Modeling morphology: Solid-solid phase transitions based on colloidal particle shape changes

June 5, 2017 by Stuart Mason Dambrot, feature
Fig. 1. (A) Spheric triangle invariant (Δ323) polyhedra form a continuous two-parameter (αa, αc) family of symmetric convex shapes that are bounded by the octahedron [(αa, αc) = (0,0)], tetrahedron [(0,1) and (1,0)], and cube (1,1). (B) We show six lines indicating regions of shape space in which there is a change in the equilibrium structure at a packing density of η = 0:55. The lines are annotated with the relevant structural transition and direction. The colors indicate the self-assembled structures, where FCC is red, BCC is blue, and SC is green. The self-assembled phases indicated are an approximated representation from the actual phase diagram (45). Phases in the white region are not of interest in this paper. Results for transitions 1 and 2 are given in Figs. 4 and 5, respectively. Results for transitions 3–6 are in SI Text. Credit: Du CX, van Anders G, Newman RS, Glotzer SC (2017) Shape-driven solid–solid transitions in colloids. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 114:E3892-E3899.

(—Phase transitions are transformations that occur between states of matter—that is, between solid, liquid, gas, and less commonly between gas and plasma. What may be surprising is that solid-solid phase transitions, which are essential in metallurgy, ceramics, earth science, reconfigurable materials, and colloidal matter, are the most common. (Examples of solid-solid phase transitions include transformations between the three primary crystalline states of pure iron and self-organizing anisotropic colloidal suspensions—that is, colloidal suspensions having different properties along different axes.) Despite their ubiquity, however, high pressure and/or high temperature contexts and the need to employ high-resolution imaging technology have made studying solid-solid phase transition intermediate transformational states significantly challenging. Recently, scientists at the University of Michigan have devised computer models demonstrating solid-solid phase transitions based on colloidal particle shape changes as the control variable, reporting both discontinuous and continuous transitions (i.e., those that require and do not require thermal activation, respectively). The researchers state that by establishing a new method for studying solid–solid phase transitions, their models may support the design and generation of reconfigurable colloidal materials.

Doctoral candidate Chrisy Xiyu Du and Prof. Greg van Anders discussed the paper that they, Dr. Richmond S. Newman, and Prof. Sharon C. Glotzer, and their co-authors published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences with Describing the main challenges in designing models that capture solid–solid phase transition thermodynamics and determining that a thermal activation barrier is not universally required in solid-solid transitions, van Anders tells that "Solid-solid transitions have been important in technology for thousands of years—in fact, since the beginning of the iron age—and are also important in geological processes. Moreover," he adds, "the pattern of symmetry breaking that exists in solids means that these transitions are not only technologically important, but that there are a lot of them. The problem in understanding the transitions is that they typically happen under extreme conditions (high temperature or pressure), which makes them hard to study."

Before their study, Du says, no other paper has done a thorough investigation of the thermodynamics for any colloidal solid-solid transitions. "This void in knowledge meant that regardless of the results we found, we needed to perform enough validation to convince ourselves that we were not observing artifacts from our simulations." She adds that anisotropic colloidal nanoparticles are perfect building blocks for crystal structure self-assembly—and researchers have been experimentally able to self-assemble these nanoparticles into colloidal crystal structures ranging from the basic and ubiquitous face-centered cubic phase to complicated phases such as clathrates.

Another challenge was finding order parameters that had appropriate signal-to-noise behavior—a particular concern, van Anders points out, because the systems they studied are entropically stabilized (that is, thermal fluctuations are fundamentally implicated in system behavior, but can complicate order parameter measurements). "Balancing these effects and checking that the behavior we observed was not an artifact of our parametrization required substantial effort."

Fig. 2. Sample self-assembled colloidal crystals formed by shapes in the Δ323 triangle-invariant family of hard polyhedra, with images showing particle shape and bond order diagram. (A) An FCC crystal self-assembled from shape (αa, αc) = (0:4, 0:525). (B) A BCC crystal self-assembled from shape (αa, αc) = (0:4, 0:59). (C) An SC crystal self-assembled from shape (αa, αc) = (0:76, 0:76). Note the similarity of shapes in A and B; even small shape differences can affect the bulk self-assembly of hard polyhedra. Shapes in A and B are both on line 1 in Fig. 1, and the shape in C is on line 2 in Fig. 1. Credit: Du CX, van Anders G, Newman RS, Glotzer SC (2017) Shape-driven solid–solid transitions in colloids. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 114:E3892-E3899.

Du notes that while studying the thermodynamics of two stable phases individually is straightforward, simultaneous comparisons are difficult. "Due to the brief timescale and low probability of the system being in a transition state, we had to apply bias forces to study it. In addition to finding the right order parameter to distinguish different crystal phases—a challenge in its own right—we carefully tuned the strength of the bias force sampling intervals to reduce noise, thereby achieving a statistically significant conclusion."

Addressing these challenges, van Anders explains, involved measuring the change in the nearest-neighbor environment for particles before and after the transition, which is usually characterized using coordination polyhedra that provide a geometric division of the local environments. "We realized that if we could come up with systems in which it is possible to directly manipulate the coordination polyhedra, it could be possible to have solid-solid transitions that occur under less extreme conditions. To do this, we realized that in suspensions of anisotropically shaped colloidal nanoparticles it is possible to manipulate the particle shape, which in turn could allow control of the shape of the coordination polyhedra in the crystal." Changing colloid shape allows for solid-solid transitions in simulations that mimic normal laboratory conditions.

