Shocking economics

Shocking economics
Each arc shows the impact of Trump tariffs on one economic sector in Europe. The blue lines show countries and sectors that gain output from the shock; red lines indicate a decreased output. The darker the lines, the bigger the effects are. Bottom left: The electricity sector shows a decrease in output consistently through all countries due to less energy being required in the EU steel and aluminum manufacturing sector. Bottom right: The manufacturers of automotive vehicles profit from the tariffs. The reduced demand for European steel and aluminum in the US increases the supply of these metals in Europe. This leads to positive effects for sectors that require them. Credit: CSHVienna / Johannes Sorger (Software:

Modern macroeconomics has failed to produce an understanding of economies in times of crisis. Modern macroeconomics are still based on the assumption of equilibria, but a shock pushes economies out of a state of equilibrium. . This model therefore fails when dealing with economies in times of crisis.

Researchers from the Complexity Science Hub Vienna (CSH) are now proposing a novel method borrowed from physics that makes the effects of major events on out-of-equilibrium economies computable for the first time. Their article was published in the current issue of Nature Communications.

The new method adds to current economic models in several ways:

Calculating resilience

"First, we can determine the resilience of an economy," says Peter Klimek, first author of the paper. Each country has different industries, and depends on various imports and exports. "We see all these interdependencies in newly available data sets. From these data, we can calculate how susceptible a country and its production sectors are to disturbances."

The scientists see, for instance, which parts of an economy are particularly vulnerable to a shock like a trade war.

Modeling outputs

"We can further quantify how much a shock in one corner of the world affects the production of a given sector far around the globe," says co-author Stefan Thurner.

Modeling responses to shocks answers questions like why it took economies so long to recover from the 2008 recession. "A shock does not evaporate," explains Peter Klimek. Just like a rock that is thrown into a still pond, a shock produces waves. "The shock waves will run through the whole system, following each of its interdependent connections." The researchers found that it typically takes six to 10 years before all sectors of an economy have fully absorbed a shock.

Testable predictions

Another line of progress resulting from the new method is that it makes testable predictions possible. The authors took the input-output data of 56 industrial sectors in 43 OECD countries from the years 2000 to 2014. With this large dataset they tested the accuracy of different economic projections that were dealing with the aftermaths of 2008. "Our method clearly outperformed all standard econometric forecasting methods—most of them substantially," the authors state.

They also estimated the effects of Donald Trump's new tariffs on EU steel and aluminum, imposed in June 2018. The model finds winners and losers. In Germany, for instance, the output of the automotive industry increases, as do legal activities or wholesale trade. On the other hand, electricity production, warehousing or land transport show a decline.

"Interestingly, the production output in most of the EU countries rises so much that it can partly compensate the losses due to the tariffs," says Thurner. As soon as statistics for 2018 and 2019 are available, the team will test its prediction with real-world data. "Our vision is to eventually be able to calculate global effects of all kinds of scenarios that can happen anywhere," the complexity scientist adds.

A concept from physics

The concept for the new model is inspired by classical physics: Linear response theory (LRT) explains such things as how electric or magnetic substances react to strong electrical or magnetic fields. This is known as susceptibility. It can be measured with special devices, but can also be mathematically derived from properties of the material. "We show that LRT applies just as well to input-output economics," says Peter Klimek. "Instead of material properties, we use economic networks; instead of , we determine the susceptibility of economies, their response to shocks."

Visualizing economies

To make it intuitively understandable how economies work, scientists at the CSH employ an interactive visualization tool. It will be constantly fed with new data until the final version should represent the whole world .

The tool visualizes the various dependencies of countries and production sectors. "Users can change all kinds of parameters and immediately see the effects across countries and sectors," says Stefan Thurner. A preliminary version, showing Trump tariff effects on Europe, can be seen at

Explore further

Foreign retaliation to U.S. tariffs disproportionately affects Republican-leaning counties, report finds

More information: Peter Klimek et al, Quantifying economic resilience from input–output susceptibility to improve predictions of economic growth and recovery, Nature Communications (2019). DOI: 10.1038/s41467-019-09357-w
Journal information: Nature Communications

Provided by Complexity Science Hub Vienna
Citation: Shocking economics (2019, April 16) retrieved 22 April 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more