Scientists prove reliability of quantum simulations for materials design

March 25, 2016, Royal Holloway, University of London

Royal Holloway physicists have been part of an international effort to demonstrate the reliability of computer simulations in the sciences, achieving a strong proof of this in the subject of computational materials simulation.

The findings are critical at a time of rapid technological change with increasing demand for new materials to make better batteries for mobile devices, catalysts, photocells for energy conversion and much more. Computer simulations at the atomic scale play an increasingly important role in designing them.

The international team asked the question: just how reliable are these simulations? If we are to make the rapid technological advances we all seek, we need to be sure that researchers and engineers across the world can rely on getting the same results. Such reproduceability is a corner stone of science: independent yet identical experiments should produce identical results. Only in this way can science identify 'laws', which lead to new insight and new technologies. However, several recent studies have pointed out that such reproducibility can not be taken for granted.

Over the last few years there has been growing alarm in the scientific community that some results cannot be reproduced. Even predictions of the same physics by different software packages ("computer codes") require caution, since the way in which theoretical models are implemented may affect simulation results.

For the study and design of materials, for instance, there are several independent software packages available based on quantum physics. The UK's leading materials simulation package, "CASTEP" is developed at Royal Holloway in collaboration with with researchers based at Oxford, Cambridge, Durham and York and the Science and Technology Facilities Council. Codes including CASTEP are being used increasingly often in automated procedures with limited human supervision in the new field of "materials informatics". It is therefore essential to know to what extent predicted materials properties depend on the code that was used.

Despite the need for reliable predictions of the properties of materials, the reproducibility of quantum simulations had not been investigated systematically before now. Scientists from Royal Holloway's Department of Physics therefore joined forces with more than 60 colleagues in the UK and worldwide, bringing together the know-how of over 30 prominent institutions.

In their study, which appears in this week's edition of Science, the researchers investigated 40 different software packages and variants to describe the influence of pressure in 71 different crystals.

Due to the international make-up of the team, discussions and collaboration were conducted using online tools – similarly to the way people collaborate to write Wikipedia. The team can now demonstrate that, although a few of the older methods disagree noticeably among themselves, predictions by recent codes are almost identical. They moreover define a quality benchmark that allows the verification of future software developments against their extensive database. New test data are continuously added to a publicly available website ( The researchers hope that this work will lead to to higher standards for property simulations, and that it will ease the development of improved simulation codes and methods.

Explore further: Researchers launch next generation of brain scanners

More information: K. Lejaeghere et al. Reproducibility in density functional theory calculations of solids, Science (2016). DOI: 10.1126/science.aad3000

Related Stories

Researchers launch next generation of brain scanners

March 18, 2016

The next generation of magnetoencephalography (MEG) brain scanners is now under development and one of the key enablers to produce lower cost, high performance machines is a nano electronic device designed at Royal Holloway ...

Researchers control properties of light using nanostructures

March 8, 2016

A theoretical study based on computational simulations conducted by the UPV/EHU's Nano-bio Spectroscopy Research Group in collaboration with the Japanese research centre AIST has shown that the intensity of ultraviolet light ...

Supercomputing for materials simulation

May 9, 2014

The National Physical Laboratory (NPL) and international partners are using advanced supercomputers to develop a new framework for accurate materials simulation.

Recommended for you

Accelerating light beams in curved space

January 12, 2018

By shining a laser along the inside shell of an incandescent light bulb, physicists have performed the first experimental demonstration of an accelerating light beam in curved space. Rather than moving along a geodesic trajectory ...

New exotic phenomena seen in photonic crystals

January 12, 2018

Topological effects, such as those found in crystals whose surfaces conduct electricity while their bulk does not, have been an exciting topic of physics research in recent years and were the subject of the 2016 Nobel Prize ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.