Computing a way through the Turing barrier

February 22, 2005

Mathematicians working in an emerging field somewhere between physics, computer science and philosophy are investigating new ways of ‘computing the incomputable’ which could radically broaden our understanding of the world. Pure mathematics professor Barry Cooper is leading a European network into a world of ‘unsolvable’ problems.

His goal – to find ways of mathematically modelling how the universe computes – is a task which increasingly engages the world’s most sophisticated logical minds. While the next generation of computers may boost the power of calculation ten or even a hundred-fold, there will still be many complex scientific questions they cannot resolve.

No one has yet managed to model computably the confusing mix of irrefutable laws and chaotic events which seem to govern nature, making, for example, weather patterns so difficult to predict. “Our notion of a mechanical universe governed by the laws of nature does not sit easily with the apparent randomness which we now know forms an important element of subatomic phenomena,” Professor Cooper said. “What I am asking is how can we make a computer model for what is happening which somehow takes account of the incomputability in nature.”

A new paradigm of computation is being sought by academics working in the field of incomputability with the aim of breaking through the ‘Turing barrier’, named after Alan Turing, the founding father of computing.

By returning to the roots of what mathematics can and cannot prove, Turing demonstrated that there are apparently some problems no present-day computer could ever solve – seemingly random events taking place in the real world which cannot be predicted. So the Turing barrier is a line in the sand, where problems are divided into those which are computable and those which aren’t, and has placed a limit on scientific work completed ever since.

Simple entities operating in an environment can form more complex behaviours as a collective, an occurrence known as ‘emergence’. A good example of this is the stock market, where the individual work of each broker combines to form the complexity of the stock market as a whole. Weather phenomena such as hurricanes are emergent properties, as is life itself. In a year which opened with such terrible scenes in south Asia, our inability to predict natural phenomena has never seemed so relevant.

Academics across Europe have been working on new models of computation for some time within their own field, coming at the subject from very different angles. To encourage collaboration and drive theories forward, Professor Cooper has formed the Computability in Europe network. Its first major event is a conference this June, bringing together mathematicians, computer scientists, physicists and philosophers with the common aim of ‘knowing the unknowable’.

“There is plenty of computability – and incomputability – theory happening, but researchers have until now tended to work in isolation,” Professor Cooper added. “I wanted to make this community of researchers a reality, where a five-minute chat over coffee could set off a whole new train of ideas.”

Professor Cooper and colleagues in the network are applying for a Marie Curie grant of around £1.75m to support Computability in Europe over the next four years. The money would be spent on finding the new computability stars of tomorrow – funding for new research students and training, as well as networking/workshops and a major conference each year.

But could the Turing barrier be eventually breached? One popular suggestion is to focus on the area of quantum computers, although these are currently more about achieving greater efficiency. Today’s computers are not far removed from Turing’s original machine of the 1930s. Although they have become faster and smaller, they still work with ‘bits’ represented as a 1 or a 0. However, research is now being conducted into new ‘quantum’ computers, which work with quantum bits represented by a 1 or a 0 , both a 1 and 0 or somewhere in between. This gives quantum computers the potential to be more powerful and millions of times faster than today’s computers.

These computers could have life-changing results. On a basic level they could be used to decode encrypted information almost instantly. Information transported over the internet could be easily manipulated by hackers able to break the encryption in seconds. More positively, they could allow us to predict the weather months in advance, by analysing its complex, seemingly random, behaviour. They could have economic applications, giving us more predictive power over the global economy. In short, they could change the world.

“The computer revolution made a huge difference to everyday life. In breaking the Turing barrier, our knowledge of the world, and therefore our control of it, would be altered forever,” Professor Cooper added.

Explore further: Move over, Turing Test. Winograd Schema Challenge in town

Related Stories

Move over, Turing Test. Winograd Schema Challenge in town

August 14, 2014

Isn't there something better than the Turing test to measure computer intelligence? Is the Turing Test the best we have to judge a machine's capability to produce behavior that requires human thought? Doubt was expressed ...

Mathematician sees artistic side to father of computer

February 23, 2012

This year a series of events around the world will celebrate the work of Alan Turing, the father of the modern computer, as the 100th anniversary of his birthday approaches on June 23. In a book chapter that will be published ...

Science world commemorates father of computer science

June 20, 2012

Scientists will gather from Bangalore to Texas on Saturday to honour British mathematician Alan Turing, a pioneer of the modern computer whose code-cracking is credited with shortening World War II.

UK finally pardons computer pioneer Alan Turing

December 23, 2013

His code breaking prowess helped the Allies outfox the Nazis, his theories laid the foundation for the computer age, and his work on artificial intelligence still informs the debate over whether machines can think.

First digital music made in Manchester

June 18, 2008

Computer scientists and engineers at The University of Manchester took part in the first ever recording of digital music in the early 1950s, it has been revealed.

Recommended for you

Cheap, sustainable battery made from tree bark tannins

December 18, 2017

(—Tannins may be best known for their presence in red wine and tea, but in a new study researchers have demonstrated for the first time that tannins from tree bark can also serve as battery cathode materials. As ...

Nanotubes go with the flow to penetrate brain tissue

December 18, 2017

Rice University researchers have invented a device that uses fast-moving fluids to insert flexible, conductive carbon nanotube fibers into the brain, where they can help record the actions of neurons.

How fungi helped create life as we know it

December 18, 2017

Today our world is visually dominated by animals and plants, but this world would not have been possible without fungi, say University of Leeds scientists.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.