At UN talks, Kyoto Protocol hangs in the balance

June 15, 2011 by Marlowe Hood
Protesters demonstrate against the possible end of the Kyoto Protocol during the United Nations Climate Change Conference in Copenhagen in 2009. The fate of the only international agreement that sets binding targets for curbing greenhouse gases is hanging by a thread, say veteran watchers of the UN talks unfolding here.

The fate of the only international agreement that sets binding targets for curbing greenhouse gases is hanging by a thread, say veteran watchers of the UN talks unfolding here.

Failure to prolong the Kyoto Protocol's roster of pledges beyond 2012 would mark a perilous new low for and their UN architecture, set down by the 1992 Rio summit, they say.

"The collapse of the is a plausible scenario," said Elliot Diringer, vice president of the Pew Center on , a Washington-based thinktank.

"Parties are facing a choice of limited progress or no progress. If they opt for the latter, it will leave the process in a shambles."

New talks under the UN (UNFCCC), ending in Bonn on Friday, aim at building consensus for the 194-nation forum's next high-level meeting, running November 28-December 9 in Durban, South Africa.

Agreed in skeletal form in 1997 and implemented in 2005 after agonising talks over its rulebook, Kyoto commits 37 advanced economies to trim six by an overall five percent by a 2008-2012 timeframe compared to 1990.

Overstepping a national target carries a penalty in lower emissions in the next commitment period. Any shortfall carries over to the second pledge and is multiplied by 30 percent.

Washington was one of the chief architects of the protocol but never ratified the treaty.

Former president George W. Bush said Kyoto was fatally flawed because it does not require developing giants, already major polluters, to take on similar constraints.

European countries are generally on track for their emissions reductions, but Canada is poised to miss its target by a wide margin.

At the same time, emissions by China, India, Indonesia and Brazil have rocketed -- nations bound by Kyoto account for less than 30 percent of , which hit record levels in 2010.

Even so, the protocol exerts tremendous force among poorer countries, which say it enshrines the responsibility of rich nations for unleashing the carbon demon.

"Developing countries have put a high priority on keeping Kyoto going," notes Alden Meyer of the Washington-based Union of Concerned Scientists. "It's the only agreement that does have binding commitments."

It also contains carefully-elaborated mechanisms for accounting and verification of emissions reductions that all parties agree should not be simply tossed aside.

There are broadly three possible outcomes for Kyoto, say experts.

The least plausible is that the Protocol's rich parties, the so-called Annex 1 nations, sign up for another five-year tour of duty with the same degree of legal constraints.

Japan and Russia have already bluntly said they will not do so.

At the other extreme, the threat of terminal deadlock looms larger.

"If they don't reach an agreement and the whole thing stalemates, it risks blocking progress on the other track of the negotiations," said Meyer, referring to breakthroughs made last December when ministers met in Cancun, Mexico.

These include steps toward a "green fund" for developing countries that could reach 100 billion dollars a year, a framework for monitoring national schemes to reduce emissions and transfer of clean technology.

The middle scenario is a stop-gap "political" agreement, in which there might be, for example, a three-year extension of Kyoto promises to secure deals in the other track.

But the European Union (EU) has warned tetchily that its backing for a Kyoto 2 should not be taken for granted.

"There is the impression that the EU will easily move into a second commitment period, that it is a foregone conclusion. That is not the case," Artur Runge-Metzger, the chief negotiator, said coming into the Bonn meeting.

Unless major emerging economies such as China, India and Brazil "make a gesture," the EU is unlikely to renew its Kyoto vows, said one European negotiator Tuesday, asking not be named.

"Ultimately, Kyoto is the only concrete decision that we can expect in Durban. It will be a defining event," said Laurence Tubiana, director of the Institute of Sustainable Development and International Relations (IDDRI).

Explore further: UN climate chief warns on Kyoto Protocol deadline

Related Stories

UN climate chief warns on Kyoto Protocol deadline

April 4, 2011

Commitments by most developed countries to cut carbon emissions are likely to expire at the end of next year without a new round of legally binding pledges, the UN's climate chief warned Monday.

EU sticks to 20-percent carbon cuts

October 29, 2010

The European Union on Friday gave notice it was not prepared to go beyond a planned 20-percent cut in greenhouse-gas emissions ahead of next month's UN climate talks in Cancun, Mexico.

India, China agree to cooperate on climate change

October 21, 2009

(AP) -- India and China, both major polluters and crucial players in fighting global warming, agreed Wednesday to stand together on climate change issues at a major global conference later this year.

US says it's committed to cutting greenhouse gases

August 2, 2010

(AP) -- The United States assured international negotiators Monday it remains committed to reducing carbon emissions over the next 10 years, despite the collapse of efforts to legislate a climate bill.

US in spotlight as UN climate talks resume

March 29, 2009

UN talks tasked with forging a global climate treaty by year's end were set to resume here on Sunday, with all eyes on the debut appearance of US negotiators from the administration of US President Barack Obama.

Recommended for you


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

3.7 / 5 (3) Jun 15, 2011
How dumb to talk about the 'carbon demon'. Ever heard of the carbon cycle? Without this we would not even be here, nor the rest of nature.
1 / 5 (1) Jun 16, 2011
At UN talks, Kyoto Protocol hangs in the balance

From what I've seen in the world news coverage lately, it seems more accurate to say that the Kyoto Protocol is about to hang from a noose. With the trading market essentially collapsed till at least 2020, according to the World Bank, it's essentially dead already, whether countries agree to renew it or not. That doesn't seem likely though, with so many key players having already announced intentions to withdraw at the next opportunity.

If they want to try again, then they need to start over and fix the mistakes they learned about in the first implementation. Repeating the methods that led to failure is the definition of insanity, according to some idiot I always here quoted.
1 / 5 (1) Jun 17, 2011
Wow, big scandal over at the IPCC this week. Even the big name warmists are calling for IPCC reform now. Any bets on whether Physorg will cover the biggest AGW political story of the week? They seem to have no problem covering the little story above. Nah, we aren't biased or anything, really.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.