The 'rebound' effect of energy-efficient cars overplayed, study finds

January 24th, 2013
The argument that those who have fuel-efficient cars drive them more and hence use more energy is overplayed and inaccurate, a University of California, Davis, economist and his co-authors say in a comment article published Wednesday in the journal Nature.

Critics of energy efficiency programs in public policy debates have cited the "rebound effect" as a reason that hybrid cars and plug-in electric vehicles, for example, don't really save energy in the long run.    

The "backfire" concept, a more extreme version of "rebound," actually stems from a 19th century analysis in a book titled "The Coal Question," by Stanley Jevons. The book hypothesized that energy use rises as industry becomes more efficient because people produce and consume more goods, according to the Nature article. But the article's co-authors found that in the modern economy, the effect is not supported empirically.

"If a technology is cheaper to run, people may use it more. If they don't, they can use their savings to buy other things that required energy to make. But evidence points to these effects being small—too small to erase energy savings from energy efficiency standards, for example," said David S. Rapson, assistant professor of economics at UC Davis.

Rebound effects are therefore "no excuse for inaction," the article states.

Energy efficiency standards will once again be a topic of debate—and a potential target for attack—with the renewed focus on climate change and the possibility of federal regulatory action, Rapson explained: "From an economic perspective, a carbon tax or well-functioning cap-and-trade market is still optimal. But if the political reality doesn't allow these, efficiency standards should be evaluated based on the balance of costs and benefits. Rebounds are an important consideration, but are often overblown and misunderstood.

"Even though increased efficiency may prompt changes in behavior, energy is still saved overall," said Rapson. "Energy efficiency policies should therefore continue to be considered as a way to address greenhouse gas emissions."

More information:
The article is available at: http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v493/n7433/full/493475a.html.

Provided by UC Davis

This Phys.org Science News Wire page contains a press release issued by an organization mentioned above and is provided to you “as is” with little or no review from Phys.Org staff.

More news stories

Large, distant comets more common than previously thought

Comets that take more than 200 years to make one revolution around the sun are notoriously difficult to study. Because they spend most of their time far from our area of the solar system, many "long-period comets" will never ...

When should the police use confrontational tactics?

Citizens depend on police to provide public safety while maintaining the trust of the community. How can democratic societies balance these two, often conflicting, aims—given citizens' often divergent views over basic tenets ...

A bar magnet creates chaos in plasma

Placing a magnet on your refrigerator might hold up your calendar, but researchers from India's Saha Institute of Nuclear Physics found that placing one outside a plasma chamber causes a localized, fireball-like structure. ...

Musk, Zuckerberg duel over artificial intelligence

Visionary entrepreneur Elon Musk and Facebook chief Mark Zuckerberg were trading jabs on social media over artificial intelligence this week in a debate that has turned personal between the two technology luminaries.