A Hazy View of Early Earth

October 12, 2009 by Anuradha K. Herath
The photochemistry of methane and carbon dioxide may have produced an organic haze layer on early Earth. Credit: NASA

Haze in the early Earth atmosphere could have played a crucial role in the origin of life. By forming a protective shield, the haze would have safeguarded organic substances from harmful ultraviolet (UV) radiation.

“Knowing more about the atmospheric conditions right before life began to develop could give researchers clues to how exactly life developed,” says H. Langley DeWitt of the Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry at the University of Colorado at Boulder.

Many scientists believe hazy conditions existed on , and DeWitt is the lead scientist of a new study investigating the effects of this haze. The paper detailing this study was published in the June edition of the journal Astrobiology.

Haze is produced when sunlight comes in contact with certain gases in the atmosphere. The types of aerosols formed through this photochemical reaction depend on the specific composition of the atmosphere.

The amount and the composition of the haze would determine whether it produced a warming or cooling effect for the planet. This new study shows that the amount of haze on early Earth was inadequate to have the type of cooling effect that scientists had previously predicted.

Tips from Titan

Scientists have looked to Titan, Saturn’s largest moon, to try to better understand the organic haze that may have existed on early Earth. Titan has a thick atmosphere containing 95 percent nitrogen, three percent methane and two percent of hydrogen and other hydrocarbons, and an atmospheric pressure about 1.6 times that of Earth. Titan is also the only other than Earth with surface liquid (on Earth that surface liquid is water, while on Titan the surface liquid is and methane.)

In a 2006 NASA study, a group of researchers that included DeWitt replicated the atmospheres of Titan and early Earth. They then compared the aerosols produced in the laboratory to the haze observed in Titan’s atmosphere during NASA’s Cassini mission. The group concluded that the two atmospheres were similar.

But there was one troubling result. An important distinction between the atmospheres of Titan and Earth is the that is present in the Earth’s atmosphere. The laboratory results in the 2006 study suggested that the reaction of carbon dioxide and methane would produce more haze on early Earth than the amount found on Titan. That implies that the Earth would have been subjected to a large anti-greenhouse or cooling effect.

The current study puts that concern to rest. DeWitt and her colleagues did additional laboratory experiments that expanded upon the 2006 study. They added hydrogen to the atmospheric composition and found that it reduced aerosol formation to the point where any potential anti-greenhouse effect would be negligible.

A colorized image of Titan’s haze taken during the Cassini mission. Credit: NASA/JPL/Space Science Institute
Mixing It Up

DeWitt’s team also looked at how varying quantities of the three main substances—hydrogen, methane and carbon dioxide—may have affected the haze that formed on Earth billions of years ago.

“Many models calculate the amount of haze that would be present at the different ratios of these chemicals,” DeWitt explains. “However, the models don’t always include experimental data in their calculations and instead use assumptions about the chemistry.”

The new study used a simplified version of an atmospheric model to examine two scenarios. One mixture contained high quantities of hydrogen and carbon dioxide with low amounts of methane. In the second simulation, the team analyzed the effects of hydrogen in a mixture that contained high amounts of methane. After the gas mixtures were exposed to UV radiation, the scientists measured the aerosols that were formed.

Their findings showed that an increase in hydrogen levels reduced the haze formation rate. They also concluded that the amount of hydrogen present in the early Earth atmosphere most likely resulted in warmer surface temperatures.

“If an organic haze did form on early Earth, the consequences of its presence beg all sorts of interesting questions,” says co-author Christa Hasenkopf of the Cooperative Institute for Research in Environmental Sciences, also at the University of Colorado at Boulder.

A question for astrobiologists is what role haze would have played in the formation of life. The scientists stated that the aerosols produced on early Earth provided a major source of organic substances to the Earth’s surface. Scientists think these organics played an important role in the origin of life on our planet. Understanding the characteristics of haze that make a planet’s surface ripe for organic material could be immensely helpful in the quest for life on other planetary bodies.

Hasenkopf says some scientists believe that the early Earth atmosphere was “virtually oxygen-free when life first formed.” That allows astrobiologists to think more broadly about what types of environments on other planets could possibly support life.

“We only know of one place in the entire universe that life was able to initially form and develop, and that was on the early Earth,” says Hasenkopf. “The climactic conditions on early Earth provide clues to our own origins.”

Calculating Climate

Scientists don’t know enough about our planet’s environment approximately four billion years ago to be able to precisely mimic the atmospheric conditions back then. The laboratory re-creation of early Earth therefore was based on many assumptions.

