US top court rejects quick health care law ruling

Apr 25, 2011

The US Supreme Court rejected Virginia's request Monday to immediately rule on whether President Barack Obama's sweeping health care reform is constitutional.

The decision left the lower courts to hash out the issue before the highest court in the land would make a final ruling, likely further prolonging the already bitter legal fight over the controversial law overhauling America's troubled .

It also marked the second time the Supreme Court denied a request from critics of the reform for an expedited review, without the issue being examined thoroughly in appeals courts first.

But the decision was not surprising. While US law allows for cases to be examined directly by the Supreme Court without first going to an , the process is exceedingly rare.

Virginia Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli, a Republican, had requested that the top US court issue to hear arguments in the case before the Fourth Circuit US Court of Appeals in his state's capital of Richmond does so.

"Regardless of whether you believe the law is constitutional or not, we should all agree that a prompt resolution of this issue is in everyone's best interest," Cuccinelli wrote in February upon making his request.

The law, one of Obama's key domestic achievements, has been hotly debated and challenged across the United States since Congress passed it last year, and legal experts believe a challenge to the law -- which extends coverage to some 32 million uninsured Americans -- will make its way to the Supreme Court.

Two Republican-appointed federal judges -- in Virginia and Florida -- have already declared the law unconstitutional, saying a key provision of the law known as the "individual mandate" exceeds Congress's regulatory powers by requiring Americans to either purchase by 2014 or pay a fine.

But, in another sign of how the rulings have been largely split along party lines, three Democratic appointees have upheld the law -- in Michigan, Virginia and the US capital Washington.

Governors and attorneys general from 26 US states have also found the provision unconstitutional in a separate lawsuit.

Related hearings are scheduled in several appeals courts.

The Richmond court is due to examine a decision backing the reform and one against it during a hearing on May 10.

Explore further: Antibacterial soap exposes health workers to high triclosan levels

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Judge in Va. strikes down federal health care law

Dec 13, 2010

(AP) -- A federal judge declared the foundation of President Barack Obama's health care law unconstitutional Monday, ruling that the government cannot require Americans to purchase insurance. The case is ...

The constitutionality of health care reform

Feb 15, 2011

President Obama’s health care reform legislation has been the subject of lively political and legal debate. Many lawsuits have been filed to prevent the implementation of the legislation. These lawsuits claim that ...

US judge deals new blow to Obama health reform

Jan 31, 2011

A second US federal judge Monday declared President Barack Obama's health care law unconstitutional, sparking a fierce new showdown with Republicans who vow to repeal the historic reform act.

Court Denies Vonage Bid for Patent Case Retrial

May 04, 2007

A U.S. appeals court denies a request by Internet phone company Vonage Holdings that it order a retrial in the patent infringement case brought against it by Verizon Communications.

Recommended for you

Mums trust mums on the net, according to study

1 hour ago

Facebook groups for mothers are overtaking the traditional mums-and-bubs and playgroup environments as a source of trusted advice, and offers a largely untapped marketing tool for businesses wanting to sell ...

Social networks key to improving health in New Zealand

1 hour ago

Turning conventional thinking about health and healthcare on its head by championing social networks is vital if New Zealanders want to improve their health outcomes, and ultimately save the nation money, says a leading public ...

User comments : 0