Study: Street gangs, crime serve as deviant leisure activities for youths

Study: Street gangs, crime serve as deviant leisure activities for youths
University of Illinois faculty members, from left, Kim Shinew, Liza Berdychevsky and Monika Stodolska are co-writing a series of papers that examine gang membership and criminal activity from the perspective of leisure science. The studies are based on interviews with former members of street gangs operating in Chicago and central Illinois. Credit: L. Brian Stauffer

Although at-risk youths may have a variety of reasons for joining street gangs, a new study suggests that gang membership and criminal acts often serve as deviant leisure activities, fulfilling young people's needs for excitement, a sense of belonging and social support.

Based on interviews with 30 former street gang members in Illinois, the study is one of the first to explore gang involvement as leisure activity. The paper was co-written by Liza Berdychevsky, Monika Stodolska and Kim Shinew, all professors of recreation, sport and tourism at the University of Illinois.

"Studies like this are particularly important right now, given the incidence of gun violence in cities such as Chicago and the renewed attention to gang crime nationwide," Berdychevsky said. "Developing an in-depth understanding of what drives delinquent and criminal activities - and ways that sports and other can be used for prosocial purposes - can help create more effective prevention, intervention and rehabilitation programs for at-risk youths and young offenders."

The researchers interviewed former members of the Latin Kings/Latin Queens, Satan's Disciples, the Vice Lords and other street gangs operating in Chicago and downstate Illinois. Some participants had left gang life as recently as the prior year, while others had desisted for decades, sometimes after serving lengthy prison sentences.

While active with a gang, each of the participants had been a perpetrator, victim and/or witness to violent crimes - including murders, rapes, beatings, shootings and stabbings. Some had trafficked drugs, stolen cars or committed arson or vandalism.

For some of the participants, the gang lifestyle was an intergenerational legacy -grandparents, parents and other family members taught criminal behaviors and values to the generations that followed. Delinquent and deviant activities were accepted or even expected in their families and neighborhoods, they told the researchers.

"One of the most heartbreaking things was these young people's fatalism and defeatist outlook on life - they thought there was no future for them other than dying young or going to prison," Berdychevsky said.

Many of the participants had dropped out of school or attended only sporadically. With no responsibilities and few recreational opportunities in their neighborhoods, the youths felt a pervasive need for stimulation, and they satiated their boredom with parties that were rife with sex, drugs and alcohol; violent clashes with rival groups; and crimes such as stealing and crashing cars into vehicles driven by rivals.

Gang members' reasons for engaging in crime and other gang activities were similar to those that motivate other to engage in sports or other positive recreational activities, the researchers found.

"They even spoke about their violent acts using leisure and sports terminology, such as describing how they 'hunted' their victims," said Stodolska, the lead author of the paper. "One man said he felt as if he were on a football team and the bystanders, fellow or people in his community who encouraged these behaviors were cheering him on from the stands.

"What was really striking about the people we interviewed was how much many of them enjoyed the violence. Some participants likened it to a drug addiction, which increased their attachment to that lifestyle."

Many of the interviewees described experiencing a "rush" - a surge of adrenaline, or a sensation similar to sexual arousal, according to one woman - during gunfights and other violent incidents. While many of them attributed much of their criminal activity to drugs or alcohol, others told the researchers they preferred to be sober while committing violent crimes for the sheer pleasure of seeing people suffer.

The use of leisure activities in gang prevention, intervention and rehabilitation of offenders is underrecognized currently by cities and organizations seeking to develop solutions for gang-related crime and delinquency, Berdychevsky said.

"People in the parks and recreation field need to be involved in developing these strategies, as they're one among a number of stakeholder groups that can help combat gang involvement," Stodolska said.

Since leaving gang life and/or prison, many of the interviewees currently are involved in prevention organizations such as Cure Violence/Ceasefire and the Chicago Dream Center.

"One of the things that struck me was how smart, charming, articulate and talented many of the interviewees are," Shinew said. "And they have leadership skills. On several occasions, I thought, 'Wow. If you had just made a few different decisions in your life, your future might have been so different.'"

The study, which was funded by a Campus Research Board grant, has been accepted by the journal Leisure Sciences. Stodolska, Berdychevsky and Shinew have presented their findings at five symposia thus far, including the Academy of Leisure Sciences Research Institute in Indianapolis in February; and at the Illinois Parks and Recreation Association Conference, held in Chicago in January.


Explore further

Gang members, domestic extremists vastly different, study says

More information: "Gangs and deviant leisure" DOI: 10.1080/01490400.2017.1329040
Citation: Study: Street gangs, crime serve as deviant leisure activities for youths (2017, May 23) retrieved 20 August 2019 from https://phys.org/news/2017-05-street-gangs-crime-deviant-leisure.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
17 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments

May 24, 2017
So tribalism is deviant? Tribalism is genetic. We were selected over 1000s of gens for our affinity for tribal life.

"Delinquent and deviant activities were accepted or even expected in their families and neighborhoods, they told the researchers"

-Of course...

""Primeval man", he argued, "regarded actions as good or bad solely as they obviously affected the welfare of the tribe, not of the species". Among the living tribal peoples, he added, "the virtues are practised almost exclusively in relation to the men of the same tribe" and the corresponding vices "are not regarded as crimes" if practised on other tribes (Darwin, 1871)

-These researchers seek to shame gang bangers for actions deemed honorable within their tribe??

The only way to change their behavior is to offer them membership in another tribe, that being the one the researchers themselves belong to.

The universal tribe.

May 24, 2017
""describing how they 'hunted' their victims," said Stodolska, the lead author of the paper."

-Apes hunt their competitors. The next tribe is always a little less human than yours. No difference between hunting and fighting.

"One man said he felt as if he were on a football team and the bystanders, fellow gang members or people in his community who encouraged these behaviors were cheering him on from the stands."

-How much more obvious could it be? Sports teams are an obvious expression of tribalism.

May 24, 2017
Forget Poe's law, the trolls in these comments can't even pass the Turing Test.

May 25, 2017
Forget Poe's law, the trolls in these comments can't even pass the Turing Test.
whiny/bitchy is not a valid form of constructive discourse.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more