How high-speed wireless compares to cable in boosting our internet speeds

April 28, 2016 by Thas Ampalavanapillai Nirmalathas, University Of Melbourne, The Conversation

Australia's national broadband network continues its roll out with more than 900,000 premises now connected, according to NBN Co's latest weekly progress report.

But Google recently announced the development of high-speed wireless internet connections, which raises the question of which technology is the best for any future broadband network.

Political influence

The technology options for deploying broadband in Australia have reflected political thinking and been heavily influenced by changes in federal government. Broadband technology also keeps improving and the continuing debate about choice of technology is hindering effective investment.

The current option for the NBN is a multi-technology mix (MTM). This approach emerged after a strategic review of the project undertaken by the Abbott-Turnbull Government.

MTM has the NBN network comprising to the home, hybrid fibre coaxial (HFC) cable network, hybrid fibre-copper cable and wireless options (fixed wireless and satellite ).

But Google's wireless plan adds fuel to the ongoing debate about whether cable connections will soon be obsolete?

The original fibre plan

The NBN's original choice of fibre to the premises (FTTP) remains not only the most future proof against rapid changes in technological evolution but also offers the highest speeds of connectivity and lowest delay (latency).

Low latency is very important for the smooth operation of any interactive application. In fact, telecommunications networks rely on optical fibre and the closer that the fibre can get to end user, the better the performance.

Hence, the debate has centred around how best to connect users to fibre over the last few kilometres.

NBN Co is interested in the HFC cable sourced from Telstra and Optus as it has an installed fibre network base within 10km of the subscribers who are connected by a copper-based coaxial cable. This has greater capacity than the standard twisted copper pair phone lines.

If NBN Co can bring fibre close to a network termination point and then utilise the existing copper based telephone lines, there are new technologies that can push the speeds of connection in the short term to that comparable to fibre.

But their upgradability is low and the last few kilometres of copper as well as the terminal equipment will need to be replaced with optical fibre or other improved technologies in the future.

Wireless still needs cable

Even the broadband wireless options being considered by Google rely on a wireless access point located close to the users. That is almost guaranteed to be connected by the optical fibre.

In order to provide wireless access with broadband, the access point needs to have a directional beam towards the user or have a smaller radius of coverage with fewer users. This would imply a significantly large number of wireless access points interconnected by an to provide a coverage to everyone.

There are plans to provide wireless broadband using satellites (NBN's Sky Muster and OTHER WHAT? others) and other floating platforms (Google's Loon Project).

But these cannot offer high bandwidth, as it will be shared by a larger number of users. They would also be significantly limited by the excessive delay caused by getting the signal to space and back again.

There is no one ideal solution, but it depends on the population density. Satellites and other space-based platforms provide universal coverage over the Earth's surface with reasonable bandwidth in a shared manner. But the delay would be a problem when it comes to highly interactive applications involving audio, video or real-time interactions.

It is ideally suited for hard-to-reach places as well as for providing universal coverage of basic broadband to sparsely located populations.

Alternative technologies, such as those being considered by Google, provide rapid deployment at a lower cost. But they also have a compromise in terms of upgradability.

Similarly, all other hybrid options such as fibre to the node (FTTN), fibre to the building (FTTB), fibre to the distribution point (FTTdP) and HFC provide low-cost activation options while deferring the upgrade costs to a future date.

These are options that network operators have when they are making decisions about investing their capital to expand the network, and shorten the time to bring services to market.

Looming election

Will the looming election cause a further change in the NBN policy?

Rethinks based on political ideology has already caused significant delays and uncertainty regarding the project.

What's needed is bipartisan commitment to accelerating NBN deployment along with modernising the infrastructure in the core network that will have to support increased access to broadband.

Internet Australia, the body representing internet users, is calling for bipartisan support for any NBN strategy. But it notes that Australia has dropped from 30th to 60th in global rankings for average internet speeds.

So it wants bipartisan support to drop the current MTM strategy in favour to adopting at least fibre to the distribution point, although it says fibre to the premises would be the "ultimate goal".

Explore further: Australia extends deadline for broadband network

Related Stories

A full fibre network is the only way to future-proof Britain

November 30, 2015

Another day, another government announcement heralding the coming of high-speed broadband for all – in this case the call, by the prime minister, David Cameron, call to make broadband a universal service obligation that ...

New hardware to expand fast fiber-to-the-home

February 14, 2016

The cost of deploying fast fibre connections straight to homes could be dramatically reduced by new hardware designed and tested by UCL researchers. The innovative technology will help address the challenges of providing ...

Recommended for you

Tiny 'water bears' can teach us about survival

March 20, 2019

Earth's ultimate survivors can weather extreme heat, cold, radiation and even the vacuum of space. Now the U.S. military hopes these tiny critters called tardigrades can teach us about true toughness.

A decade on, smartphone-like software finally heads to space

March 20, 2019

Once a traditional satellite is launched into space, its physical hardware and computer software stay mostly immutable for the rest of its existence as it orbits the Earth, even as the technology it serves on the ground continues ...

Researchers find hidden proteins in bacteria

March 20, 2019

Scientists at the University of Illinois at Chicago have developed a way to identify the beginning of every gene—known as a translation start site or a start codon—in bacterial cell DNA with a single experiment and, through ...

Turn off a light, save a life, says new study

March 20, 2019

We all know that turning off lights and buying energy-efficient appliances affects our financial bottom line. Now, according to a new study by University of Wisconsin-Madison researchers, we know that saving energy also saves ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.