Mixed-handed children more likely to have mental health, language and scholastic problems

Jan 25, 2010

Children who are mixed-handed, or ambidextrous, are more likely to have mental health, language and scholastic problems in childhood than right- or left-handed children, according to a new study published today in the journal Pediatrics.

The researchers behind the study, from Imperial College London and other European institutions, suggest that their findings may help teachers and health professionals to identify who are particularly at risk of developing certain problems.

Around one in every 100 people is mixed-handed. The study looked at nearly 8,000 children, 87 of whom were mixed-handed, and found that mixed-handed 7 and 8-year old children were twice as likely as their right-handed peers to have difficulties with language and to perform poorly in school.

When they reached 15 or 16, mixed-handed adolescents were also at twice the risk of having symptoms of attention deficit/ disorder (). They were also likely to have more severe symptoms of ADHD than their right-handed counterparts. It is estimated that ADHD affects between 3 to 9 percent of school-aged children and young people.

The adolescents also reported having greater difficulties with language than those who were left- or right-handed. This is in line with earlier studies that have linked mixed-handedness with .

Little is known about what makes people mixed-handed but it is known that handedness is linked to the hemispheres in the brain. Previous research has shown that where a person's natural preference is for using their right hand, the left hemisphere of their brain is more dominant.

Some researchers have suggested that mixed-handedness indicates that the pattern of dominance is not that which is typically seen in most people, i.e. it is less clear that one hemisphere is dominant over the other. One study has suggested that ADHD is linked to having a weaker function in the right hemisphere of the brain, which could help explain why some of the mixed-handed students in today's study had symptoms of ADHD.

Dr Alina Rodriguez, the lead researcher on the study from the School of Public Health at Imperial College London, said: "Mixed-handedness is intriguing - we don't know why some people prefer to make use of both hands when most people use only one. Our study is interesting because it suggests that some children who are mixed handed experience greater difficulties in school than their left- and right-handed friends. We think that there are differences in the brain that might explain these difficulties, but there needs to be more research.

"Because mixed-handedness is such a rare condition, the number of mixed-handed children we were able to study was relatively small, but our results are statistically and clinically significant. That said, our results should not be taken to mean that all children who are mixed-handed will have problems at school or develop ADHD. We found that mixed-handed children and adolescents were at a higher risk of having certain problems, but we'd like to stress that most of the mixed-handed children we followed didn't have any of these difficulties," added Dr Rodriguez.

To study the effects of mixed-handedness, Dr Rodriguez and her colleagues looked at prospective data from a cohort of 7,871 children from Northern Finland. Using questionnaires, the researchers assessed the children when they reached 7 to 8 years of age and again at 15 to 16 years of age.

When the children were aged 8, the researchers asked parents and teachers to assess their linguistic abilities, scholastic performance and behaviour. The teachers reported whether children had difficulties in reading, writing or mathematics and rated the children's academic performance as below average, average or above average.

The adolescents' parents and the themselves completed follow-up questionnaires when they were 15-16 years of age, with the children evaluating their school performance in relation to their peers and the parents assessing their children's behaviour, on a questionnaire that is widely used to identify ADHD symptoms.

Explore further: Experts question value of common superbug control practices

More information: “Mixed-Handedness Is Linked to Mental Health Problems in Children and Adolescents,” Pediatrics, Monday 25 January 2010

Related Stories

Hyperactive students mature later

Nov 13, 2007

Although the brains of children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder develop more slowly than those of other children, they catch up, a new study says.

Study links ADHD with sleep problems in adolescents

May 01, 2009

A study in the May 1 issue of the journal SLEEP shows that adolescents with a childhood diagnosis of Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) are more likely to have current and lifetime sleep problems and disorders, regard ...

Recommended for you

New analysis questions use of acute hemodialysis treatment

7 hours ago

A common approach to treating kidney failure by removing waste products from the blood did not improve survival chances for people who suddenly developed the condition, in an analysis led by experts at the University of Pittsburgh ...

User comments : 5

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Smellyhat
1 / 5 (1) Jan 25, 2010
Okay, this is a new low, with respect to titles. "Mixed-handed"? We can no longer expect people to know what 'ambidextrous' means, so we'll use a clumsy and poorly descriptive word that is even more confusing than not knowing what 'ambidextrous' meant?

This is a website about new developments and ideas in science. There's little sense in catering to some hypothetical person who might be unable or unwilling to learn a common word.
evod
not rated yet Jan 25, 2010
Smelly, 'ambidextrous' and 'mixed-handed' mean different things -- they aren't interchangeable. If you can spend two minutes to do a google search, you'll see that this is not journalistic caprice, but a deliberately chosen word taken from the research literature.
CarolinaScotsman
not rated yet Jan 25, 2010
I have what is called mixed specific dominance (also known as cross dominance). In other words, which hand I use depends on the specific task being performed. I can do some things right handed but not left handed and some things left handed but not right. People with this form of handedness comprise much less than 1% of the population. I would be interested to know if any similar studies have been done for mixed specific dominance.
Caliban
1 / 5 (2) Jan 26, 2010
From a quick search, my reading of the "literature" indicates that Mixed Dominance is the umbrella term for all the Non-dominant(left- or right-handedness) scenarios. Ambidexterity is a subset of the Mixed Dominance group. Mixed Dominance also correlates with early onset schizoprenia!
Sadly, given the well-known bias for right-handedness- which is frequently forced upon children who don't conform to this bias, it seems like poor science to me to take this attribute(which is probably just an expression of natural variability), and claim causation, as opposed to correlation. A kid may very well be under considerable pressure from school, family and civilization itself to conform to right-handedness, or, at the very least, left-handedness.
The pressure to conform can do terrible things to people.
dsl5000
not rated yet Jan 26, 2010
Oh I didn't know there was a name for mixed specific dominance :P I have that! I write and eat with my left but i throw with my right, play pool with left, bat with right, play ping-pong with left and punch with right (although my left arm is stronger) haha.

Best part of being a lefty is that I can use my computer mouse with my right hand and scroll around and write things down with my free left hand :P

Thanks CarolinaScotsman now I know what it's called haha