First results from Cassini's final mission phase show protons of extreme energies between the planet and its dense rings

October 5, 2018, Max Planck Society
This image shows the proton radiation belts of Saturn. The radiation in the area between the planet and the D-ring can be seen enlarged in the inset and was first observed in the last mission phase of the Cassini mission. It is created by the incidence of galactic cosmic radiation on the planet’s rings. The protons generated in this way subsequently interact with the atmosphere of Saturn, its thin D-ring and its ringlets. Credit: MPS/JHUAPL

Approximately one year ago, a spectacular dive into Saturn ended NASA's Cassini mission—and with it a unique, 13-year research expedition to the Saturnian system. In the mission's last five months, the probe entered uncharted territory again: Twenty-two times, it plunged into the almost unexplored region between the planet Saturn and its innermost ring, the D ring. On Friday, 5 October 2018, the journal Science is releasing six articles describing first results from this mission phase.

In one of these papers, a research team led by the Max Planck Institute for Solar System Research in Germany and the Applied Physics Laboratory of Johns Hopkins University in the U.S. reports on the unique proton radiation belts formed in close proximity to the planet. Due to presence of the dense A, B, and C rings, this area is almost completely decoupled from the main radiation belt and the rest of the magnetosphere, which extend farther outward.

When the space probe Cassini swung into its first orbit around Saturn and its rings on July 1, 2004, the Magnetospheric Imaging Instrument (MIMI) particle detector suite, including Low Energy Magnetospheric Measurement System (LEMMS), developed and built under the leadership of MPS, caught a brief glimpse of the region between the planet and the innermost D . The measurements indicated that a population of charged particles may be present, but its exact composition and properties remained obscure. In the following years, MIMI-LEMMS investigated the particles that are trapped by Saturn's strong magnetic field outside its rings, forming its main radiation belt that consists of high-energy protons and electrons. The proton radiation belt extends more than 285,000 kilometers into space and is strongly influenced by Saturn's numerous moons, which segment it into five sectors. "Only 13 years later, shortly before the end of the mission, we were given the opportunity to follow up on our very first measurements at Saturn and see if an additional radiation belt sector co-exists with the D ring and the upper atmosphere of the planet," explains Elias Roussos, scientist at the Max Planck Institute for Solar Systems lead author of the current study.

The 13-year-long test of patience has now paid off. In their current Science article, the scientists paint a comprehensive picture of the protons surrounding Saturn in close proximity. Two articles in the journal Geophysical Research Letters elaborate these findings.

Similar to the main proton belt of Saturn, the protons that populate the region close to the planet are generated by incident galactic cosmic radiation. When cosmic radiation interacts with material in Saturn's atmosphere or in its dense rings, it triggers a chain of reactions generating high-energy protons that are subsequently trapped by the planet's magnetic field.

Saturn's magnetic field is more than 10 times stronger near the planet than it is in the main radiation belts. That makes trapping so efficient that protons can remain for years in the same magnetic field line. That forces them to interact continuously with the D ring and the Saturnian atmosphere and gradually lose their full energy. But with the densities of the tenuous D ring unknown, it was unclear how fast this energy loss develops and whether a radiation belt could be maintained. Theoretical modeling indicated that one viable scenario might be MIMI measuring nothing but noise.

In its final mission phase, the Cassini probe entered the region between Saturn and the D-ring along the orange trajectory. The observed accumulation of protons extends across the D-ring. While the proton intensity is visibly reduced at ringlets D68 and D73, ringlet D72 hardly influences it. Although Cassini itself did not dive into the D-ring system, LEMMS obtained information about its structure as trapped particles move along magnetic field lines (e.g. marked in blue) and reach the spacecraft after they interact with ring material. Credit: MPS/JHUAPL

That fortunately did not happen – at least for protons. LEMMS measurements revealed a stable accumulation of energetic protons that extends from the atmosphere of Saturn and all across the D ring. The energy that many of these protons have is extreme: more than 10 times higher than what LEMMS was designed to measure. "We had to dig out old mechanical drawings of the instrument and construct new models of it to understand how it would measure in such an extreme environment," Roussos adds.

"Outward of the D ring, Saturn's A, B and C rings are significantly denser and dustier, forming an effective 62,000-kilometer barrier for the trapping of charged particles," Roussos continues. That meant that the outer edge of the D ring was as far as this new proton belt could extend – and LEMMS measurements confirmed that. "This creates a radiation belt that is completely isolated from the rest of the magnetosphere," says MPS scientist Dr. Norbert Krupp, Principal Investigator of the MIMI-LEMMS team and co-author of the study in Science.

This region is unique in the solar system. It offers the possibility to examine a radiation belt in laboratory-like conditions, as its protons are created by a very stable process, guided and controlled by Saturn's strong magnetic field. In Saturn's main radiation belt and in the of Earth and Jupiter, these conditions are different—and much more complicated. At Earth, for example, a variable influx of high-energy particles from the sun can have a strong influence on the radiation belt structure.

Equally valuable is the new information that LEMMS adds about the D ring system, which is too faint to study by imaging alone. This ring contains a total of three narrow ringlets, all brighter than the rest of the ring and named as D68, D72 and D73. While the intensity of protons was reduced by ringlets D68 and D73, ringlet D72 lying between them does not appear to have an effect. "Even though the D72 and D68 ringlets are similarly bright, LEMMS measurements show us that they must actually be very different," says Roussos.