The study model used simplified calculations for determining surface temperature, and the chemical reactions were based on shorter reaction times than what would have occurred under actual conditions. Additionally, the researchers only focused on three gases: methane, carbon dioxide and hydrogen. While these are believed to be the major constituents of the early Earth atmosphere, there could have been other components, such as sulfur dioxide, which were not taken into account in this study. Still, DeWitt says their study could improve the accuracy of models that predict chemical reactions in the atmosphere.

Hasenkopf says the findings also can contribute to the understanding of the current effects of climate change.

Some scientists believe that the early Earth contained higher levels of carbon dioxide and methane than current atmospheric levels. Hasenkopf explains that the interaction between the gases that produce greenhouse warming and the haze that brings about the anti-greenhouse cooling is similar to the present-day emissions caused by human activity.

“On one hand, humans emit greenhouse gases, such as carbon dioxide, causing warming,” Hasenkopf says. “Yet humans also emit large amounts of particulate pollution, which may have a net cooling effect, similar to the early Earth haze.”

Source: Astrobio.net, by Anuradha K. Herath

Explore further: Early Earth haze may have spurred life, says University of Colorado study

Related Stories

Titan gives clues to Earth's early history

December 1, 2005

Readings from the Huygens probe of the surface and atmosphere around Saturn's largest moon, Titan, give researchers a peek back through time to when and how Earth's atmosphere formed, and how our primitive planet looked before ...

Origins of life

September 7, 2005

Calculations favor reducing atmosphere for early earth. Was Miller-Urey experiment correct? Using primitive meteorites called chondrites as their models, earth and planetary scientists at Washington University in St. Louis ...

Titan's Purple Haze Points to a Fuzzy Past

August 2, 2004

Encircled in purple stratospheric haze, Saturn's largest moon, Titan, appears as a softly glowing sphere in this colorized image taken on July 3, 2004, one day after Cassini's first flyby of that moon. Titan has a dense atmosphere ...

Organic Materials Spotted in Titan's Atmosphere

April 26, 2005

During its closest flyby of Saturn's moon Titan on April 16, the Cassini spacecraft came within 1,027 kilometers (638 miles) of the moon's surface and found that the outer layer of the thick, hazy atmosphere is brimming ...

Recommended for you

Scientists solve mystery shrouding oldest animal fossils

March 25, 2019

Scientists from The Australian National University (ANU) have discovered that 558 million-year-old Dickinsonia fossils do not reveal all of the features of the earliest known animals, which potentially had mouths and guts.

Earth's deep mantle flows dynamically

March 25, 2019

As ancient ocean floors plunge over 1,000 km into the Earth's deep interior, they cause hot rock in the lower mantle to flow much more dynamically than previously thought, finds a new UCL-led study.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Oct 13, 2009
Maybe Tex is thinking of going to the outer space with his aircraft.
5 / 5 (2) Oct 13, 2009
It's an interesting puzzle.

IIRC, a paper studying DNA and protein folds figured the first a good proxy for environmental temperature (by way of nucleotide ratios) in prokaryotes, and the later a reasonable proxy for environmental temperature in all cells. They got that prokaryotes all have gone through temperature bottlenecks of ~ 50-80 Celsius as imprinted in their DNA.

At the same time the oldest protein folds are optimal at ~ 20 Celsius. (I believe cell metabolism in general is optimal ~ 37 Celsius, according to Mendez models.) So at the time cells left the RNA only world and started to control amino acids as well, they were living at fairly low sea temperatures.
5 / 5 (2) Oct 13, 2009
[cont.] Yet there is this, IIRC, 2006 paper on cherts that gets similar temperature proxies by way of several isotope ratios that consistently calibrates each other. And the get Archaean temperatures starting at ~ 70-80 Celsius, dropping to something like ~ 50 Celsius before Earth oxygenation at something like 2 - 2.5 Ga. (Snowball Earth episodes were too short to show up, as I remember it.) After that Earth entered the climate regime we are used to.

Perhaps early Earth was rather nice, as early cells left their cradle and learned how to make proteins. Thereafter an extended period of a hothouse followed during which RNA was replaced by sturdier DNA, possibly punctuated by putative snowball Earth episodes. [And, seeing the above, I note that abiogenesis, or at least early evolution scenarios, are entering a predictive and testable phase. Yay!]

I can't help but to think that these haze formation models would be immensely helpful to understand the fossil record, such as it is.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.