Google asks US court to block Canadian global delisting order

Google argues a Canadian court order requiring it to delist a website cannot be enforced in the United States
Google argues a Canadian court order requiring it to delist a website cannot be enforced in the United States

Google on Tuesday asked a California court to block an order from Canada that would require the US internet giant to remove a website from worldwide search results.

The lawsuit filed by the US technology giant asks for a declaratory judgment that the Canadian 's order cannot be enforced in the United States.

The case, which tests the limits of global copyright protections in the digital era, stems from a legal dispute involving Canadian telecommunications equipment manufacturer Equustek Solutions, which successfully sued another company for relabeling its products and passing them off as their own.

Google agreed to de-index 345 webpages associated with Datalink, the offending firm in Canada. But the company fled the country and continued to market the counterfeit products from an unknown location.

Equustek then succeeded in obtaining a court order, upheld last month by Canada's Supreme Court, that would require Google to delete all mentions of Datalink worldwide.

In its 143-page filing, Google said the Canadian court order would be "unprecedented" and violate its rights to operate in the United States.

"Without a declaration from a United States court that enforcement of the Canadian order in the US is unlawful, Google believes that Equustek will continue to pursue enforcement... and seek to hold Google in contempt," the document said.

The case is the latest dispute over jurisdiction following a case in Europe where French authorities ordered Google to delete search results worldwide in compliance with Europe's "right to be forgotten" directive.

In the latest filing, Google said it was an "innocent non-party" in the case and simply a tool to find information.

"Google is not the internet," the filing said. "The vast majority of internet websites are hosted by and operated through service providers other than Google."

Additionally, it said Equustek had not asked for delisting injunctions against other search engines, such as Bing or Yahoo, or against or other third parties.


Explore further

Canada: Top court orders Google to block website search results

© 2017 AFP

Citation: Google asks US court to block Canadian global delisting order (2017, July 25) retrieved 22 January 2020 from https://phys.org/news/2017-07-google-court-block-canadian-global.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
1 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments