Research resolves old polymorphism puzzle

March 11, 2016, Linnaeus University

The coexistence within species of two or more different forms has puzzled biologists for more than a century. According to evolutionary theory, natural selection should remove inferior individuals from the population, and thereby erode diversity and promote monomorphism. New research published in the journal Scientific Reports demonstrates that polymorphism as such can be beneficial for both individuals and populations by offering protection against predators.

That colour may offer protection against predators was suggested more than a century ago. A few studies have confirmed that individuals that are members of polymorphic groups may benefit from reduced predation risk. However, there has been no evidence that polymorphism can increase survival of populations.

Researchers from Linnaeus University in Sweden and Åbo Akademi University in Finland photographed grasshoppers, displayed the images on computer screens in groups that represented four levels of polymorphism, and then asked humans to act as 'predators'.

"We aimed to investigate whether and how polymorphism of natural camouflaged colour patterns affects survival of populations. We also wanted to examine whether the protective effect is similar or different for alternative colour morphs," says lead-author Dr Einat Karpestam.

The study included 70 human subjects and more than 3300 grasshopper images. Overall, humans needed more time and detected fewer grasshoppers when the images were presented in mixed than in homogeneous groups.

"Our results are important because they offer the first experimental demonstration that the protective effect of polymorphism can extend to the level of populations. This finding helps resolve the old puzzle why colour polymorphism is so common in nature," says Dr Sami Merilaita.

But are these results reliable? Can computer-based detection experiments really inform about natural processes? According to senior author Professor Anders Forsman the answer is yes.

"Our previous research shows that results obtained using this approach mirror imposed by real predators, such as birds, when they hunt for live and free-moving prey in the wild."

These results have some interesting implications for us as humans. For instance, the of polymorphism depended on individual characteristics of the prey. Some colour pattern phenotypes benefitted more from being members of mixed groups than others. This implicates a conflict of interest among individuals with regard to what is the optimal group composition. This is likely to influence individual decision making and can negatively impact on interactions and group dynamics.

Another lesson from the study is that dividing ones attention can be costly.

"It seems that we perform better if we focus one thing at a time. This realization is important to bear in mind in an era when multi-tasking is considered something to strive for," says Professor Anders Forsman.

Explore further: Bird color variations speed up evolution: research

More information: Einat Karpestam et al. Colour Polymorphism Protects Prey Individuals and Populations Against Predation, Scientific Reports (2016). DOI: 10.1038/srep22122

Related Stories

Bird color variations speed up evolution: research

May 9, 2012

Researchers have found that bird species with multiple plumage colour forms within in the same population, evolve into new species faster than those with only one colour form, confirming a 60 year-old evolution theory.

Diversity provides stability among the animals in the wild

August 13, 2015

Why some species of plants and animals vary more in number than others is a central issue in ecology. Now researchers at Linnaeus University in Sweden and from the Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research (UFZ) have found ...

Cannibalism of the young allows individual fish to specialize

May 23, 2007

Whitefish, Arctic char, threespine stickleback and some sunfishes display quite discrete groups living in the same lakes but utilizing different food resources in order to survive. The phenomenon is called "resource polymorphism." ...

There is strength in diversity

September 17, 2015

Altered or new environmental conditions, such as those brought about by shifts in human land use and climate change, impose challenges on living organisms. This can drive species to extinction if they fail to adapt or adjust ...

The devil is in the detail

January 9, 2015

Researchers have looked at a species of fish to help unravel one of the biggest mysteries in evolutionary biology.

Recommended for you

Duplicate genes help animals resolve sexual conflict

February 19, 2018

Duplicate copies of a gene shared by male and female fruit flies have evolved to resolve competing demands between the sexes. New genetic analysis by researchers at the University of Chicago describes how these copies have ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.