Society remains convinced rewards work, despite evidence they decrease motivation

January 20, 2017
Society remains convinced rewards work, despite evidence they decrease motivation
Credit: University of Reading

Employers continue to believe that performance-related cash bonuses, such as those offered to bankers, increase motivation, despite evidence showing they may decrease interest in their work.

In a new study, psychologists at the University of Reading tested people's expectations of the effect of incentives, and found most firmly believed they result in improved future performance.

The study follows earlier research that found, while offering financial or other rewards can lead to a short-term improvement, the recipients are in fact often less interested in completing the task well in future.

Dr Kou Murayama, a Psychology associate professor at the University of Reading who led the research, said: "Society has a deep-rooted misunderstanding of how works, and employers are repeatedly shooting themselves in the foot with the frequent use of rewards to encourage certain behaviours or increase effort.

"Our work shows we need to correct our strong misbelief in a carrot and stick approach to achieve sustained motivation among workers."

The findings of the study, published in Motivation Science, are applicable to many scenarios. As well as questioning the benefits of paying bonuses, they also cast doubt on whether parents can bribe their children with sweets to make them behave, or if rewarding students will make them continue to study hard in the long run.

In the experiment, hundreds of participants were given a description of a previous study carried out by the same team and asked to make a prediction about the results. It compared whether a group offered a performance-based reward for playing a game were more likely to play again than a group offered no incentive.

More than half of the participants (62.5 percent) believed the group would be more motivated to play again, but in fact the opposite was true. To confound matters, those making the wrong assumption were also far more confident in their predictions than those who guessed correctly.

The team suggests rewards actually undermine motivation, by triggering a subconscious feeling in the recipient that their autonomy is being threatened. People offered rewards may also find they focus on this more than the task itself.

Earlier work by Dr Murayama looked at the balance between external rewards and internal motivation, and whether this means money could be used less often as an incentive. He said further tests in situations that more closely mimic real life will be needed to determine this.

Rather than relying on rewards to control others, respecting autonomy and is one alternative strategy that it is thought could achieve better results. Changing working patterns or payment schemes could also improve motivation.

Dr Murayama said: "So much effort is put into having an immediate effect on students or employees, and it is true that people respond well in the short term to things like financial incentives. However, we have shown that providing a workplace that meets people's needs and improves job satisfaction is likely to have a greater impact on employees than money on its own.

"In the future, it may be possible to explore how such incentives can be transformed into an inner desire in the person to carry out tasks, which is far more powerful."

Explore further: Cannabis reduces short-term motivation to work for money: study

More information: People's Naiveté About How Extrinsic Rewards Influence Intrinsic Motivation. Motivation Science, DOI: 10.1037/mot0000040

Related Stories

Task master: Categorizing rewards improves motivation

May 29, 2013

What truly inspires individuals to perform at their very best? When it comes to motivating others and ourselves, it turns out offering rewards in defined categories, even when they are largely meaningless, can heighten motivation. ...

Small cash rewards pay off in weight loss plans

November 20, 2014

People who received small cash bonuses for their degree of participation in an Internet weight loss program shed more pounds than those who were not offered bonuses and they kept much of the weight off, according to a new ...

Recommended for you

New paper answers causation conundrum

November 17, 2017

In a new paper published in a special issue of the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A, SFI Professor Jessica Flack offers a practical answer to one of the most significant, and most confused questions in evolutionary ...

Chance discovery of forgotten 1960s 'preprint' experiment

November 16, 2017

For years, scientists have complained that it can take months or even years for a scientific discovery to be published, because of the slowness of peer review. To cut through this problem, researchers in physics and mathematics ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

antialias_physorg
5 / 5 (4) Jan 20, 2017
People offered rewards may also find they focus on this more than the task itself.

Crucial takeaway message: Make the task rewarding - not the reward.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.