Tiny houses look marvellous but have a dark side: Three things they don't tell you on marketing blurb

January 11, 2019 by Megan Carras, The Conversation
Going cheap. Credit: Luke Stackpoole/Unsplash, CC BY-SA

Tiny houses are everywhere. They've received heavy coverage in the media and there are millions of followers on dozens of pages on social media. While there is no census for these homes, they have seen a surge in popularity in the decade since the Great Recession – witness the prolific growth of tiny house manufacturers, for instance. Originating in the US, tiny homes have also been popping up across Canada, Australia and the UK.

Tiny houses are promoted as an answer to the affordable housing crisis; a desirable alternative to traditional homes and mortgages. Yet there are many complexities and contradictions that surround these tiny spaces, as I discovered when I began investigating them.

I have toured homes, attended tiny house festivals, stayed in a tiny house community and interviewed several dozen people who live inside them. My research took me throughout the US, from a converted accessory unit squeezed between two average size homes on Staten Island to a community in Florida full of cute and brightly coloured tiny structures – appropriately located just down the road from Disneyland. Here are three things I unexpectedly discovered along the way.

1. Tiny homes and the housing ladder

Millenials have a complicated relationship with home ownership. They often still want to own a home but are simply not able to do it in the same way as their parents, and are known as "Generation Rent" as a result.

All the tiny-houser millenials that I interviewed wanted to own bigger houses in future; they saw tiny living as a means of owning something now and being able to save at the same time. Several planned to upgrade once they had children, selling their tiny homes or even keeping them as guesthouses.

But if they saw these homes as a temporary option they would abandon as their lives progressed, it's not always so straightforward in practice. Apart from the obvious challenge of saving enough to afford a bigger place, it's not easy to sell tiny homes since they usually depreciate in value. And because they are not attached to land, there is often a question mark about their long-term viability as well.

2. Groundlessness

Tiny homes tend to be on wheels as a way of getting around government regulations on minimum habitable dwelling size. This often makes their inhabitants feel unsettled. In my own experience staying in a tiny home, I recall feeling a general awareness of the wheels underneath and a slight swaying as I jumped from the ladder that accessed the lofted bed.

As one interviewee who lives with his partner and small child on private land in rural Washington State told me: "It doesn't feel that grounded; it feels like we are detached from the earth because there are wheels underneath us… It's a constant reminder… you are in this fragile state of housing."

Credit: Paul VanDerWerf, CC BY-SA

The majority of dwellers that I talked to were eager to live on a solid foundation in future. I met one millennial who used her college fund to build a beautifully crafted and customised tiny home, but felt so groundless after only a year of living on wheels that she was trying to sell.

This suggests that building codes will need to be relaxed to allow more tiny housers to live on foundations. Some places have taken the lead on this already – one example is Spur, Texas, which has changed its relevant housing laws with the express intention of attracting tiny housers in response to a declining population. Spur is pitching itself as the first tiny house friendly town in America.

More broadly, however, the legalities around tiny homes remain complicated. They continue to restrict the potential for this lifestyle both in the US and elsewhere. In the UK, for instance, there can be issues with planning laws that require all new dwellings to have more than one bed space. In southwest England, Bristol City Council recently overruled such rules to allow several to be built in the back garden of a terraced in the suburbs, reckoning that it was necessary to help alleviate a local housing crisis.

3. Tiny homes ≠ tiny consumption

Tiny houses are often put forward as a more sustainable housing option. They are certainly a potential check on the continued pursuit of bigger houses and greater consumption of energy, building materials and so forth. Yet reducing your by going tiny is not as simple as some have claimed.

I came across several tiny households that were using external storage spaces for items that wouldn't fit in the home, for example. Referred to as a "dirty secret" by one interviewee, another explained her desire to keep items from her previous home in case she changed her mind about tiny living.

Over half of my interviewees had a "one in, one out" mentality, where they would throw away or donate one item to make space for something new. As one dweller in her late 30s, who lives in a state-of-the-art home in a caravan park in rural New Hampshire, said, "I have a TJ Maxx addiction. I still go out every couple months and buy a bunch of stuff then come home and decide which things to get rid of."

Regardless of how tiny living is marketed by the enthusiasts, sustainability was not a major driver for most of the participants in my study. Instead it was almost an afterthought. It seemingly takes more than changing the size of a to change the mentality of the people who live inside.

Explore further: The psychology behind the tiny house movement

Related Stories

The psychology behind the tiny house movement

August 12, 2016

Tiny homes have recently taken the housing market by storm, appearing all over rural and urban America as an affordable and eco-conscious solution to an increasingly tight housing supply. Generally between 100 and 400 square ...

Tiny houses could help mitigate homelessness

July 24, 2015

In recent years, the "tiny house" movement has picked up speed in the U.S. Most often, the advocates of the small homes promote them as a lifestyle choice for those seeking to save money, reduce possessions, or otherwise ...

Recommended for you

Galactic center visualization delivers star power

March 21, 2019

Want to take a trip to the center of the Milky Way? Check out a new immersive, ultra-high-definition visualization. This 360-movie offers an unparalleled opportunity to look around the center of the galaxy, from the vantage ...

Physicists reveal why matter dominates universe

March 21, 2019

Physicists in the College of Arts and Sciences at Syracuse University have confirmed that matter and antimatter decay differently for elementary particles containing charmed quarks.

4 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

dirk_bruere
not rated yet Jan 12, 2019
So, little houses on trailers. Maybe they can be parked somewhere like, maybe, a "trailer park"? As for the UK, no matter how small the house the land would still cost upward of $120k
rrwillsj
not rated yet Jan 12, 2019
Since the 70's, I have felt dubious that the tiny homes/house trailers/factory assembled housing being sturdy enough to survive really bad weather.

The impression I got while shopping for a home? From several landlords I met over the years? That they wanted a cheap way to skip zoning regulations. & squeeze in as many units as possible paying rents or leases.

Then resell the property as a packaged deal for a tax gimmick in a commercial property exchange.

Now. the recent earthquake in Alaska reveals that the majority of severely damaged homes were smaller constructs.

My guess would be poor quality standards & the lack of foundations. The small homes & trailers bounced all over, ripping out pipes & wiring. Instead of moving with the ground.
Da Schneib
1 / 5 (3) Jan 12, 2019
One word: sewage.
Anonym588159
not rated yet Jan 13, 2019
Some People that live in these things tend to take advantage of generous Neighbors who will let them bathe and do laundry, etc in their facilities.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.