Research finds some shark deterrents don't work as well

March 14, 2019, University of Western Australia
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

Shark researchers from The University of Western Australia have found that one of the personal shark deterrents commercially available in WA is not effective in deterring sharks.

The WA State Government-funded research team travelled to Mossel Bay in South Africa to test the effectiveness of the Electronic Shark Defense System (ESDSTM) with the large population of white sharks (Carcharodon carcharias) found in these waters. The team recorded 395 encounters with 44 individual white sharks.

Lead researcher Dr. Ryan Kempster said the findings, published in PLOS One, represented the most robust assessment of the effectiveness of the ESDSTM in deterring white sharks. Personal shark deterrents offer the potential of a non-lethal solution to protect individuals from sharks, but the effectiveness claims of most deterrents are based on theory rather than robust testing of the devices.

"There is therefore a clear need for thorough testing of commercially available shark deterrents to provide the public with information about their effectiveness," Dr. Kempster said.

The researchers found an active ESDSTM was no more capable of keeping sharks at a 'safe' distance than an inactive ESDSTM. Sharks would routinely approach within 20-30 cm of the , whether it was active or not.

By comparison, an active Shark ShieldTM (which was previously tested by the team using the same methodology), effectively deterred white sharks by an average of 1.3m from the device.

However, when in the presence of an active ESDSTM, sharks did show a reduction in biting, but, this was countered by an increase in other, less aggressive forms of interaction, such as bumping.

The researchers concluded that the ESDSTM showed limited meaningful effect on the behaviour of white sharks, as any effect of the active device was at such a short range that sharks would likely have only experienced it if they were close enough to bite the device itself. Given the device is designed to be worn on the person's ankle; it would leave most of their body completely unprotected.

"Although the of the ESDSTM may vary between species, due to species-specific differences in electroreceptive ability, the fact that white are implicated in the majority of fatal incidents globally suggests that a device that cannot effectively deter this species should not be considered an effective shark deterrent," Dr. Kempster said.

"Given the very short effective range of the ESDSTM and its unreliable deterrent effect, combined with the fact that shark-bite incidents are very rare, it is unlikely that the device would significantly reduce the risk of a negative interaction with a white shark."

Explore further: Hunting a 'great' shark deterrent

More information: Channing A. Egeberg et al. Not all electric shark deterrents are made equal: Effects of a commercial electric anklet deterrent on white shark behaviour, PLOS ONE (2019). DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0212851

Related Stories

Hunting a 'great' shark deterrent

May 24, 2018

Valuable insights into the performance of commercially available personal shark deterrents have been revealed in Flinders University research.

Shark deterrent research reveals interesting results

June 17, 2015

Shark researchers from the Neuroecology Group at The University of Western Australia have released the results of their WA State Government-funded research into the effectiveness of a range of novel and commercial shark deterrents.

Fifty years of decline in Queensland's coastal sharks

December 13, 2018

Queensland's coastal shark numbers are continuing a 50-year decline, in sharp contradiction of suggestions of 'exploding' shark populations, according to an analysis of Queensland Shark Control Program data.

Recommended for you

A decade on, smartphone-like software finally heads to space

March 20, 2019

Once a traditional satellite is launched into space, its physical hardware and computer software stay mostly immutable for the rest of its existence as it orbits the Earth, even as the technology it serves on the ground continues ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.