White supremacists use a decision tree to affirm or discount the results of DNA tests

Now that science can determine a person's racial and ethnic origins from a cheek swab, those devoted to ideas of racial "purity," are employing methods of mind games and logic twists to support their beliefs despite facing evidence of their own multiracial heritage.

Researchers Aaron Panofsky and Joan Donovan of UCLA looked at the way members of the white supremacist website Stormfront handled finding out the results of their DNA tests. Panofsky explained that due to the potential for conflict over their very identity, these test takers were often supported in several ways that, frankly, are obviously not true.

"When a subject would take the genetic ancestry test (GAT), the results to this group were good or they were bad," Panofsky said. "Sometimes it was a matter of 'Well I thought I was Irish, but actually I'm Norwegian, so I'm still very white, hooray.' But if the news was what these white supremacists would consider to be bad, defined as evidence of heritage from, for example, Middle Eastern peoples, this is where it would get interesting."

The first method to maintain the idea of racial purity was simply to reject GAT as a basis of knowledge about an individual's heritage. Trust in family history and records were deemed superior to "some test."

Another way that white supremacists maintain their race identity in the face of an undesirable result was what the researchers call, "The mirror ." Basically, if you look white and you don't appear to be Jewish or black, then you're not. After all, the mirror doesn't lie. Of course, this would imply that the tests are not accurate.

So-called racial purists also say they don't believe in the tests because there exists a Jewish conspiracy. Panofsky explained, "Some of these people have said, 'Well you know 23 & Me is Jewish run and operated and they just simply can't be trusted. They want to make white people doubt their , so the tests just can't be true!"

When the news, however is such that a person laments, they may be "only 71% Caucasian," there are a number of racial ideologues on the sites who accept that their fellow members can't help the fact that there is race-mixing in their family tree. Instead they're embraced for being true to the fact that there is a majority of "white" in the bloodline. The clear irony seems to be lost on a group that prides itself on standards of racial so-called purity.

"You'd think that the members of this site would say, 'Get out! We don't want you,'" Panofsky said. "Instead, they find ways to support their community members and keep them as part of the group."


Explore further

'Race tests' may be fueling segregation in white evangelical churches

Citation: White supremacists use a decision tree to affirm or discount the results of DNA tests (2017, August 17) retrieved 19 June 2019 from https://phys.org/news/2017-08-white-supremacists-decision-tree-affirm.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
27 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more