Those maps of eclipse's path? 'Wrong,' experts say—off by up to a half-mile at edge

August 11, 2017 by Eric Adler, The Kansas City Star

Anyone who has been using online maps to decide where they intend to view the historic Aug. 21 total eclipse of the sun may want to take another look.

Those maps, provided by NASA and others, show a crisply defined, 70-mile-wide path of totality where the moon will block 100 percent of the sun. But they are not as precise as they appear, at least on their edges.

The southern edge of the path as shown on the maps could be off by as little as the length of a football field or as much as a half-mile, eclipse mapping experts say. Likewise for the northern edge, meaning the path of totality might be just 69 miles wide.

"This is an issue. This is really an issue, but it's not advertised. ... Yeah, all the maps are wrong," Mike Kentrianakis, who is the project manager for the American Astronomical Society and who routinely consults with NASA, told The Kansas City Star.

It effectively means that people who assumed, based on the Google maps, that their location was just within the path of totality - thus expecting to witness a few seconds of - will instead see a . That could turn out to be a total disappointment, according to eclipse experts, who say that observing even a 99.9 percent partial eclipse is not at all the same as viewing a total eclipse.

It's been nearly 40 years since a crossed part of the contiguous United States. Ninety-nine years have passed since one spanned the breadth of the continent, as will happen Aug. 21. Knowing precisely where the path of totality begins and ends is crucial.

Current maps show the eclipse's southern edge cutting through downtown Kansas City south of Interstate 70, slicing across buildings, including The Star's brick edifice at 1729 Grand Blvd. The maps place the north part of The Star's block inside the path of totality and the south part outside the path.

And they do it with great precision. Click on a point in the parking lot south of The Star building: no totality.

Click on a point in the north parking lot and the map says, to a tenth of a second, that the total eclipse will start at 1:08:49.2 p.m. and end at 1:08:57.9.

But Kentrianakis, who discusses the issue as part of a new documentary, "Totality: The American Experience," said a more accurate line runs about a half-mile north, cutting through Ilus W. Davis Park, which separates Kansas City's City Hall (partial eclipse) and the federal courthouse (total eclipse).

Current maps also show the path cutting a sharp line through parts of St. Louis.

"St. Louis also is wrong," Kentrianakis said. Indeed, the map's edges are off along the entire path from Oregon through South Carolina.

Xavier Jubier, a French engineer whose calculations have been used to create the interactive Google maps of the eclipse, confirmed to The Star by email that the actual path of the totality is slightly narrower than the 70 miles shown on current maps.

Ernest Wright, who created maps and other multimedia presentations on the eclipse for NASA, said he thought the map might be narrower by about 100 meters, slightly longer than a football field.

He also said it's possible that Kentrianakis is correct in his estimation that the path is narrower by a half-mile or more.

"He could be," Wright said.

The reason the maps are slightly off has nothing to do with mistakes, all agree. Wright explained that eclipse maps are made based on what is known about the relative sizes and positions of the moon and the sun.

"We have really good information about the orbit of the moon, the positions of the sun, the positions of the Earth. All of that is really well nailed down," Wright said. "In order to get more accuracy, we need to take into account the mountains and valleys on the moon, and the elevations on the Earth. And we're starting to do that, as well."

The size of the moon, in fact, has been measured to within a meter, and its position in the heavens has been measured to within a centimeter.

"But the last sort of uncertainty might surprise you," Wright said. "It's the size of the sun."

It's a roiling ball of gas. "It doesn't have a solid surface," he said, making its size hard to pin down.

Scientists have calculated the sun's radius at roughly 696,000 kilometers (432,500 miles) from edge to center, but they do not know its size with precision.

A bigger sun would make the moon's shadow, and thus the path of totality, narrower.

"You would think you could send a satellite up there, take a picture of the sun and put a ruler on the picture and decide how big the sun is," Wright said.

