New study maps the influence of organized crime and the wealthy over Russian foreign policy

Credit: Unsplash/CC0 Public Domain

Russian foreign policy-making is often guided by elites, intermediaries, private companies, and organized crime groups rather than the national interest, a new study shows.

Identifying and tracing Russian illicit financial flows is very difficult due to the politicized nature of authoritarian legal systems and data gaps. Being able to "follow the money" is hard because there is minimal formal regulation or oversight.

Researchers mapped the malign Russian practices via a literature review of existing studies on overseas practices by those connected with the Kremlin. This allowed them to categorize different types of influence which created conditions friendly to illicit financial flows. This included political activities, which blur formal and informal means of diplomacy and political influencing to promote Russia-friendly candidates and ; media activities, which blur truth and falsehood by constructing and disseminating narratives painting Russia and pro-Russia actors in a positive light; and , which blurs legitimate and illegitimate use of force to secure investment projects, destabilize regions and undermine or eliminate opposition.

The research was conducted by Catherine Owen and Tom Mayne from the University of Exeter and Tena Prelec from the University of Oxford and University of Rijeka. It was carried out as part of the Serious Organized Crime & Anti-Corruption Evidence (SOC ACE) research program, which is funded by the UK's Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office (FCDO).

Dr. Owen says that "it is virtually impossible to disentangle the relationship between Russian foreign policy and Russian illicit financial flows since Russian foreign policy has a strong illicit financial—or kleptocratic—element."

"Where there is Russian formal foreign engagement, it is also likely that illicit financial flows are present. Russian foreign policy initiatives expedite the overseas investment of corruptly acquired money; therefore, the informal, patronal relationships that facilitate this, as well as the domestic political conditions in which they are embedded, are key factors in Russian foreign policy decision-making."

Dr. Mayne says that "it is hard to prove the presence of specific illicit financial flows, but our research suggests malign overseas activities funded by Russian elites seek to produce outcomes beneficial to Russia's Kremlin-connected billionaires."

"The 'political', 'media' and 'violence' are used alongside one another and mutually reinforce one another."

"The principal actors in Russian foreign policy-making and -doing are not state institutions but elites, intermediaries, private companies, and organized crime groups, and the form they take is quite different."

Dr. Prelec says that "Russia's formal foreign policy initiatives can provide legitimation, or 'cover', for recently established IFF and, on the other, IFF can build on or cement relationships forged through formal foreign agreements. Often those individuals forging such agreements—both on the Russian side and in partner countries—are very wealthy individuals with in a range of industries and sectors, who can use these agreements to enrich themselves."

Explore further

Google's Russian business plans to file for bankruptcy

More information: Report: … gn-policy-report.pdf
Citation: New study maps the influence of organized crime and the wealthy over Russian foreign policy (2022, August 15) retrieved 2 October 2022 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors