Worm-eating mice reveal how evolution works on islands

May 16, 2018, Field Museum
One of the worm-eating mouse species that earned its home island Mindoro a spot as the smallest known island where one species has evolved into many more. Credit: L. R. Heaney, The Field Museum

Australia has a bunch of kangaroo species, Madagascar has multiple species of lemurs, the Galapagos Islands have boulder-sized tortoises—islands get lots of cool animals. That's because when animals are isolated on islands, they can evolve into strange new species found nowhere else on Earth. But what's the cut-off—how small can an island be and still support the evolution of multiple new species from a single common ancestor? A team of mammalogists just discovered that four species of mice evolved from one common ancestor on Connecticut-sized Mindoro Island in the Philippines, making it the smallest known island where one kind of mammal has branched out into many more.

"The single most remarkable thing about planet Earth is there are so many here, so much biodiversity. We take it for granted, but holy cow, there's a whole lot of stuff out there—how did it get here?" says Lawrence Heaney, Negaunee Curator of Mammals at Chicago's Field Museum and co-lead author of a recent paper in the Journal of Biogeography. "This is one of the few papers ever written to look at whether there's a limit to how small an island can be for species diversification to occur, and it's the only one looking at it in mammals. Mindoro is by far the smallest island on which we've seen this happen."

According to Heaney, this quest to find the smallest island that can support new mammals started with a thought experiment posed in 1980. Michael Soulé, a conservation biologist, wondered if new animal species could diversify in an area the size of the largest of existing national parks. Diversification means that multiple species arise from one parent species. "There are many that have species that arrived from somewhere else and that subsequently changed into something distinctive. Many of these islands are much smaller than Mindoro," explains Heaney. "Rather, the key to this study is whether a single species that arrived from somewhere else has produced multiple species that all evolved within the given island from the single ancestral species. It is the issue of an increase in the number of species within the island, by evolution within the island."

Previously, the smallest island where scientists knew mammal species had diversified was Luzon, the largest island in the Philippines. But Luzon is one of the biggest islands in the world, about the size of Virginia. Heaney and his team wanted to see if they could do one better—"We looked at a map and said, okay, where's there a smaller island where diversification may have occurred?"

The scientists didn't have to look far—they turned to Mindoro, a small island just across a channel from Luzon. Mindoro is a tenth the size of Luzon—it's about two-thirds the size of Connecticut. Heaney's colleague Danny Balete, now deceased, led the fieldwork missions on Mindoro for four field seasons, searching for the island's mammals.

Scientists doing fieldwork that helped show Mindoro is the smallest known island where one species has branched into many. Credit: L. R. Heaney, The Field Museum

This is where the worm-eating come in.

"The mice we looked at in this study are all members of the "earthworm mouse" group Apomys—they love earthworms, but they also eat seeds and fruits. They've got big dark eyes, great big ears, long soft fur, white feet, dark tails—they're very pretty little mice," says Heaney.

When the team analyzed the DNA of Mindoro's earthworm mice, they found that the mice belonged to four separate species, three of which were new to science. And all four of the species, Heaney says, evolved on Mindoro from a .

"The results are unambiguous—we've got four species of forest mice on Mindoro from one colonization event from Luzon about 2.8 million years ago," says Heaney. "And three of those four mouse species are found on their own separate mountains."

Chris Kyriazis, Heaney's former undergraduate student and co-first author on the paper, led the DNA analysis from the Field Museum's Pritzker DNA Lab. "By examining genetic variation across these populations, we were able to confirm not only that these mice originated from a single colonist on Mindoro, but also that they are distinctive enough to be considered different species. The fact that variation in external measurements show the same pattern only strengthens the case," says Kyriazis, who is now pursuing his Ph.D. in biology at UCLA.

