E. coli outbreak points to gaps in US food system

Jun 02, 2011 By LAURAN NEERGAARD , AP Medical Writer
Chief of the laboratory in research into the Escherichia Coli bacterium at the Brno research institute, Pavel Alexa, left, and his assistant Gabriela Glocknerova, right, take samples from a cucumber for a molecular biological test in Brno, Czech Republic, Wednesday, June 1, 2011. The ongoing outbreak of E. coli has claimed 16 people and infected around 1500 across Europe. The laboratory is testing the vegetables for the Czech market. (AP Photo/Petr David Josek)

(AP) -- The nasty form of E. coli hitting Europe points out gaps in the U.S. food safety system that raise concern that similar outbreaks might happen here.

It's impossible to test for every illness-causing form of E. coli, even the kinds we already know about.

Today, the and focus mostly on a single strain of the bacteria that until now was considered the most dangerous. But some different strains collectively known as "the other E. colis" were sickening more and more people well before this extra-deadly European bug burst on the scene.

"It's a wake-up call around the world," said Dr. Robert Tauxe of the , which has long been concerned about the lesser known strains.

Authorities don't yet know the source of the European infection, but , tomatoes and leafy lettuce grown there are suspected.

There's no reason to stop eating fresh vegetables in the United States, but officials are monitoring the situation carefully. The has stepped up testing of those foods imported from affected countries as a precaution, although very little is imported.

And Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack said Thursday there's no immediate threat from what's happening in Europe. "We have to constantly look for ways to improve food safety, and that requires us to make sure that we're testing for the right things," he said.

USDA, under pressure from consumer groups, already was working on a measure to address some of the other E. colis in beef, a policy being reviewed by the Obama administration. Researchers created tests to screen for the six strains considered most prevalent, before the toll in Europe revealed a seventh.

When it comes to , a sweeping new law requires the FDA to set standards to guard against contamination of all sorts. The rules are expected to address such things as properly processed , worker hygiene, and keeping animals and their runoff from fields or irrigation water.

It's not clear how quickly those rules will emerge; Republican-led efforts to cut FDA's budget would strain the work.

"There are no regulations in place today that would prevent this kind of outbreak from occurring" in the U.S., said food-safety expert Caroline Smith DeWaal of the Center for Science in the Public Interest.

But specialists say the broad focus promised by the food-safety law is critical to get ahead of the next emerging germ, rather than racing to develop tests for each new strain.

"You never know what's around the corner that's just waiting to bite you," said former FDA assistant commissioner Dr. David Acheson, now a food-safety consultant. "You cannot test your way to safety, you just can't do it."

The produce industry says it's not waiting on the FDA. Some growers in California and other areas, for example, have voluntarily adopted such standards as not harvesting leafy greens within 5 feet of feces or other animal activity in a field, said David Gombas of United Fresh Produce. What prevents the long-targeted E. coli strain should prevent these newly worrisome varieties, too, he said.

E. coli is incredibly common. Hundreds of strains, most of them harmless, live in the intestines of humans, cows and numerous other animals. But some produce toxins that can cause diarrhea, sometimes severe enough to trigger kidney failure, even death.

The most dangerous form in the U.S. has been the E. coli O157:H7 strain, notorious since a 1993 outbreak at a fast-food chain led to its classification as an adulterant in meat, requiring testing and recalls. A 2006 outbreak in spinach highlighted the threat to fresh produce, too. The CDC estimates that strain alone causes about 63,000 foodborne illnesses a year.

In Europe's unusually large outbreak, an emerging super-strain named O104:H4 has sickened at least 1,600 people and killed 18. Most surprising is that nearly 500 of those victims have that kidney damage, more than typical with other strains.

It's not clear why this particular strain is so virulent. But genetic testing suggests a toxin-spewing form of the bug combined with another strain that attaches to a patient's gut in a more aggressive way - the germs stacking in a brick-like pattern rather than individually, said Acheson. He has long studied E. coli and warned years ago that lesser known were "just accidents waiting to happen."

In fact, CDC's Tauxe says that other toxin-forming E. colis altogether cause more illnesses - about 112,000 U.S. cases a year - than the most targeted type. But the other E. colis got less attention because they tended to cause smaller outbreaks, like the one in romaine lettuce blamed for two dozen illnesses in five states last year.

That's why Bill Marler, a Seattle attorney who specializes in food poisoning cases, petitioned USDA to mandate beef testing for the other E. colis, knowing that other foods tend to follow the meat industry.

"If E. coli O157 is an adulterant in hamburger, then these other bugs should be, period," he said.

Tauxe cautions there's a lot to learn about these other E. colis. Later this year, the CDC will begin a study to identify risk factors, what foods and which people seem particularly vulnerable.

Explore further: Quality improvement intervention cuts tests ordered


Related Stories

Smoking gun elusive in deadly E. coli outbreak

Jun 01, 2011

(AP) -- European health officials tracking one of the worst E. coli outbreaks on record might never know where it came from. It's a sad fact of life in food poisoning cases: There often is no smoking gun.

FDA: Dough's E. coli strain differs from illness

Jul 10, 2009

(AP) -- The Food and Drug Administration said Thursday the strain of E. coli found in a sample of raw cookie dough collected at a Nestle USA manufacturing plant does not match the strain that has been linked to a 30-state ...

Disease-causing Escherichia coli: 'I will survive'

Sep 09, 2009

Strains of Escherichia coli bacteria that cause food poisoning have been shown to have marked differences in the numbers of genes they carry compared to laboratory strains of E. coli. Some of these genes may enable them t ...

Recommended for you

Quality improvement intervention cuts tests ordered

2 hours ago

(HealthDay)—Implementation of a multifaceted quality improvement intervention is associated with a decrease in the number of ordered laboratory tests, according to a study published online March 21 in the ...

Soldiers cite 'Medic!' as a top hearing priority

9 hours ago

'Medic!', 'Hold fire!' and grid references are amongst the highest priorities for soldiers to be able to hear while on duty, according to new research from the University of Southampton.

User comments : 0

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.