Low-cost Moon mission puts India among lunar pioneers

India's Chandrayaan-2 moon mission is scheduled to launch from Sriharikota space centre on July 15 and to land at the lunar Sout
India's Chandrayaan-2 moon mission is scheduled to launch from Sriharikota space centre on July 15 and to land at the lunar South Pole in September 2019

India will step up the international space race on Monday when it launches a low-cost mission to become only the fourth country to land a probe on the Moon.

Just five days before the 50th anniversary of man's first lunar landing, Chandrayaan-2—or Moon Chariot 2—will blast off from a tropical island off Andhra Pradesh state after a decade-long build-up.

The mission will also highlight how far space travel has advanced since Neil Armstrong's giant leap for mankind during the Apollo 11 mission.

India has spent about $140 million to get Chandrayaan-2 ready for the 384,400 kilometres (around 240,000 miles) trip from the Satish Dhawan Space Centre to the scheduled landing on the lunar South Pole on September 6.

The United States spent about $25 billion—the equivalent of more than $100 billion in current prices—on 15 Apollo missions, including the six that put Armstrong and other astronauts on the Moon.

China landed its Chang'e 4 lunar craft in January, and spent $8.4 billion on its entire space programme in 2017, according to international Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development figures.

And Russia—the first country to land an unmanned Moon rocket in 1966—spent more than $20 billion at today's values on lunar missions in the 1960s and 70s.

India's Vikra lander and orbiter
India's Vikra lander and orbiter

Spiced-up space race

Almost the entire Chandrayaan-2's orbiter, lander and rover have been designed and made in India.

India will use its most powerful rocket launcher, GSLV Mk III, to carry the 2.4 tonne orbiter, which has a mission life of about a year.

The spacecraft will carry the 1.4 tonne lander Vikram—which in turn will take the 27-kilogramme (60-pound) rover Pragyan—to a high plain between two craters on the lunar South Pole.

Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) chief K. Sivan said Vikram's 15-minute final descent "will be the most terrifying moments as we have never undertaken such a complex mission".

  • Five days before the 50th anniversary of the first man on the moon, India's Chandrayaan-2 will blast off
    Five days before the 50th anniversary of the first man on the moon, India's Chandrayaan-2 will blast off
  • The United States spent about $25 billion on 15 Apollo missions, including that which first put Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin o
    The United States spent about $25 billion on 15 Apollo missions, including that which first put Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin on the moon in 1969

The solar-powered rover can travel up to 500 metres (yards) and is expected to work for one lunar day, the equivalent of 14 Earth days.

Sivan said the probe will be looking for signs of water and "a fossil record of the early solar system".

Despite the relatively small budget, the mission does raise questions about how funds are allocated when the country is still battling hunger and poverty.

But is at stake: Prime Minister Narendra Modi has vowed to send a manned mission into orbit by 2022.

Most experts say the geo-strategic stakes are small—but that India's low-cost model could win commercial satellite and orbiting deals.

K. Sivan, chief of the Indian Space Research Organization, says that the lander's descent will be the hardest part of its missio
K. Sivan, chief of the Indian Space Research Organization, says that the lander's descent will be the hardest part of its mission to the moon

"The fundamental question that we should ask ourselves in this context is not whether India should undertake such ambitious space ventures, but whether India can afford to ignore it," said K. Kasturirangan, a former ISRO chief.

India has to aim to be a leader in space, he added.

Rajeswari Pillai Rajagopalan, head of space policy at the Observer Research Foundation, a New Delhi think tank, said Chandrayaan-2 will enhance the nation's reputation "at a time when the global and particularly, the Asian space programmes are becoming increasingly competitive".

Amitabha Ghosh, a scientist for NASA's Rover mission to Mars, said the benefits of Chandrayaan-2 are huge, compared to its cost.

"A spacecraft mission of the complexity of Chandrayaan-2 conveys a message that India is capable of delivering on difficult technology development endeavours," said Ghosh.

The history of space exploration, from 1957 - 2019
The history of space exploration, from 1957 - 2019

However, some experts say anyone looking for a cheap ticket to should think of the comfort on low-cost plane rides closer to Earth.

Scott Hubbard, a former top NASA researcher now with Stanford University, examined the cost-effectiveness of the Indian Mars orbiter against the American Maven mission.

Although both launched in 2013, Maven is estimated to have cost 10 times more, but India's Mangalyaan was only designed to last about a year.

"The US was required to last two years. That's a big difference in cost," said Hubbard. And Mangalyaan's payload was 15 kg, while Maven could carry 65 kg with more sophisticated instruments.

"So you get what you pay for," concluded Hubbard.


Explore further

India unveils spacecraft for moon-landing mission

© 2019 AFP

Citation: Low-cost Moon mission puts India among lunar pioneers (2019, July 12) retrieved 22 July 2019 from https://phys.org/news/2019-07-low-cost-moon-mission-india-lunar.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
169 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments

Jul 12, 2019
Why does the camera shot look like a VHS movie cover left out at a blockbuster video under a neon light for 10 years?

Jul 12, 2019
well chemhaznet1, why not?

not every picture has to have that fakey-glossy, photoshop air-brushed look of porn magazines
impressed by the illusion of "perfection"?
why? whats wrong with admiring reality?

one day, knock on vinyl
Humanity may perhaps successfully send Human explorers to Callisto

Standing on the surface?
they will look up & if timed right?
Jupiter will be in orbital phase to reflect sunlight

the astronauts are going to go completely apeshit at what they will be seeing
that will be magnitudes beyond all the "perfected" photos they had previously seen

i believe that it will be an experience similar to paddling a surfboard into the curl of a monster wave
just as it starts to crash down on you
& yes, i crapped my shorts
was saved by the lifeguard wavebeater

PLUS during the Big Moon's orbit allowing a "night" view of the Gassy Giant's intermittent periods of dark?

i'm speculating that looming ball of dark will be showing spectacular lightning storms & auroras?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more