One of the worm-eating mice that showed that Mindoro is the smallest known island where one species evolved into many. Credit: D. S. Balete, The Field Museum

The fact that the four mouse species evolved on this little island means that there's a new answer to the question posed by Soulé in 1980: mammals can diversify in an area as small as Mindoro. And since Mindoro is the same size as Yellowstone National Park, that means that new mammal species can evolve from one ancestor in areas as small as at least some large wildlife preserves.

The implications of Heaney and Kyriazis's discovery goes far beyond a thought experiment, though: it gives scientists a valuable tool for planning conservation spaces.

"This study changes how I think about conservation," says Heaney. "When we think about how to design protected areas, we need to think about the topography of the Earth, not just a flat map. The fact that these mice evolved on their own separate mountains within a limited geographic area tells us that mountains are important."

And figuring out how to plan protected wildlife spaces is crucial for preserving biodiversity. "As human population continues to expand, what's going to happen to everything else? How will be able to evolve?" asks Heaney. "This project is a step forward in being able to answer that."

Explore further: New shrew species discovered on 'sky island' in Philippines

Related Stories

New shrew species discovered on 'sky island' in Philippines

May 8, 2018

The Philippines teems with biodiversity: 657 bird species roam and fly throughout the country's 7,641 islands, and over 2,000 fish species swim in the surrounding seas. But beyond these beaked and scaly creatures, the Philippines ...

Seven new mice species found in Philippines

June 15, 2011

Seven new species of mice have been found by local and US scientists in the mountains of the Philippines, the government's environment department said Wednesday.

Island emus' size related to size of island homes

April 4, 2018

Emus that lived isolated on Australia's offshore islands until the 19th century, including Kangaroo Island, King Island and Tasmania, were smaller versions of their larger mainland relatives – and their overall body size ...

The secret life of island animals

December 11, 2017

Islands are places of myth and wonder that have fascinated people for centuries. They're also places to find odd versions of some familiar animals.

Recommended for you

Archaeologists discover Incan tomb in Peru

February 16, 2019

Peruvian archaeologists discovered an Incan tomb in the north of the country where an elite member of the pre-Columbian empire was buried, one of the investigators announced Friday.

Where is the universe hiding its missing mass?

February 15, 2019

Astronomers have spent decades looking for something that sounds like it would be hard to miss: about a third of the "normal" matter in the Universe. New results from NASA's Chandra X-ray Observatory may have helped them ...

What rising seas mean for local economies

February 15, 2019

Impacts from climate change are not always easy to see. But for many local businesses in coastal communities across the United States, the evidence is right outside their doors—or in their parking lots.

The friendly extortioner takes it all

February 15, 2019

Cooperating with other people makes many things easier. However, competition is also a characteristic aspect of our society. In their struggle for contracts and positions, people have to be more successful than their competitors ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (4) May 17, 2018
evolution of multiple new species from a single common ancestor?

This is supposedly a vindication of the Darwinian paradigm. However, the mice did not turn into cows or dogs or cats they remained MICE.
There is simply kinds of animals which has a large variability built into their genomes but there are definite limits to their ability to adapt in response to environmental signals. If the environmental pressures exceed the adaptability built into the "kind", they simply go extinct. They do not jump across boundaries by developing completely new structures and integrated functionality that gradually morphs them into something other than the broad kind.
we've got four species of forest mice on Mindoro from one colonization event from Luzon about 2.8 million years ago,

No, the evolutionist view is sadly mistaken in this. Adapting to an environment with the resulting speciation happens very very quickly - in perhaps one or two generations. It is FAST.
5 / 5 (3) May 17, 2018
They're different species, dude.
Also, why would an animal evolve into another animal that already exists? There's not some kind of "pre-approved species list" that limits the speciation possible. Last time I looked, ape species that evolved from a common ancestor are all pretty ape-like.

Also, can I point out that that your first paragraph completely contradicts your second? Evolutionary theory shows how we adapt to environmental changes. But if that environmental change is too fast or too radical, the species dies out. This hardly "disproves evolution". That's how evolution works! Why do you think we're so worried about rapid climate change caused by global warming?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.