Physicists investigate 'best friends forever'

April 22, 2008 by Lisa Zyga weblog
Cell phone network
A network model created with data from the study: blue nodes are males, pink nodes are females, and gray nodes are unknown gender. The node size is proportional to the age of the phone user, and the color and width of the links grows with persistence. Image credit: Cesar Hidalgo and Carlos Rodriguez-Sickert.

Some friendships are short and fleeting, while others may last years. Although a wide variety of factors go into determining the strength of our relationships, the long-lasting ones seem to share a number of the same characteristics, according to a recent study.

Using data from nearly 2 million people and 8 million phone calls over the course of a year, physicist Cesar Hidalgo from the University of Notre Dame and sociologist Carlos Rodriguez-Sickert from the Pontifical Catholic University of Chile have investigated the persistence of relationships within the cell phone network. Somewhat intuitively, they found that the leading cause of persistent relationships is reciprocity - returning a friend´s call. Further, they could use these characteristics to predict the nature of relationships in the future.

As the researchers explain in their study, the persistence of the connection between two individuals is a measurement of how often they call each other. The scientists analyzed 15-day intervals, and determined if the two callers made contact within each interval. The greater number of these chunks of time in which contact occurred, the higher the pair´s persistence value was.

The scientists found that the majority (60%) of ties between two callers lasted for just one 15-day interval. The next 20% of ties disappeared slowly throughout the course of the year, and the remaining 20% persisted for the entire one-year period.

The results showed that the strongest factor determining persistence values was when individuals returned calls to each other. When links were reciprocated, those links had a greater chance of persisting for longer time periods. Also, when an individual´s connections had connections among themselves (when a person´s friends knew each other), his or her own connections lasted longer. The results also revealed insight into "social butterflies" - individuals with a high number of links.

"One result that I thought was somehow not so intuitive was the trade-off between the degree (number of links) of a person and the persistence of its ties," Hidalgo told "It has been known for a long time that some people are much more connected than others, yet it was not known whether these highly connected individuals also had a larger number of strong connections. While time constraints may force people with more ties to be less persistent on average, the data also showed that, in absolute terms, people with more ties also have a greater number of persistent ties than those less connected. Highly connected individuals are not trading quality for quantity; rather, they appear to be more socially expressed in both the numbers of links and the persistence or strength of them."

By knowing the characteristics of persistence, the researchers could look at the features of the network for the first 15 days, and predict what the network would look like in the future. Since social connections play a role in areas such as collective decision making and consumption, predicting these connections might help researchers predict some of society´s actions. For example, measuring the persistence of a person´s social ties might open a new dimension for marketing segmentation strategies.

"One area which is interested in new ways of characterizing individuals is marketing," Hidalgo said. "To more effectively market their products, companies have traditionally segmented the targeted population by age, gender, ethnicities and socioeconomic status. As data on the social structure becomes increasingly available, it becomes possible for companies to categorize people based on their local structure on the social network.

"This opens a new layer of information that cannot be accessed otherwise. The social structure surrounding an individual is likely the result of its behavior and personality, hence is likely to carry more relevant information than its age and gender. The persistence of a person´s social relationships is a dynamical measure that can be used to tell us how strongly a person is connected to its peers. It could indicate a level of respect or authority that cannot be captured by purely structural measures, such as the number of links or the density of its social structure."

More information: Hidalgo, Cesar A. and Rodriguez-Sickert, C. "The dynamics of a mobile phone network." Physica A 387 (2008) 3017-3024.

Explore further: Providing healthcare for non-US citizens a 'moral obligation,' professors say

Related Stories

Strong neighborhood ties can help reduce gun violence

December 22, 2014

The bonds that tie a neighborhood together can help shield community members from gun violence, according to new findings by Yale School of Medicine researchers in the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Clinical Scholars Program ...

Social networks may inflate self-esteem, reduce self-control

January 14, 2013

Users of Facebook and other social networks should beware of allowing their self-esteem—boosted by "likes" or positive comments from close friends—to influence their behavior: It could reduce their self-control both on ...

Recommended for you

Inventing a new kind of matter

March 24, 2017

Imagine a liquid that could move on its own. No need for human effort or the pull of gravity. You could put it in a container flat on a table, not touch it in any way, and it would still flow.

In a quantum race everyone is both a winner and a loser

March 24, 2017

Our understanding of the world is mostly built on basic perceptions, such as that events follow each other in a well-defined order. Such definite orders are required in the macroscopic world, for which the laws of classical ...

Physicist develops drip-free wine bottle

March 23, 2017

Drips are the bane of every wine drinker's existence. He or she uncorks a bottle of wine, tips it toward the glass, and a drop, or even a stream, runs down the side of the bottle. Sure, you could do what sommeliers in restaurants ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (3) Apr 22, 2008
Is this the same device used to map sex activity of school children?
2 / 5 (3) Apr 22, 2008
Phone usage? That is so 90's. Maybe if they had tracked e-mails, instead.
4.5 / 5 (2) Apr 22, 2008
There are several advantages of measuring the layer of the social network defined by Mobile Phones, such as the larger market share of mobile phones compared to emails, the more personal nature of the communication: as mobile phone numbers are unlisted, just having them indicates a sort of social connection, plus no Spam and not nearly as many multiple accounts that as in emails, among other arguments that can be found on the original paper.
5 / 5 (1) Apr 22, 2008
How did they discern social interactions from business interactions?
5 / 5 (1) Apr 23, 2008
Superhuman: Kudos.

Logic would dictate that if you don't communicate with someone they aren't your friend. 100% of people I never talk to aren't my friends, and if I constantly don't call someone back, eventually communications cease, but that's just me.
1 / 5 (1) Oct 21, 2008

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.