Daffodils help inspire design of stable structures

May 10, 2016, American Institute of Physics
The unique geometry of the daffodil stem could be used to design more stable structures. Credit: Artwork © 2016 Sally J. Bensusen/Visual Science Studio

In 1940, the Tacoma Narrows Bridge collapsed in dramatic fashion, twisting in the wind before it snapped and plunged into the water below. As wind blew across the span, the flow induced oscillating sideways forces that helped bring down the bridge—just months after opening. This type of side-force oscillation can also damage antennae, towers and other structures.

Now, researchers from Seoul National University and Ajou University in South Korea have found that a structure with a twisted, helical and an elliptical cross section—inspired by the stem of a daffodil—can reduce drag and eliminate side-force fluctuations.

The researchers describe their findings this week in Physics of Fluids.

Side forces come into play whenever wind flows across an elongated object—like when you stick your arm out the side of a moving car. As the air flows around your arm, it forms vortices that come off the top and bottom of your arm in an alternating fashion. This vortex shedding, as it's called, imparts periodic forces on your arm.

"You will immediately feel that your arm will be forced to move up and down," explains Haecheon Choi of Seoul National University.

This phenomenon, called von Kármán vortex shedding, affects any elongated structure caught in wind or water currents such as lampposts, high rises and the long vertical pipes used for drilling oil at sea.

In the case of the Tacoma Narrows Bridge, the frequency of these periodic forces happened to hit its resonant frequency.

"This vortex shedding triggered the twisting mode of the bridge," Choi said, "and finally the bridge collapsed."

To find a way to reduce these forces, the researchers looked to nature for inspiration. Specifically, they studied the shape of a daffodil stem, whose twisting, lemon-shaped cross-section enables it to turn away from wind and protect its petals.

The researchers used computer simulations to explore the fluid dynamics around the daffodil stem's shape: a helically twisted, elliptical cylinder. They tested different variations—some with more elliptical cross-sections or with more twists, for example—in smooth, laminar airflow or a more turbulent wind.

In both cases, the daffodil shape made a big difference.

"Some helically twisted cylinders annihilated the vortex shedding, resulting in drag reduction and zero side-force fluctuations," Choi said. Compared to a round cylinder, the daffodil shape reduced drag by 18 and 23 percent, respectively, for laminar and turbulent flows.

The unique geometry of the daffodil stem could be used to design more stable structures. Although such a shape probably doesn't make sense for a bridge, it could work for things like antennae, lampposts, chimneys, underwater oil-drilling pipes, sky-scrapers and even golf clubs. In fact, Choi said, the researchers already have a patent for a helical golf club.

Explore further: Vortex Bladeless aims for lower-cost wind energy approach

More information: "Flow around a helically twisted elliptic cylinder," by Woojin Kim, Jungil Lee and Haecheon Choi, Physics of Fluids, May 10, 2016 , DOI: 10.1063/1.4948247

Related Stories

Vortex Bladeless aims for lower-cost wind energy approach

May 18, 2015

A technology leap forward in wind energy? Or, as the company in charge calls it, a "new paradigm" of wind power, lowering costs, requiring no training, using fewer supplies? They believe they have a great idea and they aim ...

What guitarfish and aircraft wings have in common

May 5, 2016

Recent research by a team led by Jonathan Cox and Zhijin Wang shows how water flows through the nose of a guitarfish, a type of ray. The team discovered that vortex-like structures in their noses help the guitarfish to swim ...

Liquid spiral vortex discovered

April 19, 2016

In many plumbing and pipework systems in general, there are junctions and connections to move liquids such as water in different directions, but have you ever thought about what happens to the water in those fluid intersections? ...

Recommended for you


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.