Springs built from nanotubes could provide big power storage potential

September 21, 2009
Carol Livermore, associate professor of mechanical engineering, left, stands with graduate student Frances Hill in Livermore's lab. Photo - Patrick Gillooly

(PhysOrg.com) -- New research by MIT scientists suggests that carbon nanotubes -- tube-shaped molecules of pure carbon -- could be formed into tiny springs capable of storing as much energy, pound for pound, as state-of-the-art lithium-ion batteries, and potentially more durably and reliably.

Imagine, for example, an emergency backup or alarm system that can be left in place for many years without losing its "charge," portable mechanical tools like leaf blowers that work without the noise and fumes of small gasoline engines, or devices to be sent down oil wells or into other harsh environments where the performance of ordinary batteries would be degraded by temperature extremes. That's the kind of potential that springs could hold, according to Carol Livermore, associate professor of mechanical engineering. Carbon nanotube springs, she found, can potentially store more than a thousand times more energy for their weight than steel springs.

Two papers describing Livermore and her team's findings on in carbon nanotube springs have just been published. A paper describing a theoretical analysis of the springs' potential, co-authored by Livermore, graduate student Frances Hill and Timothy Havel SM ’07, appeared in June in the . Another paper, by Livermore, Hill, Havel and A. John Hart SM ’02, PhD ’06, now a professor at the University of Michigan, describing laboratory tests that demonstrate that nanotubes really can exceed the energy storage potential of steel, appears in the September issue of the Journal of Micromechanics and Microengineering.

Theoretical analysis shows the carbon nanotube springs could ultimately have an energy density — a measure of the amount of energy that can be stored in a given weight of material — more than 1,000 times that of steel springs, and comparable to that of the best lithium-ion batteries.

With a snap or a tick-tock

For some applications, springs can have advantages over other ways of storing energy, Livermore explains. Unlike batteries, for example, springs can deliver the stored energy effectively either in a rapid, intense burst, or slowly and steadily over a long period — as exemplified by the difference between the spring in a mousetrap or in a windup clock. Also, unlike batteries, stored energy in springs normally doesn't slowly leak away over time; a mousetrap can remain poised to snap for years without dissipating any of its energy.

For that reason, such systems might lend themselves to applications for emergency backup systems. With batteries, such devices need to be tested frequently to make sure they still have full power, and replace or recharge the batteries when they run down, but with a spring-based system, in principle "you could stick it on the wall and forget it," Livermore says.

Livermore says that the springs made from these minuscule tubes might find their first uses in large devices rather than in micro-electromechanical devices. For one thing, the best uses of such springs may be in cases where the energy is stored mechanically and then used to drive a mechanical load, rather than converting it to electricity first.

Any system that requires conversion from mechanical energy to electrical and back again, using a generator and then a motor, will lose some of its energy in the process through friction and other processes that produce waste heat. For example, a regenerative braking system that stores energy as a bicycle coasts downhill and then releases that energy to boost power while going uphill might be more efficient if it stores and releases its energy from a spring instead of an electrical system, she says. In addition to the direct energy losses, about half the weight of such electromechanical systems currently is in the motor-generator used for the conversion — something that wouldn't be needed in a purely mechanical system.

One reason the microscopic tubes lend themselves to being made into longer fibers that can make effective springs is that the nanotube molecules themselves have a strong tendency to stick to each other. That makes it relatively easy to spin them into long fibers — much as strands of wool can be spun into yarn — and this is something many researchers around the world are working on. "In fact," Livermore says, the fibers are so sticky that "we had some comical moments when you're trying to get them off your tweezers." But that quality means that ultimately it may be possible to "make something that looks like a carbon nanotube and is as long as you want it to be."

Tough and long-lasting

Carbon nanotube springs also have the advantage that they are relatively unaffected by differences in temperature and other environmental factors, whereas batteries need to be optimized for a particular set of conditions, usually to operate at normal room temperature. Nanotube springs might thus find applications in extreme conditions, such as for devices to be used in an oil borehole subjected to high temperature and pressure, or on space vehicles where temperature can fluctuate between extreme heat and extreme cold.

"They should also be able to charge and recharge many times without a loss of performance," Livermore says, although the actual performance over time still needs to be tested.

Livermore says that to create devices that come close to achieving the theoretically possible high energy density of the material will require plenty of additional basic research, followed by engineering work. Among other things, the initial lab tests used fibers of carbon nanotubes joined in parallel, but creating a practical energy storage device will require assembling nanotubes into longer and likely thicker fibers without losing their key advantages.

"These scaled-up springs need to be large (i.e., incorporating many carbon nanotubes), but those individual carbon nanotubes need to work well enough together in the overall assembly of tubes for it to have comparable properties to the individual tubes," Livermore says. "This is not easy to do."

