vehicles, increasing parking rates that are now lower than bus fares, and introducing a London-like congestion charge for driving in the city center.

Delhi also is expanding its metro, and wants to auction off its 17 bus routes to replace a chaotic system that has dozens of single owner-operators working independently - and inefficiently.

But whether the changes are made, and how effective they would be in persuading people to give up their cars, remains to be seen.

In the meantime, at least 3,000 Delhi residents will die each year from pollution-related causes, out of the city's 100,000 annual deaths, according to a recent study by The Energy Resources Institute in New Delhi and the U.S.-based health Effects Institute. Other studies have put the number of pollution-related deaths at 10,000 a year or higher.

Thousands more will develop asthma, chronic bronchitis or other respiratory ailments.

Unsurprisingly, most patients and victims live near the city's biggest roads.

"The number of respiratory diseases is definitely on the rise. Even in children we are finding more respiratory problems," said Dr. Vinod Khetarpal, president of the Delhi Medical Association. "With the introduction of CNG, it had come down quite drastically. But now it's back up again. Cars seem to be our new vice."

Explore further: Clean fuel worsens climate impacts for some vehicle engines: study


Related Stories

EPA mandates ultra-low-sulfur diesel fuel

June 5, 2006

The Environmental Agency has quietly issued a rule requiring U.S. oil refineries to produce ultra-low-sulfur diesel fuel to substantially reduce emissions.

Delhi air quality regulations improve respiratory health

April 11, 2011

Recent radical changes in air quality regulations in Delhi, India, have had a substantial positive effect on the health of city residents, according to new research co-authored by Andrew Foster, professor of economics and ...

Traffic pollution worsens symptoms in asthmatic children

November 14, 2008

Traffic pollution, especially in cities, adversely affects respiratory health in children with asthma. A study published in BioMed Central's open access journal Respiratory Research has found that in this vulnerable group, ...

Beijing launches action plan to fight pollution

April 19, 2011

Beijing -- one of the world's most polluted cities -- launched a five-year action plan on Tuesday that aims to improve the environment by phasing out coal-fired boilers and reducing bad air days.

Five myths about diesel engines

June 14, 2011

( -- Diesel engines, long confined to trucks and ships, are garnering more interest for their fuel efficiency and reduced carbon dioxide emissions, relative to gasoline engines. Argonne mechanical engineer Steve ...

Recommended for you

The world needs to rethink the value of water

November 23, 2017

Research led by Oxford University highlights the accelerating pressure on measuring, monitoring and managing water locally and globally. A new four-part framework is proposed to value water for sustainable development to ...

'Lost' 99% of ocean microplastics to be identified with dye?

November 23, 2017

The smallest microplastics in our oceans – which go largely undetected and are potentially harmful – could be more effectively identified using an innovative and inexpensive new method, developed by researchers at the ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

3 / 5 (2) Dec 16, 2011
wouldn't have anything to do with that 14% population growth rate, would it?

Why don't you Indians spit out another 150 million net increase in people over the next decade? That'd be great.

Why stop at 2.8 or children per woman?

Aim for TEN!

Ya'll can double up world population within a decade, if you hurry!

These people need their heads examined.

The U.S. population growth, as I proved to Ghost Tard the other day, is almost entirely from immigration and increases in life expectancy.

These people multiply like frogs or rodents or something, and they aren't even the bad ones! Look at all the nut-jobs ahead of them!

Iraq 4.26 per woman

Pakistan 3.5

Palestinians 5*

* They don't have any land, but all they do is lay around and fuck and ask everyone else for money...

Aghanistan 7 Wow..

No wonder there's so much pollution in India.
1 / 5 (3) Dec 16, 2011
Nano. . .overpopulation is definitely a factor, but also to the Indians, ownership and driving a car around is a "status symbol" that represents their new-found "wealth". That is their form of "keeping up with the Joneses", while ignoring each individual's role in polluting the air over New Delhi. They are impressing their friends, neighbors and strangers, who then want to own THEIR own cars so that they can show off also. It's like a kid with a new toy who will play with it for hours and days. The New Delhi city fathers should raise the price of fuel AND raise the taxes on that fuel so high so that the car owners can no longer AFFORD to use their cars. They will then have to go back to rickshaws, bicycles, mass transportation and walking. Trying to convince those people to stop driving wouldn't do any good. They are too much like children.
1 / 5 (1) Dec 16, 2011
It's true. Human nature is that people typically don't change for the good unless they're absolutely forced to do so.

Is there anything stopping the CO2 apocalypse?

And the fourth angel poured out his vial upon the sun; and power was given unto him to scorch men with fire.

And men were scorched with great heat, and blasphemed the name of God, which hath power over these plagues: and they repented not to give him glory

Like I said the other day, maybe mankind will kill himself and save God the trouble.
3 / 5 (2) Dec 16, 2011
@Nano i think islam is to blame.... have many kids and sent them to your "enemies".
not rated yet Dec 16, 2011
Pirouette, this is a great idea: "The New Delhi city fathers should raise the price of fuel AND raise the taxes on that fuel so high so that the car owners can no longer AFFORD to use their cars"

However, imagine if you tried to do that in the US or some other established country... it wouldn't last long.

They just need to stop using diesel SUVs, work on fuel economy for engines, and possibly possibly make it easier/cheaper/faster for people to take mass-transit so they make the decision for themselves, not because you are forcing them to.

And of course, what was the point of creating a larger middle-class if you just make them lower-class again.
1 / 5 (1) Dec 16, 2011
Pollution is the one form of population control that India can use without causing widespread uprisings.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.