Intel project seeks to mark disputed Web information

July 22, 2009 By Nicholas Diakopoulos

Do Eskimos have more words for "snow" than we do? You're probably not alone if you thought the answer was yes.

Truth is, this is one of those pesky urban myths -- like the untrue predictions of a moon-sized Mars in August -- that just won't fade from the popular mindset.

Such legends can spread quickly on the Internet, so at Research in Berkeley, Calif., are developing new technologies to filter and measure disputed information online.

The software is called Dispute Finder and is the project of Rob Ennals, a research scientist at the Intel lab.

Think of it this way: Every time you visit a Web site, any statement on that page will be highlighted if someone else has marked it as disputed. If you click the highlight, you can see what evidence people have used to dispute the statement.

"Disputed does not mean wrong, it just means that there's some credible people that disagree with it," Ennals said. Objectivity, then, is not paramount -- just contention.

The software makes use of a small number of highly motivated users to mark statements on Web pages as disputed while they're reading. These demarcations are then syndicated out to the broader array of more passive .

The traditional way of dealing with questionable information would be to rely on experts like Conrad Jung, an astronomer at the Chabot Observatory in Oakland, Calif. He reports receiving calls about a persistent chain letter claiming that Mars will reach its closest point to Earth in August.

The chain letter -- it's not dated but has been traced back to 2003 -- is not outright false. It's just been misread as a prediction that Mars will be the same size as the moon in the August night sky.

That's not true, Jung said.

And in politics -- where statements often become contentious -- the Pulitzer Prize-winning Web site has journalists rating statements against a "truth-o-meter."

President Barack Obama's recent statement, "Californians consume 40 percent less energy per person than the national average," was rated "Mostly True" on the site, based on an analysis of California's electricity and energy usage as compared to national averages. (It turns out they use 40 percent less electricity, but only 30 percent less energy overall.)

Now imagine if, while you surfed the Web, you had a thousand little Conrad Jungs in your computer, whispering, "Hey, watch out, that might not be true." That's what Dispute Finder promises.

In the future, Ennals said, he'd like to develop Dispute Finder to also work with TV closed captions and, ultimately, with those persistent chain e-mails.


(c) 2009, San Jose Mercury News (San Jose, Calif.).
Visit, the World Wide of the Mercury News, at
Distributed by McClatchy-Tribune Information Services.

Explore further: A glimpse at Intel's futuristic gadgets

Related Stories

A glimpse at Intel's futuristic gadgets

July 1, 2009

Wouldn't it be useful to have a gadget that immediately warned you when the information you just saw on the Internet or heard from a buddy might be baloney?

Celebrate the centennial of historic radio broadcasts

February 5, 2009

Charles Herrold isn't going to be forgotten this year. What do you mean, "Who's Charles Herrold?" This is just the sort of thing San Jose, Calif., boosters and radio fans - two in particular - have been fighting against ...

Google to add maps of local findings to search results

April 8, 2009

Google has confirmed that it is going to start adding a map of local findings to search results for things like "pizza," "burger" and "dentist," something that Google watchers have been buzzing about for months.

Recommended for you

Finnish firm detects new Intel security flaw

January 12, 2018

A new security flaw has been found in Intel hardware which could enable hackers to access corporate laptops remotely, Finnish cybersecurity specialist F-Secure said on Friday.

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jul 23, 2009
I don't know if Eskimos have more words for "snow" than we do, but we sure have more words for "tree" than they do.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.