'Zero tolerance' policies disproportionately punish black girls, professor says

January 10, 2017 by Mike Krings

When schools put zero tolerance policies into effect, such rules were intended to address problems such as violence, weapons, drugs or other illegal activities. Consequently, "zero tolerance" policies have been used to punish behavioral issues, including inappropriate dress and other minor transgressions. And like many disciplinary measures, they have disproportionately affected black students. A University of Kansas researcher has co-authored a study calling for more research on zero tolerance policies and for policy makers and educators to consider the implications for such policies on students of color, especially black girls.

Dorothy Hines-Datiri, assistant professor of multicultural education, co-authored the study with Dorinda Carter Andrews of Michigan State University and argues that zero tolerance policies are not colorblind. Much research has been devoted to how discipline policies disproportionately affect black males, but little attention has been paid to how they affect black girls. Hines-Datiri has presented the study at the American Educational Research Association's national convention and it is forthcoming in the Urban Education journal. Black girls who are punished more harshly than their white peers face a host of educational consequences that extend throughout school because they are disciplined more often and viewed by their peers and educators as more likely to be disciplined.

"What we see in data from the U.S. Department of Education is that zero tolerance policies are disproportionately affecting students of color and especially black girls," Hines-Datiri said. "How I see myself as a student has a lot to do not only with how I see myself in general, but how others see me, and it is rooted in where I am, including in schools."

The aforementioned data shows that in 2010, black girls in middle school were suspended four times more than their white female counterparts, and in the 2011-2012 year, black girls were suspended six times as often as white girls.

Hines-Datiri suggests that more qualitative research should be conducted to include black girls' narratives, address intersectionality and explore implicit racial bias of teachers and school staff. More empirical studies should be conducted specifically in the areas of critical race feminism and figured worlds, she wrote. The former explores the intersectionality of race and gender and how it influences daily experiences, while the latter examines cultural contexts and sites where identities are produced in school. Individuals "figure" who they are in relation to their social location and develop relationships within a context that is racialized and gendered by teachers and schools. Thus, black girls' experience in schools are largely shaped by zero tolerance policies that not only hold them to ideals of white, heteronormative femininity but punish them for being their authentic selves and suggests that identities other than their own are more valued.

Zero tolerance policies produce a wide array of negative outcomes, including reduced educational achievement, academic disengagement, higher suspension and dropout rates, lower wages earned in postschool careers and more students placed in the school-to-prison pipeline.

"In essence, we urge educational researchers—and K-12 educators and —to consider how disciplinary policies create certain kinds of interactions between adults and female students in learning spaces, and how those interactions around disciplinary offenses create certain role expectations in the classroom, 'adultifies' black female students and solicits certain types of behaviors from them," the researchers wrote.

Zero tolerance policies criminalize and police the types of mannerisms, language, posture and communicative styles of black girls while reinforcing their marginalization in the classroom, Hines-Datiri argues.

Policy makers can help address this issue by rethinking discipline, zero tolerance policies and realizing they are not colorblind. Humanizing black girls in school and viewing their multiple consciousness instead of essentializing them can help to reduce disparities in suspensions, expulsions and punishments given to for perceived disrespect or insubordination.

"Our hope is that school officials and policy makers can rethink not only who these policies hurt, but also who they protect," Hines-Datiri said.

Hines-Datiri, whose research examines school discipline, race and multicultural education, recently received the Paula Silver Case Award for the most outstanding publication in the Journal of Cases in Educational Leadership from the University Council for Educational Administration. The award was for a publication examining how race and culture influence school discipline when police are involved in schools.

The hope is that additional research will help schools better understand how zero tolerance policies marginalize young black women and how society and schools influence how kids learn in the classroom, and addressing their overcriminalization.

"It will hopefully bring up some good dialogue, but also results," Hines-Datiri said of the research. "We need to make sure as school personnel that kids have a place to be themselves, and also consider the consequences of the words we speak and how they will affect people who have traditionally been marginalized. We need to look at these issues how they are, not how we perceive them to be. It's about having justice in schools and having equitable schools."

Explore further: Study examines how race, culture influence school discipline, dropout rates

Related Stories

'Hip-hop' students unfairly targeted, study finds

January 10, 2014

Black and Latino "hip-hop" students are disproportionately punished in urban schools, finds a two-year study that sheds light on some of the unfair disciplinary practices newly targeted by the Obama administration.

Recommended for you

Study on prehistoric violence published

February 20, 2017

A longtime Cal Poly Pomona anthropology professor who studies violence among prehistoric people in California has been published in a prestigious journal.

'Tully monster' mystery is far from solved, group argues

February 20, 2017

Last year, headlines in The New York Times, The Atlantic, Scientific American and other outlets declared that a decades-old paleontological mystery had been solved. The "Tully monster," an ancient animal that had long defied ...

Mathematical models predict how we wait in line, traffic

February 17, 2017

As New Jersey drivers approach the George Washington Bridge to enter New York City, a digital sign flashes overhead with estimates of the delays on the upper and lower levels of the bridge. Most drivers choose the level with ...

4 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

philstacy9
3 / 5 (2) Jan 18, 2017
Punishment corrects bad behavior so it is a good thing. Black girls receive a disproportionate benefit.
rhugh1066
5 / 5 (1) Jan 18, 2017
"Thus, black girls' experience in schools are largely shaped by zero tolerance policies that not only hold them to ideals of white, heteronormative femininity but punish them for being their authentic selves and suggests that identities other than their own are more valued."

What does that sentence even mean? Since when is it "white" to obey the rules? And people wonder why the local news is filled with the daily slaughter of black-on-black killings. *sigh* And no one seems to give a damn.
MR166
not rated yet Jan 18, 2017
"Humanizing black girls in school and viewing their multiple consciousness instead of essentializing them can help to reduce disparities in suspensions, expulsions and punishments given to black girls for perceived disrespect or insubordination."

Oh this paper is just filled with racial gems isn't it. Does " multiple consciousness" infer that they are exempt from the rules of general society?
MR166
not rated yet Jan 18, 2017
What the paper is inferring is that there should be different rules for different cultures. Huuum, let's see how that would work. Lets say I am a Muslim and I catch my woman flirting with a man. Can I behead her or am I limited to only forty lashes?

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.