Environmental policy often has undesirable side effects

climate policy
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

"Good intentions" do not generally produce "good results." This wisdom also applies to establishing coherent environmental policies. Without proper oversight and planning, environmental policies can lead to unintended and harmful side effects. A current special issue of the journal Environmental Research Letters is devoted to this urgent problem. The guest editors are researchers from the University of Bonn and international partners.

Bioplastics is frequently understood as synonymous with green, sustainable and environmentally friendly alternatives to petroleum based plastic products. This is not the whole story, however. While is true that plastics made from corn, wheat, or sugarcane are, in principle, climate-neutral and protect declining oil reserves—a broad shift in consumption from conventional to bio-based materials could be bad news for the environment given the current state of technology. After all, plant based are produced on land and unregulated agricultural expansion often leads to the conversion of natural, such as tropical forests. This jeopardizes climate change mitigation efforts, because forests bind considerably more carbon than, for instance, corn or sugar cane plantations. Hence, the unintended consequences of promoting "green" products through ill-designed , could potentially lead to more harm than good for the , not to mention other consequences, such as rising food prices and biodiversity loss.

A number of such examples can be found in the special issue "Focus on Leakage" of the journal Environmental Research Letters. They show that policies intended to combat climate change and environmental destruction often produce impacts that planners had not anticipated in the design phase. "It is therefore important to assess potential undesired consequences in advance and, if necessary, adjust or even pull the plug before it's too late," emphasizes Dr. Jan Börner, who holds the Chair of Economics of Sustainable Land Use and Bioeconomy at the University of Bonn. "To this end, we have to get better at understanding how these so-called spillover effects occur and how they can be minimized. The collection of papers in this special issue contributes to this aim."

Computer models as decision aid

The cause-and-effect relationships in the global land use system are complex, however. Computer models thus represent an important tool to support design processes. Clearly, models of global land use dynamics do not make precise predictions. "Their accuracy is too low for that," explains Börner. "In contrast to bio-physical simulations, psychological, economic, and sociological factors dominate in human managed systems. This makes them useless as forecast tools." Nevertheless, policy simulations can show what consequences an environmental policy decision can possibly have in order to anticipate which measures are the best way to reduce undesirable side effects.

Policy design is further complicated when spillovers occur far away from where policy decisions are made. While the decision to replace with biogenic raw materials has an immediate positive effect on the German carbon emission balance, it also means that Germany has to import more biomass, potentially driving deforestation in regions such as South America and Southeast Asia. These dynamics have measurably increased the that the EU generates through its imports from other countries, as shown by a study in the special issue. Moreover, these ecological costs usually arise in countries with weak environmental legislation. This can potentially turn a net-benefit of a well-intended environmental policy into a net-cost.

Prof. Börner calls for binding sustainability guidelines in international agreements. "We need to discuss where it is efficient to produce certain products, both from an economic and an ecological point of view and on a global level," he says. "If this means that some regions lose out economically, we must think about suitable compensation mechanisms." The current trend towards bilateral agreements has not been helpful from this perspective. "International environmental and trade agreements must engage as many parties as possible in order to deal with global impacts of local policies."


Explore further

More bioplastics do not necessarily contribute to climate change mitigation

More information: Focus on Leakage: Informing Land-Use Governance in a Tele-Coupled World. Environmental Research Letters. iopscience.iop.org/journal/174 … age/Leakage-Land-Use
Journal information: Environmental Research Letters

Provided by University of Bonn
Citation: Environmental policy often has undesirable side effects (2020, March 19) retrieved 30 March 2020 from https://phys.org/news/2020-03-environmental-policy-undesirable-side-effects.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
9 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments