Points system used in football matches encourages dirty play

June 25, 2010
The points system used in football matches encourages dirty play. Credit: SINC

A study by the University of Oviedo has shown that the change in the system used to reward wins in the European leagues, going from two to three points, has led to an increase in dirty play in football matches. The researchers used the number of red cards issued in each match during the 94/95 and 95/96 seasons, when the change was made in the scoring system, as an indicator of "sabotage" in the matches.

"If football teams achieve greater relative value for winning a match, this incentive can have unanticipated and negative effects on the game, as has happened in the Spanish league", Juan Prieto, co-author of the study and a researcher at the University of Oviedo, tells SINC.

The experts compiled data on Spanish league matches during the 94/95 season (the last season in which the winning team received two points) and in 95/96 (the season when a win started to be assigned three points) using official match data, which show the number of yellow and red cards per match, as well as the minutes when these were given and information about the minutes in the match when goals are scored.

"This information allows us to monitor not only the match itself, but also the development of the game over the course of the 90 minutes of each. This allows us to find out the precise moment at which a red card was given, and also to observe whether this happened when the receiving was behind or ahead on the scoreboard, if they were losing or making a comeback", points out the expert.

The study confirms that the change in league regulations, which spread throughout almost all of the European leagues in the 1990s, led to a change in the relationship between the cost and benefit of red cards, with the modification to the number of points given for winning (which started to be worth 50% more with the change to three points) having negative effects on the form of play.

More send-offs when a team is doing well

"There was a significant change in the number of red cards given during the second season in comparison with the first. We can see there has been an increase in red cards given to teams that are winning, and this can easily be attributed to the change in the points system", the study explains.

Juan Prieto adds: "The objective was to give greater incentives for attacking play and goal-scoring, but the change has had unexpected negative effects, such as the increase in dirty play".

This kind of point system is also used in the current World Cup. "If wins are important in a league of 38 matches, with 20 teams playing, even though they account for little more than 2% of the total of the league, then they take on much greater importance in a World Cup, given that only three matches are played in the first round, meaning that drawing or winning has much more impact", the researcher concludes.

Explore further: The first goal is the deepest: Can mathematics predict the match outcome?

More information: Julio del Corral, Juan Prieto-Rodriguez and Rob Simmons 'The Effect of Incentives on Sabotage: The Case of Spanish Football', Journal of Sports Economics, 11 (3): 243-260 junio de 2010. DOI: 10.1177/1527002509340666

Related Stories

Can a formula predict the outcome of a soccer match?

March 5, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- Soccer, like most sports, is a game full of surprises and lucky or unlucky breaks. After all, if it was easy to predict the winner of a soccer match, there wouldn’t be much reason to watch it. But a team ...

Best Team Not Guaranteed World Cup Success

June 11, 2010

The World Cup offers fans of the globe's most popular sport the chance to thrill and agonize over the ups and downs of their nations' teams. For scientists, whether or not they are fans, it's another chance to collect data ...

Recommended for you

New paper answers causation conundrum

November 17, 2017

In a new paper published in a special issue of the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A, SFI Professor Jessica Flack offers a practical answer to one of the most significant, and most confused questions in evolutionary ...

Chance discovery of forgotten 1960s 'preprint' experiment

November 16, 2017

For years, scientists have complained that it can take months or even years for a scientific discovery to be published, because of the slowness of peer review. To cut through this problem, researchers in physics and mathematics ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jun 25, 2010
Is it possible the refs simply hand out more to the winning teams, to keep the game and league competative..or biased?

Its not beyond refs to disallow clear goals as we've seen in the World Cup. We also saw Denmark get a PK yesterday for a dive where the Japan guy never touched him. japan was winning, not a dirty play in the least, nor would they ever wanna be at 10 men up 2 - 0.

I think they should at least study the accuracy of the red cards given esp since they know where they occurred, and we have slow mo replay, before making final conclusions.
As with other professional sports as well, there is a desire to protect elite players. Pele used to get the crap beat out of him every game. They just didnt call it. Nowadays, you protect your Messi's and Torres' just like a qb. In essence more yellow/red cards.
Plus dives and acting have increased where as, I think teams are just as dirty as they were beforehand. Unless of course you think acting is just as dirty :)

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.