The Wizard of Oz most 'influential' film of all time according to network science

Credit: Cristie Guevara/public domain

The Wizard of Oz, followed by Star Wars and Psycho, is identified as the most influential film of all time in a study published in the open access journal Applied Network Science.

Researchers at the University of Turin, Italy, calculated an influence score for 47,000 films listed in IMDb (the internet movie database). The score was based on how much each film had been referenced by subsequent films. The authors found that the top 20 most influential films were all produced before 1980 and mostly in the United States.

Dr. Livio Bioglio, the lead author, said: "We propose an alternative method to box office takings—which are affected by factors beyond the quality of the film such as advertising and distribution—and reviews—which are ultimately subjective—for analysing the success of a film. We have developed an algorithm that uses references between as a measure for success, and which can also be used to evaluate the career of directors, actors and actresses, by considering their participation in top-scoring movies."

Applying the algorithm to directors, the five men credited for The Wizard of Oz are all in the top eight, with Alfred Hitchcock, Steven Spielberg and Stanley Kubrick ranked third, fifth and sixth respectively. When the authors used another approach to remove the bias of older movies—which, because they were produced earlier, can potentially influence a greater number of subsequent films—Alfred Hitchcock, Steven Spielberg and Brian De Palma occupied the top spots instead.

When applied to actors, the algorithm ranked Samuel L. Jackson, Clint Eastwood and Tom Cruise as the top three. The authors noticed a strong gender bias towards male actors; the only female in the top ten was Lois Maxwell, who played the recurring role of Miss Moneypenny in the James Bond franchise.

Dr. Bioglio said: "The scores of top-ranked actresses tend to be lower compared to their male colleagues. The only exceptions were musical movies, where results show moderate gender equality, and movies produced in Sweden, where actresses ranked better compared to actors."

To calculate the influence score for the 47,000 films investigated in this study, the authors treated the films as nodes in a network and measured the number of connections each film has to other films and how influential the films connected to it are. Similar methods have already been widely applied to measuring the impact of work in other fields, such as scientific publications.

Dr. Bioglio said: "The idea of using network analysis for ranking films is not completely new, but to our knowledge this is the first study that uses these techniques to also rank personalities involved in film production."

The authors suggest that their method could be used for research in the arts and by film historians. However, they caution that the results can only be applied to Western cinema as the data on IMDb are strongly biased towards produced in Western countries.

Explore further

Automated method beats critics in picking great movies

More information: Livio Bioglio et al, Identification of key films and personalities in the history of cinema from a Western perspective, Applied Network Science (2018). DOI: 10.1007/s41109-018-0105-0
Provided by BioMed Central
Citation: The Wizard of Oz most 'influential' film of all time according to network science (2018, November 29) retrieved 20 October 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Nov 29, 2018
I am nobody in particular and I approve of this message

Nov 30, 2018
Another demonstration of the fact that, using the right criteria, you can "prove" that coconuts are cranberries.
Here, the term "influential" is employed and the "criterion" is only how many times a film was mentioned in subsequent films. How does that make a film "influential"? If a film is only mentioned in another film, how does that make it necessarily, conventionally "influential"? At one time, "I Am Curious (Yellow)", "Last Tango In Paris", "Deep Throat" and "Debbie Does Dallas" were widely referenced, but does that make them necessarily, conventionally "influential"?
A point, though. The same scam here as in Carl Sagan's "extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof". "Extraordinary" is not defined. As here, it can be defined any way, certainly by connivers. If you don't want to acknowledge something, simply declare the proof not "extraordinary" enough.

Nov 30, 2018
oh juliaodd, you really missed the point of such research. Those movies that you piously disclaim, after getting your jollies watching them.
Cause otherwise how could you make any honest criticism?

Are influential in that they disgust and dismay so many viewers.

Though the way you churchies abuse women and children?
I'd guess you consider those films to be your training guides excusing all you godnuts for your violent sexual perversions.

Dec 01, 2018
Some permutation or another of Dorothy's line, "Toto, I've a feeling we're not in Kansas anymore" to convey the idea that someone is out of their depth or in a place that lacks innocence or familiarity has been used in so many other movies I've given up trying to make a list. On that basis alone I'd have to agree with giving 'The Wizard of Oz' the number one spot as I can't even think of a single quote from another movie that comes in a distant second.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more