Research exposes prejudice over teachers with northern accents

May 12, 2016 by Kath Paddison

Trainee teachers with northern accents are under pressure to speak 'the Queen's English' in the classroom, according to a study carried out at The University of Manchester.

Dr Alex Baratta, a lecturer in linguistics, found that accents most associated with the Home Counties were favoured by the teacher training profession.

Last year Dr Baratta found trainee teachers with northern accents felt they were 'selling out' because they felt they had to change their accents to be understood in the classroom, having been instructed to do so by their mentors.

His latest study explored teacher accent, identity and linguistic prejudice and centred on schools based in the south of England - the previous study involved northern schools.

The research, according to Dr Baratta, exposes a culture of linguistic prejudice for a profession which would not tolerate prejudice based on race and religion.

He said: "There is a respect and tolerance for diversity in society, yet accents do not seem to get this treatment – they are the last form of acceptable prejudice! One teacher told me that it makes no sense that teachers have to sound the same, but teach the children to be who they are."

In interviews with trainee teachers with , Dr Baratta said almost all of his participants admitted that their accent had been picked-up on by mentors, leading to too many teaching staff feeling they had to neglect their 'true voice' and modify accents that were somehow deemed inappropriate for education.

"The I spoke to believe that they are being judged for how they speak and not what they say and asking them to modify their accents made them feel inferior," he said.

Another participant from the Midlands claimed that a mentor with a southern accent said that she'd be 'best to go back to where you came from', in relation to her pronunciation of 'a' and 'u', as in 'bath' and 'bus'.

"While Received Pronunciation or the Queen's English was historically regarded as the most prestigious accent, there is evidence to suggest its influence is less pervasive nowadays amidst growing recognition of, and respect for, regional accents.

"We live in a society in which equality is championed and diversity is celebrated, certainly within the workplace so why does it feel as if the teaching profession is completely discarding the unique richness that comes with regional accents."

In 2014, Dr Baratta conducted the first study into how in Britain affects the way people feel about themselves. He found that many people felt like fakes for 'poshing up' their accents to fit in to certain work and social situations, threatening their personal identities and often causing anger and frustration.

Explore further: Teachers feel pressure to 'standardise' their accents in class

Related Stories

Brits feel fake when 'poshing up' accents

July 8, 2014

Some Brits with regional accents see themselves as frauds when they change their accent to cope with social situations, according to a University of Manchester linguist.

Accents impact workplace and consumer choices

October 3, 2014

(Phys.org) —An accent can affect an individual's evaluation and impact perceptions of competence, scholarly research tells us. But do negative assumptions based on accent translate to decision-making and behaviors?

Are bilingual kids more open-minded?

March 5, 2014

There are clear benefits to raising a bilingual child. But could there be some things learning a second language doesn't produce, such as a more open-minded youngster?

Recommended for you

2 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

dirk_bruere
not rated yet May 12, 2016
Accent still matters a great deal in the UK, and not just regional
ElizabethNonw
not rated yet May 13, 2016
This is a relevant issue for the teaching of phonics, which is my speciality. I have found that there are people in the south of England who believe that they speak correctly with no accent and that other people have accents. This is an illogical and prejudiced belief.

In fact it is easier to teach phonics with a northern English accent, because the vowels match the spellings more consistently. The examples of 'a' and 'u', as in 'bath' and 'bus' are good ones. In the north, 'baths' rhymes with 'maths' and 'but' rhymes with 'put', but not in the south.

However, it is not straightforward with all accents. If children speak English in a way outsiders cannot understand or if English is not their first language, we owe it to them to model a pronunciation of words that is easily understood by outsiders.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.