Du describes two key, prior insights used in this work: entropy can lead to order, and particle shapes can be included as a thermodynamic variable similar to temperature or pressure. "In our work, we combined these two insights and extended the study of solid-solid to include building block properties such as shape. As to technical difficulties, we searched through the literature to select a good order parameter to distinguish different crystal structures, and then adapted it to meet our needs." The scientists also extended the NVT (or canonical) statistical ensemble—a constant-temperature, constant-volume ensemble—in HOOMD-blue (a general-purpose particle simulation toolkit) to better reduce noise in their simulations.

"Our work has two sets of implications," van Anders tells "Firstly, we showed that it is simple to construct minimal models of solid-solid transitions that occur in systems that can be studied in real time, simple, tabletop experiments using optical microscopy. This should give us new ways of getting detailed insight into how solid-solid transitions happen. Secondly, we demonstrated that solid-solid transitions driven by shape change occur on sufficiently brief timescales, allowing them to be used for making reconfigurable materials."

Fig. 7. Shape-driven solid–solid reconfiguration and self-assembly timescales for BCC, FCC, and SC structures. Thermodynamically discontinuous FCC↔BCC solid–solid phase transitions occur dynamically in MC simulations on timescales (τ >~ 107 MC sweeps) that are similar to self-assembly timescales (τ ≈ 106 MC sweeps) beyond the metastable region. In the metastable region, solid–solid reconfiguration does not occur on timescales (τ >> 107 MC sweeps) that are much longer than typical self-assembly times. Thermodynamically continuous BCC$SC solid–solid phase transitions occur dynamically in MC simulations on timescales (τ <~ 106 MC sweeps) that are comparable with or less than typical self-assembly times. Credit: Du CX, van Anders G, Newman RS, Glotzer SC (2017) Shape-driven solid–solid transitions in colloids. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 114:E3892-E3899.

Du tells that in some cases, with appropriate shape-change, it is possible to find solid-solid transitions that occur on Monte Carlo simulation timescales that are comparable to or shorter than timescales for self-assembly of the relevant solid phase from a dense, disordered fluid. This finding, Du adds, gives further evidence that colloidal matter provides a potential route for developing reconfigurable materials. "With the recent development of shape-shifting colloidal materials, our work can be a good theoretical guide to experimentalists: When they're trying to use shape-shifting particles to make reconfigurable materials, our work can potentially explain some of the behaviors they might observe."

"Our results also provide design criteria for selecting particle shapes and their transformations for achieving smooth versus abrupt reconfiguration, depending on the intended application," adds senior author Prof. Sharon Glotzer. "Moreover—and even more exciting—we now understand how to inversely design particle shapes for specific, targeted solid-solid transitions."

Regarding next steps, the researchers intend to understand types of transitions other than the ones reported in this paper. As to other areas of research that might benefit from their study, van Anders says that possible applications include the development of reconfigurable materials, and greater insight into solid-solid transitions in atomic systems.

"The focus of our work was on getting detailed understanding of the thermodynamics of the transitions we studied," van Anders concludes. "Moving forward, the ability to study shape-driven solid-solid transitions with optical microscopy opens up the opportunity to get very detailed, particle-level information about transformation kinetics."

Explore further: Two-dimensional melting of hard spheres experimentally unravelled after 60 years

More information: Shape-driven solid–solid transitions in colloids, PNAS (2017) 114(20):E3892-E3899, doi:10.1073/pnas.1621348114.


Observation of solid–solid transitions in 3D crystals of colloidal superballs, Nature Communications (2017) 8:14352, doi:10.1038/ncomms14352.

Shape-anisotropic colloids: Building blocks for complex assemblies, Current Opinion in Colloid & Interface Science (2011) 16(2):96-105, doi:10.1016/j.cocis.2011.01.003.

Colloidal Recycling: Reconfiguration of Random Aggregates into Patchy Particles, ACS Nano (2016) 10:4322-4329, doi:10.1021/acsnano.5b07901.

Shape-shifting colloids via stimulated dewetting, Nature Communications (2016) 7:122216, doi:10.1038/ncomms12216.

Related Stories

Melting solid below the freezing point

January 23, 2017

Phase transitions surround us—for instance, liquid water changes to ice when frozen and to steam when boiled. Now, researchers at the Carnegie Institution for Science have discovered a new phenomenon of so-called metastability ...

Phase transition discovery opens the door to new electronics

January 16, 2017

A group of European scientists led by researchers at TU Delft has discovered how phase transitions propagate throughout materials called nickelates. The discovery improves our understanding of these novel materials, which ...

Recommended for you

New study explores cell mechanics at work

June 19, 2018

It's a remarkable choreography. In each of our bodies, more than 37 trillion cells tightly coordinate with other cells to organize into the numerous tissues and organs that make us tick.

The secret to measuring the energy of an antineutrino

June 18, 2018

Scientists study tiny particles called neutrinos to learn about how our universe evolved. These particles, well-known for being tough to detect, could tell the story of how matter won out over antimatter a fraction of a second ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.