Hostage situation or harmony? Researchers rethink symbiosis

July 27, 2017, University of British Columbia
An euplotes host, blue-stained nuclei and red-stained Polynucleobacter bacteria. Credit: Vittorio Boscaro and Patrick Keeling

Relationships where two organisms depend on each other, known as symbiosis, evoke images of partnership and cooperation. But a new study in Nature Ecology and Evolution shows that, when it comes to certain microorganisms, symbiotic partners are actually being held "hostage".

The international research team, led by biologists from the University of British Columbia, studied a freshwater bacterium called Polynucleobacter that often lives inside the single-celled protozoan, Euplotes, to better understand the between symbionts, or organisms in .

"Most people think symbiosis means there is an toward harmony, a perfect balance of the two partners," says Vittorio Boscaro, a biologist at UBC and lead author of the study. "But although the host needs the bacterium to survive, the bacterium doesn't gain any advantage in this relationship."

In fact, the researchers were able to determine that Euplotes hosts constantly "snatch up" useful bacteria like Polynucleobacter from the environment, and then later discard and replace them with "fresh" symbionts.

"They're being replaced, just like you change your clothes," said Patrick Keeling, a UBC microbiologist and senior author of the study. "You take advantage of your symbiont until it's no longer useful, and then you get a new one."

An Euplotes host, stained nuclei and Polynucleobacter bacteria. Credit: Vittorio Boscaro and Patrick Keeling

The team examined what was happening between the microbes by analyzing the of Polynucleobacter. Once it is snatched up by Euplotes, it leads to major changes to the Polynucleobacter genome.

While these changes are not unexpected, the researchers were surprised to learn how the genome changes over time. Typically, we think of evolution in terms of adaptation to survive. In the case of symbiotic Polynucleobacter, they found that the genome was changing and losing genes at random and ultimately ceasing to be useful to their host.

"I like to think of the relationship being more like death row than cooperation—sure the is kept safe and well-fed in the short term, but ultimately it's not a good place to be," said Keeling.

A single-celled protozoan, Euplotes. Credit: Vittorio Boscaro and said Patrick Keeling

The researchers believe such insight may lead to a conceptual change of evolutionary processes and their complexity.

The paper was published in Nature Ecology & Evolution.

Explore further: Lice and their bacterial sidekicks have evolved together for millions of years

More information: Vittorio Boscaro et al, Parallel genome reduction in symbionts descended from closely related free-living bacteria, Nature Ecology & Evolution (2017). DOI: 10.1038/s41559-017-0237-0

Related Stories

Symbiotic ciliates and bacteria have a common ancestor

July 14, 2017

Ciliates, just like humans, are colonized by a vast diversity of bacteria. Some ciliates and their bacterial symbionts have become friends for life, as researchers from the Max Planck Institute for Marine Microbiology in ...

Bacterial tenants in fungal quarters

May 29, 2015

Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich researchers have sequenced the genome of a bacterial symbiont hosted by a mycorrhizal fungus. Analysis of the symbiont's genetic endowment reveals previously unknown facets of the partnership ...

Recommended for you

Spotlighting differences in closely-related species

October 22, 2018

There are millions of fungal species, and those few hundred found in the Aspergillus genus play important roles in areas ranging from industrial production to agricultural plant pathogens. Reported October 22, 2018, in Nature ...

Cellular trash cans reveal the roles of proteins in disease

October 22, 2018

If we really want to know how our body's cells work—or don't work, in the case of disease—we might need to look beyond their genes and even beyond the proteins they are made of. We may need to start going through the ...

Cells that change jobs to fight diabetes

October 22, 2018

Diabetes is characterized by persistent high blood sugar levels that occur when certain cells in the pancreas—the insulin-producing β cells—are destroyed or are no longer able to secrete insulin. Researchers at the University ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.