Bat signal: Fireflies' glow tells bats they taste awful

Bat signal: Fireflies' glow tells bats they taste awful
Fireflies (Photinus pyralis) defuse bat attack with bioluminescence and slow, predictable flight. Credit: Dr. Stephen Marshall

Fireflies flash not just for sex, but survival, a new study suggests.

Scientists wanted to find out if there's more to the lightning bug's signature blinking glow than finding a mate. Some experts had speculated it was a glaring signal to predators, like , that bad.

To test out whether the glow acted like a flashing bad Yelp review, researchers at Boise State University put bats and fireflies in front of high-speed cameras. They published their results in Wednesday's journal Science Advances .

The painstaking experiment required researchers to introduce western bats, which had never seen lightning bugs before, to the insects. Later, they hand-painted firefly bellies black, essentially turning off their night lights, avoiding the holes the critters breathe through.

When the bats first saw the unfamiliar lit-up fireflies, they swooped in and munched on them, only to get a bad taste in their mouths.

"They shake their heads, salivate and spit and generally despise their caretakers for giving such a rude meal," said study author Jesse Barber, a Boise State biology professor.

Two palatability trials are shown. The first trial is of a palatable pyralid moth (Galleria mellonella), which is quickly bitten by the bat and ingested. The second trial shows a bat tasting and rejecting a firefly (Photinus pyralis). Credit: Barber Lab, Boise State University

After a few tries, the bats then avoided the glowing fireflies. (Despite the popular misconception, bats aren't blind, a study author noted.)

Once the fireflies essentially taught bats that they taste bad, Barber and colleagues introduced the darkened fireflies. About 40 percent of the painted ones were munched, while none of the normal fireflies were eaten.

Scientists also think the way lightning bugs fly signals what they are. To test that they put fireflies on fishing lines to change how they flew and the bats went after them, despite already knowing that fireflies don't taste good.

The results make sense and are valuable, said outside expert Nick Dowdy, a Purdue University researcher.

A bat is first shown hawking a palatable scarab beetle (Callistethus marginatus) in flight, which it subsequently ingests. The second interaction is of a bat capturing, then dropping a firefly (Photinus pyralis). Finally, after several subsequent firefly interactions, a bat is shown approaching and avoiding another firefly. Credit: Barber Lab, Boise State University

Scientists already knew that fireflies have distinctive flash patterns that tell others who they are and where they are. And some females prefer males that flash at higher rates, according to study co-author Marc Branham of the University of Florida.

Barber noted that even in their larval stage, the bugs glow and don't get munched on. So he theorized that when it comes to evolution, fireflies' glowing trait may have developed first as protection from predators and later became a sexy signal.

So, Barber said, "bats may have invented fireflies."

Explore further

Video: How do fireflies glow?

More information: Brian C. Leavell et al. Fireflies thwart bat attack with multisensory warnings, Science Advances (2018). DOI: 10.1126/sciadv.aat6601
Journal information: Science Advances

© 2018 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.

Citation: Bat signal: Fireflies' glow tells bats they taste awful (2018, August 22) retrieved 19 October 2019 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Feedback to editors

User comments

Aug 22, 2018
Why don't all animals just tell their predators they don't taste good? I'll tell you why it would not work for snakes... everyone knows snakes are liars

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more