Having brothers delays sexual maturation in women

August 19, 2010 by Lin Edwards, Phys.org report

(PhysOrg.com) -- Scientists in Perth, Western Australia, investigating the costs of brothers and sisters in contemporary Australian society, have discovered that girls with older brothers tend to start menstruation later, and girls with younger brothers have their first sexual experiences later.

The researchers, behavioral ecologists Dr. Debra S. Judge and Fritha H. Milne, from the University of Western Australia's School of Anatomy and Human Biology, found that having brothers made no difference to fitness factors such as the number of pregnancies, or the age of the first pregnancy or the first birth. This suggests the negative effect of brothers on and activity is not associated with a fitness cost.

have known for some time that in "traditional" societies siblings in families with more sons tend to have fewer offspring, and Dr. Judge said this was thought to be because boys tended to require more resources than girls, leaving less for further children. She and Milne decided to investigate adults in a contemporary Western culture to see if the same effect was present.

They studied 197 adult women and 76 men aged 18-75, giving each participant a questionnaire about their siblings, the onset of the menarche (menstruation), and their age at their first . The questionnaire also asked questions about the number and age of their children and their age when their first child was born.

The results were that girls with older brothers (but no older ) started their periods at a mean age of 13.6 years, while those with both older brothers and older sisters began the menarche at 13.3. Girls with no older brothers (with or without older sisters) started at 12.7 years of age. The more older brothers the girl had, the older she was when she started her periods.

The age of the older brother(s) did not affect the results, which Dr. Judge said discounts any "father figure" effect. (Earlier research had found girls with an absent father tend to reach menarche earlier, which had been attributed to stress.)

The study also found that girls with one or more younger brothers experienced their first sexual activity up to two years later than girls without younger brothers. The number of boys in the family did not affect how many children their went on to have or when they gave birth to their first child.

The findings lead to more questions than answers. Dr. Judge said the later onset of menarche could be related to hormonal differences or girls being treated differently if they have an older brother, or a psychosocial process of some sort. The later start in sexual activity when girls have younger brothers could be because older girls spend more time babysitting and helping with domestic chores, leaving less opportunity and time for sexual experiences.

These results were not expected in a society where there are plenty of resources available and where adults tend to live independently of their parents for some time before starting a family. This latter fact may help explain why having had no effect on the age of first pregnancy, first birth, and the number of children. Judge said she preferred not to speculate too much as the study was very basic and straightforward, and she emphasized the delays should not necessarily be seen as negative anyway.

The paper was published in the Proceedings of the Royal Society B on August 18.

Explore further: Scent of father checks daughter’s maturity

More information: Brothers delay menarche and the onset of sexual activity in their sisters, Proceedings of the Royal Society B, Published online before print August 18, 2010, doi:10.1098/rspb.2010.1377

Related Stories

Scent of father checks daughter’s maturity

September 11, 2006

Chemical cues from fathers may be delaying the onset of sexual maturity in daughters, as part of an evolutionary strategy to prevent inbreeding, according to researchers at Penn State.

Sex, drugs and dating make teens feel older

June 18, 2007

A Canadian study has confirmed what parents have long suspected: dating, sexual activity and substance use seem to make teens feel older than they really are. And, as adolescents get older, the gap between their chronological ...

Study Suggests Why Parents Stricter With Older Children

April 16, 2008

If you think your parents let your younger siblings get away with everything, you’re probably right. A new study from researchers at Duke University, Johns Hopkins University and the University of Maryland concludes that ...

Sibling relationships reflect family dynamics

November 15, 2006

Most children in the United States grow up with sisters and brothers. Connections that usually last a lifetime, these relationships can be strained at times, especially during childhood. New research concludes that sibling ...

Recommended for you

Study sheds new light on ancient human-turkey relationship

January 17, 2018

For the first time, research has uncovered the origins of the earliest domestic turkeys in ancient Mexico. The study also suggests turkeys weren't only prized for their meat—with demand for the birds soaring with the Mayans ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

2 / 5 (3) Aug 19, 2010
Reading about the study now, astonishes me. I would have expected that this kind of knowledge would have been around for at least a century now.

Maybe this tells more about our society than siblings.
not rated yet Aug 19, 2010
Science confirming the obvious, again.
not rated yet Aug 19, 2010
I wonder if delays in girls with older brothers coming to sexual maturity could have something to do with a sort of DNA-induced primitive disincentive against incest?
not rated yet Aug 19, 2010
I wonder if delays in girls with older brothers coming to sexual maturity could have something to do with a sort of DNA-induced primitive disincentive against incest?

... or if the same mechanisms that cause females to menstruate in synch could have an effect when the female is regularly surrounded by males.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.