Texas mulls changing science standards questioning evolution

January 31, 2017 by Will Weissert

The Texas Board of Education will decide whether to scrap a requirement that public schools teach high school students to scrutinize "all sides" of scientific theory after hearing Tuesday from academics who say that was meant to water down lessons on evolution and leave students wondering whether God created the universe.

Supporters of the existing high school science curriculums told the board that changing the rule could hurt independent thought in classrooms across America's second-largest state.

How Texas teaches its 5.3-plus million public school students evolution has been a flashpoint for years, despite federal courts rulings against teaching creationism and the similar theory of in . The standards govern what teachers cover in classrooms, topics on standardized tests and the material published in textbooks statewide. Texas is one of the nation's largest textbook purchasers, so changes publishers make to meet the state's curriculum standards can wind up altering contact in textbooks sold around the U.S.

In 2009, the Board of Education dropped a then-20-year-old requirement directing science classes to teach "strengths and weaknesses" of the theory of evolution and added a requirement that students learn to scrutinize "all sides" of . A panel of Texas teachers and experts is recommending the board of 10 Republicans and five Democrats remove that language, saying it is confusing and time-consuming for students and unnecessarily allows religious and conservative ideology to trump science.

The board heard hours of testimony Tuesday and will hold preliminary votes on the standards later this week.

"The establishment of our educational goals should not be based on opinion polls," Arturo De Lozanne, a molecular bioscience professor at the University of Texas, told the board.

A testy moment came when former teacher Tanya Estes urged removing "creationism from our science curriculum." David Bradley, a Republican board member from Beaumont pressed her to "please cite" where "creationism" appears. Estes responded by questioning Bradley's "mocking smiling."

The standards do not specifically mention creationism, but critics say they have the practical effect of challenging evolution. Besides the "all sides" language, expert panels also have recommend removing teaching about gaps in the fossil record that religious conservatives argue show significant changes to life itself that could suggest the influence of a higher power.

Republican board member Barbara Cargill noted that many oil and gas sector leaders have urged that the fossil record be taught in Texas classrooms.

"Their big thing is: Our kids need to learn more about the and they need to question things that are out there," said Cargill, of The Woodlands in suburban Houston. "If there is a question, then they need to know about that."

Ray Bohlin, a science fellow for the Discovery Institute—a group that promotes intelligent design, which holds that certain features of life forms are so complex that they can best be explained by an origin from an intelligent higher power—said removing the current standards could mean "evolution gets a free pass."

"There are some very real ideological objections to any evidence that could be construed as compromising to evolution," Bohlin said. "And I think that's behind a lot of this."

How the board will vote remains unclear, but Bradley said after the hearing that he's not expecting major changes to the science curriculum.

"I can count," he said, referring to the Republican majority. "It'll be a Republican vote, though there'll be some harping and whining."

Explore further: Texas education board approves science standards (Update)

Related Stories

Science materials in Texas get prelim. approval

July 22, 2011

(AP) -- An expected fight over teaching evolution in Texas classrooms fizzled Thursday when the state's Board of Education gave preliminary approval to supplemental science materials for the coming school year and beyond ...

Texas board hears testimony on science standards

March 26, 2009

(AP) -- Tensions over the teaching of evolution are simmering as the State Board of Education begins the final stretch in the process of adopting new classroom science curriculum standards.

Texas Ed Board compromises on evolution materials

July 22, 2011

(AP) -- The Texas State Board of Education gave final approval to supplemental high school science materials on Friday, delivering a blow to the board's social conservatives after a brief flare-up over some lessons teaching ...

Recommended for you

What rising seas mean for local economies

February 15, 2019

Impacts from climate change are not always easy to see. But for many local businesses in coastal communities across the United States, the evidence is right outside their doors—or in their parking lots.

Where is the universe hiding its missing mass?

February 15, 2019

Astronomers have spent decades looking for something that sounds like it would be hard to miss: about a third of the "normal" matter in the Universe. New results from NASA's Chandra X-ray Observatory may have helped them ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.