Injection wells can induce earthquakes miles away from the well

August 30, 2018, University of California - Santa Cruz
In this diagram of an injection operation, the blue and red areas represent the spatial footprint of induced seismicity for injection into basement rock (blue) or the overlying sedimentary layer (red). Gray lines represent the fault network. The graphs below show the corresponding earthquake probabilities as a function of distance from the well. Credit: Goebel and Brodsky, Science, 2018

A study of earthquakes induced by injecting fluids deep underground has revealed surprising patterns, suggesting that current recommendations for hydraulic fracturing, wastewater disposal, and geothermal wells may need to be revised.

Researchers at UC Santa Cruz compiled and analyzed data from around the world for earthquakes clearly associated with wells. They found that a single injection well can cause earthquakes at distances more than 6 miles (10 kilometers) from the well. They also found that, in general, injecting fluids into can cause larger, more distant earthquakes than injecting into the underlying basement rock.

"This is problematic, since the current advice is to preferentially inject into the sedimentary sequence as a theoretically safer alternative to the basement rock," said Emily Brodsky, professor of Earth and planetary sciences at UC Santa Cruz.

Postdoctoral researcher Thomas Goebel said the key issue is the spatial footprint of induced seismicity around the injection well. "It's not that the basement rock is safe, because there is still the possibility of encountering a fault in the basement rock that can cause a large , but the probability is reduced because the spatial footprint is smaller," he said.

In a paper published August 31 in Science, Goebel and Brodsky described two distinct patterns of induced seismicity, which they associated with different physical mechanisms acting in basement rock and sedimentary rock. In the first pattern, associated with injection into basement rock, earthquakes tend to occur in a compact cluster around the well, with a steep decline in earthquakes farther from the well. In the other pattern, associated with sedimentary rock, induced earthquakes decline gradually with from the well and occur at much greater distances.

Injection sites with steady spatial decay and comparably large spatial footprint in Central Europe, the United States and Australia. Credit: Thomas Goebel

The physical mechanism by which injection wells induce earthquakes was thought to be a direct result of increased fluid pressure in the pores of the rock, causing faults to slip more easily. This mechanism can account for the spatial pattern of seismicity seen with injection into basement rock, Goebel said. But the seen with injection into sedimentary rock suggests a different mechanism resulting from efficient "poroelastic coupling," which controls the ability of the rock to transmit fluid stresses into the solid rock matrix.

"When you inject water into the ground, it pushes on the surrounding rock and creates elastic stress in the rock, which can put pressure on faults at a distance without putting water into those faults. So if poroelasticity is dominant, you end up with a larger footprint because it's loading neighboring faults beyond the area of increased pore pressure," Brodsky said.

According to Goebel, the crystalline basement rock is stiffer and has lower porosity than sedimentary . "Therefore, the increase in pore pressure is limited to isolated pockets around the well, and the coupling of that with the overall stress field is low," he said.

Goebel said their findings help explain the extent of induced seismicity in regions such as Oklahoma where there are many injection sites in oil and gas fields. Oklahoma has seen a dramatic surge in earthquakes since 2010, to the extent that there are now more earthquakes each year in Oklahoma than in California. Goebel and Brodsky did not include sites in Oklahoma in their study, however, because there are so many they couldn't isolate the effects of individual wells.

"In Oklahoma, they are injecting into the high-porosity sedimentary unit above the basement, but these elastic stresses can be transmitted over a large distance, so you could activate a large basement at a distance of 10 kilometers," Goebel said. "That may be what we're seeing in places like Oklahoma."

Explore further: Oklahoma is laboratory for research on human-induced earthquakes

More information: T.H.W. Goebel el al., "The spatial footprint of injection wells in a global compilation of induced earthquake sequences," Science (2018). … 1126/science.aat5449

Related Stories

Study finds possible deep faults, possible earthquake source

June 5, 2018

Scientists may have found previously unmapped faults in Oklahoma that could be contributing to a sharp increase in induced earthquakes in the state, according to a report on a study that used magnetic imaging to explore the ...

Recommended for you

Extreme weather events rarely occur in isolation

September 25, 2018

The end of the baking hot summer is a forceful reminder of what the climate could hold in store for us in the future. Between April and August of this year, rainfall in Eastern Switzerland was lower than has ever been recorded. ...

How Earth sheds heat into space

September 24, 2018

Just as an oven gives off more heat to the surrounding kitchen as its internal temperature rises, the Earth sheds more heat into space as its surface warms up. Since the 1950s, scientists have observed a surprisingly straightforward, ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

5 / 5 (1) Sep 01, 2018
The PV system which powers my two electric cars affects nobody, is perfectly clean, and silent.
And I own it.
1 / 5 (1) Sep 03, 2018
Injection wells are often used to dispose of industrial chemical wastes from many industries including those that might make PV batteries, plastics, and many other so-called "green" products.

Nothing humans do is "perfectly clean," and or really sustainable in the long term. In the next couple of decades we will be forcibly introduced to both the "critical" and "finite" limitations/bottlenecks of our most sensitive finite critical resources as a species - as we deplete the last of some of them.
not rated yet Sep 03, 2018
Injection wells are often used to dispose of industrial chemical wastes from many industries including those that might make PV batteries, plastics, and many other so-called "green" products.

I call BS. Where is the proof?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.