Genetic study of plains zebra finds that six subspecies made by appearance-only do not match genetic evidence

January 23, 2018 by Bob Yirka, report
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

A team of researchers with members from Denmark, the U.S., Portugal and France has found that the six subspecies classifications currently used to categorize plains zebras living in Africa do not match with genetic evidence. In their paper published in the journal Nature Ecology & Evolution, the group describes their DNA analysis of zebras living in several parts of Africa and what they found by doing so.

Zebras are among the iconic animals of Africa. With their black and white stripes, they are one of the more recognizable creatures living on the continent today. They live mostly in the savanna of southern and eastern Africa and survive by eating generally low-quality forage. Unfortunately, like so many other animals, they are at risk due to loss of habitat, and conservationists are looking for ways to help them. That should start, the researchers with this new effort claim, with correctly classifying them.

For many years, conservationists have classified plains zebras by the shape of their head and their pattern of stripes. This has resulted in six broad classifications used when reporting on zebras and developing efforts to protect them, but now, it appears the six categories do not correspond with genetic lineage.

To develop more meaningful classifications, the researchers collected samples from 59 plains zebras representing multiple sites across Africa—they also included samples from three mountain zebras and three Grevy's zebras. Analysis of the DNA evidence suggested that there are actually nine populations of plains zebras with distinct evolutionary properties, only two of which overlap with the traditional categorizations.

Grouping zebras by genetic factors, the team notes, is important for conservation efforts, because it ensures enough diversity among populations. The team actually found an example of this—two groups of Zebras living in Uganda showed remarkably low diversity, which needs to be addressed if the groups are to survive.

In studying the DNA data, the researchers also found that the extinct creature "quagga" was a subspecies of the plains zebras and not a unique species, as some have suggested. And they also found that the birthplace of the plains zebras was in the wetlands of southern Africa.

Explore further: How a Zebra Lost its Stripes: Rapid Evolution of the Quagga

More information: Casper-Emil T. Pedersen et al. A southern African origin and cryptic structure in the highly mobile plains zebra, Nature Ecology & Evolution (2018). DOI: 10.1038/s41559-017-0453-7

The plains zebra (Equus quagga) is an ecologically important species of the African savannah. It is also one of the most numerous and widely distributed ungulates, and six subspecies have been described based on morphological variation. However, the within-species evolutionary processes have been difficult to resolve due to its high mobility and a lack of consensus regarding the population structure. We obtained genome-wide DNA polymorphism data from more than 167,000 loci for 59 plains zebras from across the species range, encompassing all recognized extant subspecies, as well as three mountain zebras (Equus zebra) and three Grevy's zebras (Equus grevyi). Surprisingly, the population genetic structure does not mirror the morphology-based subspecies delineation, underlining the dangers of basing management units exclusively on morphological variation. We use demographic modelling to provide insights into the past phylogeography of the species. The results identify a southern African location as the most likely source region from which all extant populations expanded around 370,000 years ago. We show evidence for inclusion of the extinct and phenotypically divergent quagga (Equus quaggaquagga) in the plains zebra variation and reveal that it was less divergent from the other subspecies than the northernmost (Ugandan) extant population.

Related Stories

How a Zebra Lost its Stripes: Rapid Evolution of the Quagga

September 26, 2005

DNA from museum samples of extinct animals is providing unexpected information on the extent and effect of the Ice Age as well as the path of species evolution, according to a report by scientists from Yale University, the ...

New idea on how the zebra got its stripes

January 14, 2015

( —A small team of researchers affiliated with the University of California has found little evidence to support prior theoretical explanations of why zebras have evolved to have stripes and instead suggest that ...

Zebra stripes not for camouflage, new study finds

January 22, 2016

If you've always thought of a zebra's stripes as offering some type of camouflaging protection against predators, it's time to think again, suggest scientists at the University of Calgary and UC Davis.

Scientists solve the riddle of zebras' stripes

April 1, 2014

Why zebras have black and white stripes is a question that has intrigued scientists and spectators for centuries. A research team led by the University of California, Davis, has now examined this riddle systematically. Their ...

Computer simulation explains why zebras have stripes

December 18, 2013

( —Two researchers, one from the University of Queensland, the other the University of London have published a paper together in the journal Zoology in which they claim to have solved the riddle of why zebras have ...

Recommended for you

Microplastics may enter foodchain through mosquitoes

September 19, 2018

Mosquito larvae have been observed ingesting microplastics that can be passed up the food chain, researchers said Wednesday, potentially uncovering a new way that the polluting particles could damage the environment.

In a tiny worm, a close-up view of where genes are working

September 19, 2018

Scientists have long prized the roundworm Caenorhabditis elegans as a model for studying the biology of multicellular organisms. The millimeter-long worms are easy to grow in the lab and manipulate genetically, and have only ...

Social animals have tipping points, too

September 18, 2018

In relatively cool temperatures, Anelosimus studiosus spiders lay their eggs and spin their webs and share their prey in cooperative colonies from Massachusetts to Argentina. Temperatures may vary, but the colonies continue ...

Why do we love bees but hate wasps?

September 18, 2018

A lack of understanding of the important role of wasps in the ecosystem and economy is a fundamental reason why they are universally despised whereas bees are much loved, according to UCL-led research.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jan 23, 2018
Yeah, here again we see how meticulously structured research using improving technology and the scientific Method.

Demolishes the claptrap of centuries of pseudo-scientific eugenics and other bunco artist propaganda.

Unfortunately, the crazy and the crank will continue to repeatedly spew up all the fraudulent debris of stuporstitious nonsense. Separating the gullible and the ignorant from their money.
not rated yet Jan 23, 2018
They are still just basically horses with stripes. Supply enough food and it doesn't matter which particular little subdivision they fit into. They will still thrive if humans would leave them alone.
not rated yet Jan 24, 2018
Unfortunately leaving them alone really doesn't work when humans want the land.

Zebras are a good example of good intentions causing godly level disasters.

The globe trotting tourists want to see a herd of zebra "running free across the veldt". And they want it right now! Dammit! Dontcha know they are entitled to their whims?

Those tourists are not about to walk out to where the herd is right now. They pay for the privilege of not having to sweat.

Well, that means they need to be transported, guided, cosseted, served iced drinks upon demand.

That means a whole lot of support staff. Vehicles and entertainment and latrines and gourmet chefs. And all their staffs and support infrastructure.

And those 'employees' all have families to house and feed. And that means more infrastructure and construction apace. The families need the support of farms and ranches and dairies, that all need land.

You see where I'm going with this tiny sliver of our modern society?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.