Mexico City, supremely vulnerable to quake threats

September 21, 2017 by Pascale Mollard-Chenebenoit
The collapsed Enrique Rebsamen elementary school in Mexico City, where at least 21 children were killed and about 30 children are still missing

Built in a natural basin filled with the sediment of a former lake, Mexico City has proved particularly vulnerable to the devastating effects of earthquakes, seen once again with a 7.1-magnitude tremor on Tuesday that killed at least 233 people in the capital.

The quake was "medium strong" according to Yann Klinger, an expert at the Global Physics Institute in Paris.

By comparison, the 8.2-magnitude quake that rocked southern Mexico on September 7 was "a monster", Klinger said—yet resulted in fewer, about 100, deaths.

"The fact that there were a lot of victims this time is mainly due to the specific configuration of Mexico City," he said.

Mexico as a whole sits along the edges of several huge tectonic plates, though generally their movements produce quakes along the country's western coast, through more common "interplate" shiftings deep below the earth, which is what caused the massive quake that hit Mexico in 1985, killing an estimated 10,000 people.

Tuesday's quake occurred farther to the east and involved the Cocos, a so-called microplate "stuck" between the Pacific and the North American plates, Klinger said.

Such phenomena, which also caused the that hit on September 7, are known as "intraplate" quakes that happen within plates, and not when the edges of separate plates grind against each other.

"Fortunately this occurred deep down (about 50 kilometres) so the shaking at ground level was not as bad as it might have been," said David Rothery, a geosciences professor at the Open University in Britain.

"The deformation builds up by flexing and bending until enough stress has been built up to release the blockage, allowing many year's worth of movement to occur in a few seconds," he said.

'Like quicksand'

But no matter the type of tectonic activity, the resulting vibrations can be especially deadly in Mexico City because it is built on the packed sediment of a dried-up lake.

"There are two very dangerous effects coming together: The seismic waves are trapped in the basin and amplified," Klinger said.

"And furthermore, the unconsolidated sediments (clay, sand) lose their coherence in the shaking and become like liquid, a little like quicksand."

Taller buildings in the capital are especially susceptible to the resulting vibrations on shaky ground, posing bigger risks for residents.

Rescuers were focusing their efforts in particular on Thursday on a school in the south of Mexico City, where 21 children and five adults were crushed to death, and where many might still be trapped in the rubble.

"The Enrique Rebsamen elementary school where many children died looks like a modern building, and ought to have had in-built earthquake resilience," Rothery said.

"Had it been properly constructed it should not have collapsed, and I expect questions will be asked about whether the appropriate building codes were adhered to," he added.

Scientists are also expecting aftershocks in the coming days or weeks.

"In the most common scenario, the magnitudes are lower than the initial earthquake. But we can't exclude other strong shocks," Klinger said.

Explore further: Soft soil makes Mexico City shake like it was built on jelly

Related Stories

Soft soil makes Mexico City shake like it was built on jelly

September 20, 2017

The soft soil that lines the ancient lake bed that Mexico City is built on amplified the shaking from Tuesday's earthquake and increased its destructive force, seismologists say as they try to better understand the quake ...

Toll in Mexico quake rises to at least 32

September 8, 2017

Mexico was severely jolted overnight by its most powerful earthquake in a century, which killed at least 32 people as it struck the Pacific coast, officials said Friday.

Chile eyes quake fault that could strike capital

August 11, 2017

Earthquake-prone Chile may be one of the countries best prepared for seismic shocks, but officials are nervously watching a major fault line that could shift any time, threatening the capital.

Race to rescue survivors from ruins of Mexico quake

September 9, 2017

Police, soldiers and emergency workers raced to rescue survivors from the ruins of Mexico's most powerful earthquake in a century, which killed at least 61 people, as storm Katia menaced the country's east Saturday.

Recommended for you

Semimetals are high conductors

March 18, 2019

Researchers in China and at UC Davis have measured high conductivity in very thin layers of niobium arsenide, a type of material called a Weyl semimetal. The material has about three times the conductivity of copper at room ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.