No long-distance risks from mega-quakes: study

March 27, 2011 by Richard Ingham
A car remains stuck under the roof of a warehouse, after it was pushed there by the recent tsunami, at the port of Miyako, Iwate prefecture. Monster earthquakes like the 9.0-magnitude event that occurred off Japan on March 11 are unlikely to trigger a large quake in distant regions of the world, according to a study published on Sunday.

Monster earthquakes like the 9.0-magnitude event that occurred off Japan on March 11 are unlikely to trigger a large quake in distant regions of the world, according to a study published on Sunday.

The research -- coincidentally published in the wake of the tsunami-generating killer -- counters a novel theory that an exceptional quake in one continent can unleash a temblor in another.

Tom Parsons of the US Geological Survey (USGS) and Aaron Velasco of the University of Texas at El Paso cast their net in 30 years of data.

They looked at all earthquakes around the world that were 7.0 magnitude or above and were followed by quakes greater than magnitude 5.0.

Their trawl came up with 205 main shocks, and more than 20,000 hypothetical secondary shocks.

There was a "significant increase" in seismic activity in adjoining areas of the fault, they found.

This confirms beliefs that a big quake places stress on a nearby section of the same fault, which then ruptures, rather like buttons on a shirt that pop off one by one.

But beyond this localised knock-on effect -- which typically occurred two or three rupture lengths farther down the same fault -- there was no increase in seismic risk.

"The regional hazard of larger earthquakes is increased after a mainshock, but the global hazard is not," concludes the study, which appears in the journal Nature Geoscience.

The theory of earthquakes triggered at long distance was sketched in a 2009 paper.

It noted in particular a big change in stress in a closely monitored section in California's San Andreas fault after the 9.1 quake that struck west of Sumatra in December 2004, a whopping 8,000 kilometres (5,000 miles) away.

Parsons said that, after a very large quake, "the whole planet is an aftershock zone."

Pulses of seismic energy show up even in places such as Australia which are not quake-prone regions.

This is because surface waves from a quake are transmitted along the globe's thin crust, which effectively channels their energy around the world.

But there was no evidence that the pulse brings distant faults closer to rupture, he said in an interview with AFP.

The authors of the 2009 paper "didn't actually see a large earthquake occurring" in California after the 2004 Sumatra quake, he noted.

Parson said he monitored the March 11 event as it unfolded, but saw nothing to suggest it was badly shaking up another fault beyond its region. A strong 6.8 quake hit Myanmar on March 24, but this was most likely coincidence, he said.

"There are clusters of events that happen, then there's periods of quiet, it's just the Earth behaving as it does -- there is variability," he said.

"There might also be some causes that we don't understand. But there's nothing that leaps out about this last decade that's unusual."

Seismologists were racing to calculate the potential increase in risks to faults south of where the March 11 earthquake happened, for it includes a notorious area underlying Tokyo that caused devastation in 1923 and 1703, he added.

"There's certainly a concern. Every time you have a disturbance like this, the odds of other earthquakes are raised for a period of time. It can be decades."

Explore further: Mountain spine is a quake hotspot

Related Stories

Mountain spine is a quake hotspot

April 6, 2009

Scientists said a killer earthquake that struck central Italy on Monday occurred in a notorious trouble spot and warned further powerful shocks in the coming months could not be ruled out.

Deadly quakes are coincidence, scientists say

March 8, 2010

(AP) -- Experts say there is nothing unusual about the latest spate of earthquakes in Haiti, Chile and now Turkey, but their devastating effects illustrate how increased construction up and down the world's fault lines can ...

Earthquakes actually aftershocks of 19th century quakes

November 4, 2009

( -- When small earthquakes shake the central U.S., citizens often fear the rumbles are signs a big earthquake is coming. Fortunately, new research instead shows that most of these earthquakes are aftershocks ...

Triple whammy triggered Samoa tsunami (Update 2)

August 18, 2010

A tsunami that hit the Pacific islands of Samoa and Tonga last year was generated by three earthquakes unleashed by a seismic mechanism that has never been observed before, scientists said on Wednesday.

Recommended for you

Heavy nitrogen molecules reveal planetary-scale tug-of-war

November 17, 2017

Nature whispers its stories in a faint molecular language, and Rice University scientist Laurence Yeung and colleagues can finally tell one of those stories this week, thanks to a one-of-a-kind instrument that allowed them ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

2.6 / 5 (5) Mar 27, 2011
I am not convinced that earthquakes are so well understood as this story implies.

With kind regards,
Oliver K. Manuel
Former NASA Principal
Investigator for Apollo
not rated yet Mar 27, 2011
The static coefficient of friction is greater than the kinetic.
5 / 5 (2) Mar 27, 2011
One only has to consider the relative amplitude of the Japanese tsumami vs the one that reached the California coast to see just how much energy is dissipated through transmission. But it seems entirely pie-in-the-sky to say that it could never happen. All that appears to be lacking is just the right set of circumstances.
5 / 5 (2) Mar 27, 2011
I'll be inclined to believe this when accurate prediction exists. The credibility of those who make this claim will be significant. Until then, I see this story as a placation.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.