Extent of inbreeding in pedigree dogs revealed in new study

August 15, 2008,
Extent of inbreeding in pedigree dogs revealed in new study
German shepherd dogs are prone to an abnormal development of the hip joints.

The extent of inbreeding in purebred dogs and how this reduces their genetic variation is revealed in a new study by Imperial College London researchers. Inbreeding puts dogs at risk of birth defects and genetically inherited health problems.

These issues and the researchers' findings are highlighted in an upcoming TV programme entitled "Pedigree dogs exposed," which will air on BBC One on Tuesday 19 August 2008 at 21.00 BST.

Particular dog breeds are believed to be prone to particular health problems and birth defects. For example, Dalmation dogs are predisposed to deafness, many Boxer dogs have problems with heart disease, and disproportionate numbers of German Shepherd dogs have an abnormal developmentof the hip joints known as hip dysplasia.

Inbreeding in pedigree dogs arises because certain dogs, prized for exhibiting the characteristics desirable for that breed, are used to father many litters of puppies. When dogs from these litters come to be mated, some will be paired with dogs having the same father from other litters. Over generations, more and more dogs across a particular pedigree are related to one another and the chances of relatives mating increase.

Recessive genetic variants only have adverse health effects such as deafness when an individual carries two defective copies of the gene. If a popular sire carries just one defective copy, he will not show the problem himself and nor will his puppies. However, the defect may become common in later generations if his grandpuppies and great grandpuppies are mated with each other, rather than introducing new genetic traits by breeding outside their relatives.

Although the problems associated with inbreeding have been known for many years, prior to the new study it had not been systematically measured. For this study, researchers from Imperial used mathematical modelling to analyse how dogs were related to one another within ten different dog breeds including the Boxer and Rough Collie.

They looked at the parentage of eight generations of dogs, using records collected from 1970 to the present day by the UK Kennel Club.

The researchers' analysis showed that, for example, Boxer dogs were so closely related to one another and had such little genetic variation between them that genetically, 20,000 dogs looked like a population of about 70. In the Rough Collie breed, 12,000 dogs looked in genetic terms like a population of about 50.

Such small effective population sizes mean that the chances of a dog breeding with a close relative, resulting in birth defects and genetically inherited health problems, are high. The researchers argue that those involved in breeding dogs should encourage breeding from a larger pool of potential mates in order to create greater genetic variation and lessen dogs' chances of inheriting genetic disorders. They suggest measures such as limiting how many times a popular dog can father litters; encouraging mating across national and continental boundaries; and relaxing breed rules to permit breeding outside the pedigree.

Professor David Balding, the corresponding author of the research from the Division of Epidemiology, Public Health and Primary Care at Imperial College London, said: "The idea that inbreeding causes health problems in particular dog breeds is not a new one, but we believe ours is the first scientific study to explore this issue and analyse the extent of inbreeding in a systematic way, across many breeds. We hope that following our work, dog breeders will make it a high priority to increase the genetic diversity within different breeds. Otherwise, we will see growing numbers of dogs born with serious genetically inherited health problems."

The researchers carried out their analysis as part of an effort to explore how understanding disease in dogs can help inform research into human disease. The research was funded by the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council.

Further information about the research is provided in the study, which is published in the journal Genetics: "Population structure and inbreeding from pedigree analysis of purebred dogs," Genetics, 179(1): 593–601, 2008. doi:10.1534/genetics.107.084954 Calboli FC , Sampson J, Fretwell N, Balding DJ

Provided by Imperial College London

Explore further: How serious is inbreeding in show dogs?

Related Stories

How serious is inbreeding in show dogs?

March 18, 2016

A German shepherd with a sloping back that was awarded best of breed brought the dog show Crufts in for this year's annual bout of criticism. Viewers took to social media to accuse the owner of animal cruelty by suggesting ...

Golden retrievers help scientists track human disease genes

January 31, 2012

A team of EU-funded researchers has successfully identified a gene that triggers a skin disorder in dogs - and the findings could have implications for humans who also suffer from the condition. Whether it manifests in golden ...

Inbreeding taking toll on Michigan wolves

April 4, 2009

(AP) -- The two dozen or so gray wolves that wander an island chain in northwestern Lake Superior are suffering from backbone malformations caused by genetic inbreeding, posing yet another challenge to their prospects for ...

Recommended for you

How our plants have turned into thieves to survive

February 18, 2019

Scientists have discovered that grasses are able to short cut evolution by taking genes from their neighbours. The findings suggest wild grasses are naturally genetically modifying themselves to gain a competitive advantage.

Great white shark genome decoded

February 18, 2019

The great white shark is one of the most recognized marine creatures on Earth, generating widespread public fascination and media attention, including spawning one of the most successful movies in Hollywood history. This ...

Light-based production of drug-discovery molecules

February 18, 2019

Photoelectrochemical (PEC) cells are widely studied for the conversion of solar energy into chemical fuels. They use photocathodes and photoanodes to "split" water into hydrogen and oxygen respectively. PEC cells can work ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (1) Aug 15, 2008
This 'recapitulation' of the
ancient lore of "Inbreeding is
Bad" is misleading. Yes, of
course, if breeder's mate
defective (typically recessive)
pairs the odds of unhealthy
offspring are increased. This
is not a consequence of 'inbreeding'
per se, but the consequence of
'stupid inbreeding'. Surely it
can not be a challenging thought t
that GOOD qualities are equally
capable of being transferred to
progeny!!!! Historiclly, it has
been various churches which have
promulgated these mis-conceptions.
And it has not been unusual that
'scientists' have 'walked this
5 / 5 (1) Aug 16, 2008
" Surely it
can not be a challenging thought t
that GOOD qualities are equally
capable of being transferred to
Correct, one problem in your line of reasoning is that the good qualities are mostly correct stance of the left ear. Or a white patch of hair under the right nostril.
The bad quality's were talking about are a mostly a lot worse: blind/deaf/hip dysplacy etc. etc. The ods of getting the good or the bad qualitys are as big. Even with smart inbreeding.
Not one sane dog owner wants to have his dog go trough that shit. And if you are willing to take that risk with your puppys I think you should be allowed to own pets.
not rated yet Aug 16, 2008
Perhaps i was not so clear: i
meant to note that 'inbreeding'
can be beneficial or detrimental,
and meant it in the most general
sense. I agree, breeding for a
white earspot would seem pointless
and hardly likely to benefit the ani
animal, canine or primate. As
a past breeder of Afghan Hounds,
i am too familiar with the
consequences of 'stupid breeding':
: todays Afghan would have great d
difficulty even surviving a week
in the wild, so detrimental is
his long coat: entangled in a
bush, he'd die within days.. The s
source of this honorable breed
was very short-haired. This is
'stupid breeding par excellance''

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.