For superconductors, discovery comes from disorder

For superconductors, discovery comes from disorder
This image shows the transition between Cooper pair density (indicated by blue dots) and charge density waves. Argonne scientists found that by introducing defects, they could disrupt charge density waves and increase superconductivity. Credit: Ellen Weiss / Argonne National Laboratory

Discovered more than 100 years ago, superconductivity continues to captivate scientists who seek to develop components for highly efficient energy transmission, ultrafast electronics or quantum bits for next-generation computation. However, determining what causes substances to become—or stop being—superconductors remains a central question in finding new candidates for this special class of materials.

In potential superconductors, there may be several ways electrons can arrange themselves. Some of these reinforce the superconducting effect, while others inhibit it. In a new study, scientists at the U.S. Department of Energy's (DOE) Argonne National Laboratory have explained the ways in which two such arrangements compete with each other and ultimately affect the temperature at which a material becomes superconducting.

In the , electrons join together into so-called Cooper pairs, in which the motion of electrons is correlated; at each moment, the velocities of the electrons participating in a given pair are opposite. Ultimately, the motion of all electrons is coupled—no can do its own thing—which leads to the lossless flow of electricity: .

Generally, the more strongly the pairs couple and the larger the number of electrons that participate, the higher will be the superconducting transition temperature.

The materials that are potential high-temperature superconductors are not simple elements, but are complex compounds containing many elements. It turns out that, besides superconductivity, electrons may exhibit different properties at low temperatures, including magnetism or charge density wave order. In a charge density wave, electrons form a periodic pattern of high and low concentration inside the material. Electrons that are bound in the charge density wave do not participate in superconductivity, and the two phenomena compete.

"If you remove some electrons to put into a charge density wave, the strength of your superconducting effect will diminish," said Argonne materials scientist Ulrich Welp, a corresponding author of the study.

The work of the Argonne team is based on the realization that charge density wave order and superconductivity are affected differently by imperfections in the material. By introducing disorder, the researchers suppressed a charge density wave, disrupting the periodic charge density wave pattern while having only a small effect on superconductivity. This opens a way to tune the balance between the competing charge density wave order and superconductivity.

To introduce disorder in such a way that impaired the charge density wave state, but left the superconducting state largely intact, the researchers used particle irradiation. By hitting the material with a proton beam, the researchers knocked out a few atoms, changing the overall electronic structure while keeping the chemical composition of the material intact.

To get a picture of the fate of the charge density waves, researchers utilized state-of-the-art X-ray scattering at Argonne's Advanced Photon Source (APS), a DOE Office of Science User Facility, and the Cornell High Energy Synchrotron Source. "X-ray scattering was essential to observe the subtleties of this electronic order in the material," said Argonne physicist and study author Zahir Islam. "We discovered that a dilute concentration of disordered atoms really diminished the charge density wave to enhance superconductivity."

According to Islam, while the current brilliance of the APS allowed for systematic studies of charge density waves from tiny single-crystal samples despite its relatively weak scattering strength, the upcoming planned upgrade to the facility will afford researchers utmost sensitivity to observe these phenomena. Furthermore, he said, scientists will benefit from studying these materials in extreme environments, in particular, under high magnetic fields to tip the balance in favor of charge density waves to gain necessary insights into high-temperature superconductivity.

In the research, the scientists investigated a material called lanthanum barium copper oxide (LBCO). In this material, the superconducting temperature plummeted almost to absolute zero (-273 degrees Celsius) when the material achieved a certain chemical makeup. However, for closely related compositions, the transition temperature remained relatively high. The scientists believe this effect of chilling superconductivity is due to the presence of charge density waves and that suppressing the charge density wave could induce even higher transition temperatures.

With charge waves impaired by disorder, superconductivity reaps the benefit, Wai-Kwong Kwok, Argonne Distinguished Fellow and study author, explained. "From the perspective of the superconductor, the enemy of my enemy truly is my friend," he said.

A paper based on the study, "Disorder raises the critical temperature of a cuprate superconductor," appeared in the May 13 online issue of the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

Explore further

The relationship between charge density waves and superconductivity? It's complicated

More information: Maxime Leroux et al. Disorder raises the critical temperature of a cuprate superconductor, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (2019). DOI: 10.1073/pnas.1817134116
Citation: For superconductors, discovery comes from disorder (2019, August 16) retrieved 19 September 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Aug 17, 2019
Magnetic Fields Destroy Superconductivity

For it is the magnetic field created by the flow of electrons
That destroys the flow of electrons
We only require frictionless electron flow
Not magnetic fields
We can now construct electronic insulating layers one atom thick
Building these layers into multilayer's
Electrons flow from atom to atom in the vacuum in between the mono-atom layers

To stop these magnetic fields destroying these superconducting currents is simplicity itself
Using these mono-atom layers
With superconducting currents
Flowing in alternating directions
Wires only atoms in diameter
In bundles
Will cancel these magnetic fields

Then miraculously
Electric currents will suddenly start flowing in perpetuity
With no friction
Supplying us with electricity
To our homes
With no frictionless loss's

In fact
From our PowerStation's
Will flow to our homes without the need for 250,000volts

All Because We Cancelled These Magnetic Fields

Aug 17, 2019
For when our Electricity flows without Friction

This is the whole point of frictionless wires
When electricity flows without friction
The wires
Can be several atoms thick
The wires will no longer glow red with friction
Our electric cables
Will be so thin
We will need to make them thicker
Just to make them visible

But this new intractable problem
Of our superconducting wires being too small in diameter to see
Will only become serious problem
We Neutralise these Infernal Magnetic Fields

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more