MIMI measurements also revealed a secondary, lower-energy radiation belt at an altitude below several thousand kilometers. This belt forms occasionally when fast neutral hydrogen atoms created in Saturn's magnetosphere get trapped near the planet when they impact its atmosphere and become charged. "The presence of this lower-altitude belt shows that some minimal information by Saturn's variable, distant magnetosphere can be transmitted across the planet's dense rings," Krupp adds.

In the 13 years the MIMI/LEMMS instrument spent at Saturn, it conducted one of the most comprehensive investigations of a planetary belt other than that of the Earth and even helped to discover unknown rings. A summary of these and further discoveries can be found in the book Saturn in the 21st Century, which is published by Cambridge University Press this month. Dr. Norbert Krupp from the MPS is among its four editors.

Explore further: Saturn's radiation belts: A stranger to the solar wind

More information: E. Roussos et al. A radiation belt of energetic protons located between Saturn and its rings, Science (2018). DOI: 10.1126/science.aat1962

N. Krupp et al. Energetic neutral and charged particle measurements in the inner Saturnian magnetosphere during the Grand Finale orbits of Cassini 2016/2017, Geophysical Research Letters (2018). DOI: 10.1029/2018GL078096

Saturn's innermost radiation belt throughout and inward of the D‐ring. Geophysical Research Letters.

Related Stories

Saturn's radiation belts: A stranger to the solar wind

October 30, 2017

The radiation belts of Earth and Saturn differ more strongly than previously assumed. In these belts, very energetic particles, such as electrons and protons, move around the planet at high velocities - captured by its magnetic ...

New Transient Radiation Belt Discovered at Saturn

September 14, 2009

Scientists using the Cassini spacecraft's  Magnetospheric Imaging instrument (MIMI) have detected a new, temporary radiation belt  at Saturn, located around the orbit of its moon Dione at about 377 000 km from the center ...

Image: Saturn's B-ring close-up

March 20, 2017

This image shows the incredible detail at which the international Cassini spacecraft is observing Saturn's rings of icy debris as part of its dedicated close 'ring grazing' orbits.

Image: Saturn's B ring peaks

February 19, 2018

While the Winter Olympics is in full swing in PyeongChang, South Korea, and many winter sport fanatics head to snow-clad mountains to get their thrills on the slopes this ski-season, this dramatic mountain scene is somewhat ...

Recommended for you

Meteorite source in asteroid belt not a single debris field

February 17, 2019

A new study published online in Meteoritics and Planetary Science finds that our most common meteorites, those known as L chondrites, come from at least two different debris fields in the asteroid belt. The belt contains ...

Diagnosing 'art acne' in Georgia O'Keeffe's paintings

February 17, 2019

Even Georgia O'Keeffe noticed the pin-sized blisters bubbling on the surface of her paintings. For decades, conservationists and scholars assumed these tiny protrusions were grains of sand, kicked up from the New Mexico desert ...

Archaeologists discover Incan tomb in Peru

February 16, 2019

Peruvian archaeologists discovered an Incan tomb in the north of the country where an elite member of the pre-Columbian empire was buried, one of the investigators announced Friday.

Where is the universe hiding its missing mass?

February 15, 2019

Astronomers have spent decades looking for something that sounds like it would be hard to miss: about a third of the "normal" matter in the Universe. New results from NASA's Chandra X-ray Observatory may have helped them ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

2.5 / 5 (8) Oct 05, 2018
This must be an embarrassment to the Electric Universe loonies.
3.4 / 5 (5) Oct 05, 2018
This must be an embarrassment to the Electric Universe loonies.

How so?
2 / 5 (8) Oct 05, 2018
Seriously, Cusco? Are you denying that electric currents exist in the Universe? Why not try holding a metal fork and stick the tines into a live electrical outlet and see what happens.
Science tells us that there are filaments in the Cosmos that connect galaxies. What do you think those filaments consist of? Spaghetti?
2 / 5 (8) Oct 05, 2018

Electric universe is one of the alternatives being considered by scientists.
3.3 / 5 (3) Oct 05, 2018

Electric universe is one of the alternatives being considered by scientists.

I think that's being a bit optimistic. The article you've referenced still assumes that the magnetic nature of the 'black hole' caused the filament in one way or another.
3.7 / 5 (9) Oct 06, 2018

Electric universe is one of the alternatives being considered by scientists.

No, it is not since there are no peer reviewed publications. The unordered set of 'ideas' does not work. It is considered pseudoscience. "Electric Universe (EU)[note 1] is an umbrella term that covers various pseudo-scientific cosmological ideas ... often vary from one delusional crank to the next." [ https://rationalw...Universe ].

The article you refer to is a rare radio filament - so not very "universal" or influential as such - and the mundane explanation proposed is cyclotron radiation - which is just what plasma do and black holes are especially known for. "Cyclotron radiation from plasma in the interstellar medium or around black holes and other astronomical phenomena is an important source of information about distant magnetic fields.[2][3]" [ https://en.wikipe...adiation ]
1 / 5 (1) Oct 07, 2018
This little movie demonstrates the charged nature of the rings. A moonlet approaching a ring is attracted towards it, then a discharge occurs causing the video drop-out, the ring dust is sputtered onto the moonlet, the charge equalises and the moonlet is repulsed and will head back towards another ring with a different charge level where the process will be repeated, so the moonlet will grow over time.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.