But it doesn't work that way. Scientists have space-based and Earth-based telescopes constantly trained on the sun. Earth-based telescopes must contend with atmospheric interference. Space-based telescopes also have limitations.

"Most of the telescopes pointed at the sun use very narrow-band filters," Wright said. "So instead of looking at the sun in white light, it is kind of splitting the light into a prism and picking only one color to look at. And the different colors are going to give you slightly different sizes."

Jubier said that the current maps are accurate using the 696,000-kilometer radius and other standards agreed upon in 1976 at a meeting of the International Astronomical Union.

"This is perfectly accurate but we know it does use a solar diameter that is not large enough. Why don't we change the value(?)" Jubier wrote. "Well simply because the IAU (International Astronomical Union) has not yet approved a new value. This is part of the research we're doing and for which we're looking for funding."

He continued, "So technically speaking if the Sun is larger than the adopted IAU value, and we know it is, the eclipse path is necessarily narrower and our tools can simulate this, yet the standard maps for the public will still retain the currently adopted solar radius until a new value has been accepted. Such a process will take years as everything needs to be peer-reviewed and then validated during a General Assembly."

Jubier also does not think the small difference will change much for the average eclipse viewer, "as usually people don't go near the edges of the eclipse path."

But for untold thousands of people, including in Kansas City and St. Louis, who live near the edge, Wright with NASA and Kentrianakis with the American Astronomical Society offer this advice: Do your best to move closer toward the middle of the path of totality.

The closer one gets to the middle of the path, the longer the totality will last, up to a maximum of about 2 minutes and 40 seconds. At the edge, totality lasts less than 10 seconds.

"There are cool things to see at the edge, too," Wright said. Some astronomers argue that viewing a solar eclipse from the edge of the path of totality offers wonderful views, including a protracted view of the sun's rosy-red chromosphere, a layer of atmosphere just above its surface.

"But the big show," Wright said, "is going to be the closer you are to the center. And you don't have to drive 35 miles. You can go 10 miles and get up to a minute of totality. If you stay at the , you're only going to get a couple of seconds."

Explore further: What's a total solar eclipse and why this one is so unusual

84 shares

Related Stories

What's a total solar eclipse and why this one is so unusual

August 5, 2017

Total solar eclipses occur every year or two or three, often in the middle of nowhere like the South Pacific or Antarctic. What makes the Aug. 21 eclipse so special is that it will cut diagonally across the entire United ...

NASA moon data provides more accurate 2017 eclipse path

January 5, 2017

On Monday, Aug. 21, 2017, millions in the U.S. will have their eyes to the sky as they witness a total solar eclipse. The moon's shadow will race across the United States, from Oregon to South Carolina. The path of this shadow, ...

Recommended for you

Solar eruptions could electrify Martian moons

October 18, 2017

Powerful solar eruptions could electrically charge areas of the Martian moon Phobos to hundreds of volts, presenting a complex electrical environment that could possibly affect sensitive electronics carried by future robotic ...

3 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

BendBob
5 / 5 (1) Aug 12, 2017
Here in Central Oregon the observation of the Carmageddon is also a scheduled event which will last a good deal longer than the little 'ole solar eclipse.
michbaskett
Aug 13, 2017
This comment has been removed by a moderator.
michbaskett
1.5 / 5 (2) Aug 13, 2017
For many years I have been reading that the sun is roughly 835,000 miles wide at the equator. Now they're telling me it's roughly 140,000 miles narrower? The decision was made to use this measurement was in 1976. Why has this knowledge taken decades to filter down to even cosmologists and astronomers, the very people from whom I have been getting my information? I know my complaining will have zero effect, but that really pisses me off. I consider myself to be scientifically literate, but if I'm fed bad information than I'm no less ill informed than the idiot who lied to me or gave me false information thinking they were giving good information. Christ, might as well listen to what comes out of the White House and consider it to be good information instead of idiotic twaddle.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.