Does a collaborative learning approach work for everyone?

November 5, 2018 by Diana Lachance, University of Alabama in Huntsville
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

There's a good reason why universities have spent the last few years dedicating precious resources and time to fostering a collaborative learning environment. Students who are encouraged to participate in discussions, work cooperatively in small-group settings, and actively engage with their peers are believed to gain not only the cognitive skills needed to survive in the professional workplace, but also the interpersonal ones needed to thrive. And for many, the approach seems to be working. But is it working for all students?

That's the question Dr. Whitney Meade, an assistant professor in the College of Education at The University of Alabama in Huntsville (UAH), is hoping to answer. Together with Dr. Letha Etzkorn and Dr. Huaming Zhang, her colleagues in the Department of Computer Science in the College of Science, Dr. Meade was awarded funding from the university's Collaborative Learning Center for their research project, "What Is the Extent of the Problem: How Many Students Will Do Poorly in Collaborative Learning Because of Lack of Social Skills?"

It was Drs. Etzkorn and Zhang who initially brought the issue to Dr. Meade's attention. "About a year ago, they reached out to me about an increase they had seen in the number of students who were struggling in the class setting," she says. "Whether it was interrupting the professor or not being able to vary their thought process, they would seem to get stuck on one thing and not let it go." Dr. Meade, whose research focus is on and behavioral disorders and who serves as the director of the UAH Regional Autism Network, suspected the cause might be an impairment of , particularly given the professors' field. "It's possible those who don't have strong social skills or are introverts might be more likely to choose majors like computer science, where their social skills aren't going to be tapped so readily," she says. "So we wanted to see how many people would need intervention."

The three decided to partner on a pilot study titled "The Missing Element: A Discussion of Autism Spectrum Disorders in Computer Science," which they presented earlier this year at the American Society for Engineering Education's Southeastern Section Conference in Daytona, Fla. Students in the professors' class who consented to the study were anonymously screened for autism using Gilliam Autism Rating Scale-3 protocols and then scored using the autism index. "The results caught me very off guard," says Dr. Meade. "More than 80 percent scored either 'probably' or 'very likely' on the . And even though Huntsville is known to have a higher rate of autism, mirroring Silicon Valley, we weren't expecting that."

The team began to wonder if they hadn't stumbled on to something. If a high percentage of computer science students struggled with social skills, wasn't it possible the same would be true of students in similar fields? "We hypothesized that those who have good social skills might be more likely to choose a major, and thus a profession, that is service oriented, like nursing, communications, or education, where there's a lot of interaction with people," she says. "Conversely, those who don't have strong social skills or who are introverts might be more likely to choose majors like computer science, engineering, or math, where their social skills aren't going to be tapped so readily."

That's when the trio reached out to the aforementioned CLC to seek funding. "We applied for the CLC award so that we could buy the Social Responsiveness Scale-2 protocols," says Dr. Meade, referring to a well-known screening instrument used to identify and quantify the severity of social impairment. "I then met with the deans of all the colleges, and I asked them to randomly pick faculty members who could then ask their students to complete the survey." Once those surveys are returned, the team will then score and analyze the data to determine if there are any statistically significant connections. "We'll look and see whether there are more students who have impairments in social skills in a certain major, whether they are predominantly male or female, and whether there more in a certain age or ethnic group," she says.

It's what they learn from those findings that will ultimately give them insight into whether is effective for students whose social skills don't lend themselves to an interactive environment. "If we get almost nothing back that indicates there's a problem, then we were wrong," says Dr. Meade. "But if we get a big pile of data that show students in non-service-oriented majors have lots of social skills deficits, at that point, do you stop the train and say maybe this isn't the best approach because it's not going to be successful? That's the big question."

Explore further: Students' social skills flourish best in groups with similar skill levels

Related Stories

Children with delayed motor skills struggle more socially

July 1, 2013

(Medical Xpress)—Studies have shown that children with autism often struggle socially and now new research suggests that a corresponding lack of motor skills – including catching and throwing – may further contribute ...

Children with autism who live with pets are more assertive

December 30, 2014

Dogs and other pets play an important role in individuals' social lives, and they can act as catalysts for social interaction, previous research has shown. Although much media attention has focused on how dogs can improve ...

Recommended for you

Study casts new light on fishing throughout history

November 12, 2018

A new study from The Australian National University (ANU) has revealed new insights into ancient fishing throughout history, including what type of fish people were regularly eating as part of their diet.

A toast to the proteins in dinosaur bones

November 9, 2018

Burnt toast and dinosaur bones have a common trait, according to a new, Yale-led study. They both contain chemicals that, under the right conditions, transform original proteins into something new. It's a process that may ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.