Rod Ruoff, professor of mechanical engineering at the University of Texas, adds that while the theoretical energy density of such systems is high, present ways of making carbon nanotubes are limited in their ability to produce highly concentrated bundles, and so "It appears to me that the 'low hanging fruit' here is to find important applications where the energy density on per weight basis outweighs the on a per volume basis." But, he adds, if Livermore and her team are able to produce denser bundles of carbon nanotubes, "then there are exciting possibilities for mechanical storage" with such systems.

The group has already filed for a patent on the technology.

Provided by Massachusetts Institute of Technology (news : web)

Explore further: Engineers Create Super Compressible Carbon Nanotube Foam-like Films

Related Stories

High Power Supercapacitors From Carbon Nanotubes

February 15, 2005

Supercapacitors that can deliver a strong surge of electrical power could be manufactured from carbon nanotubes using a technique developed by researchers at UC Davis. Supercapacitors are electrical storage devices that can ...

Nanoscientists fired up about battery alternative

February 8, 2006

Just about everything that runs on batteries - flashlights, cell phones, electric cars, missile-guidance systems - would be improved with a better energy supply. But traditional batteries haven't progressed far beyond the ...

Water inside single-walled carbon nanotubes

June 25, 2008

Researchers have identified a signature for water inside single-walled carbon nanotubes, helping them understand how water is structured and how it moves within these tiny channels.

Clemson scientists put a (nano) spring in their step

August 13, 2008

Electronic devices get smaller and more complex every year. It turns out that fragility is the price for miniaturization, especially when it comes to small devices, such as cell phones, hitting the floor. Wouldn't it be great ...

Nano World: Carbon nanotube capacitors

February 3, 2006

Carbon nanotubes could help release and hold electrical energy, for potential use in everything from microchips to hybrid cars, experts told UPI's Nano World.

Recommended for you

Breakthrough in ultra-fast data processing at nanoscale

October 20, 2017

A research team from the National University of Singapore has recently invented a novel "converter" that can harness the speed and small size of plasmons for high frequency data processing and transmission in nanoelectronics.

Art advancing science at the nanoscale

October 18, 2017

Like many other scientists, Don Ingber, M.D., Ph.D., the Founding Director of the Wyss Institute, is concerned that non-scientists have become skeptical and even fearful of his field at a time when technology can offer solutions ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Sep 21, 2009
Carbon nano tubes. Is there anything they can't do??
1 / 5 (1) Sep 21, 2009
carbon nanotubes -- these things fix everything -- next thing you know if you add carbon nanotubes to skin cells they will make stem cells automatically -- jk jk
5 / 5 (1) Sep 21, 2009
I'll be jumping like the hulk on nanospring boots.

Once they find a way to grow carbon tubes and sheets in large sizes nothing short of a second industrial revolution will happen and a whole bunch of metal plastics and poisenous organics will be replaced in all kinds of fields and far fetched fantasies like spaceelevator cable seem within grap
5 / 5 (1) Sep 21, 2009
the hard part will be making little carbon nanotube keys to wind them up
not rated yet Sep 21, 2009

more than 1,000 times that of steel springs, and comparable to that of the best lithium-ion batteries

Darn. The best Li-ion batteries have an energy 10x too low for practical transportation. Ability to make longer fiber braids is interesting however.
not rated yet Sep 22, 2009
There's a new battery technology every other month.
not rated yet Sep 22, 2009
Rubber has up to ten times the energy per unit weight as steel. But uses of rubber for energy storage are limited except in tires and golf balls, where energy storage and release are nearly instantaneous. One exception is the use of rubber bands to power model airplanes. Even there, lithium-ion batteries are better.
The problem with using springs for long term energy storage is in controlling the release of this energy. Using brakes will cause half of the energy to be lost (inelastic collision). A good infinitely variable transmission is what is needed.
Sep 22, 2009
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
1 / 5 (1) Sep 22, 2009
I was disappointed to read that they were only comparable with the best lithium batteries. That's not to say that there are not some major advantages to this approach but it's an alternative - not a revolution. Maybe we will be fortunate and find another new matterial for making springs which can store even more energy and is made of easily acquired elements.
1 / 5 (1) Sep 22, 2009
Wait, the article mentions the theoretical energy storage - energy per unit of weight - as comparable to the best lithium batteries but I'm a little unsure as to the energy per volume comparison. If they took up less volume for the same weight it would still be an improvement for stationary robots and home power storage application right? They'd be heavier but take up less room or the same room with more capacity.
not rated yet Sep 26, 2009
i wonder how well silicon/germanium hybrid nanocoils would do in piezoceramic wafers

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.