Alternative fuels need more than hype to drive transportation market

March 3, 2016 by Kat Kerlin, UC Davis
Dan Sperling, director of the Institute of Transportation Studies at UC Davis, stands beside his Toyota Mirai, a hydrogen fuel cell vehicle. Credit: UC Davis

Hype followed by disappointment: That's been the general pattern over the past few decades when an alternative fuel is presented to the public. It's a fuel du jour phenomenon, from methanol to hydrogen, where government leaders and the media hype a new fuel, only to abandon it when lofty expectations are not met.

Policymakers who want to decarbonize the transportation sector will need to move beyond hype and find better ways to assess and sustain promising technologies and fuels, suggests a study from Simon Fraser University, Canadian consulting firm Navius Research, and the University of California, Davis.

"Technology hype is a highly inefficient, but natural, phenomenon," said co-author and professor Dan Sperling, founding director of the UC Davis Institute of Transportation Studies. "The challenge is to fashion policies and strategies that acknowledge and harness hype as we transition to low-carbon fuels and vehicles."

The study, published in the journal Nature Energy, looks unsparingly at the history of hype around vehicles and what policies and innovations are needed to move from current shortfalls to widespread commercialization of low-carbon vehicles.

Hype not enough for low-carbon world

"Transportation is one of the biggest challenges in climate change abatement," said lead author Jonn Axsen, an environmental professor at Simon Fraser University. "We are a long way from where we need to go. A full-on transition to alternative fuel vehicles needs to start today to have any hope of cutting our emissions by 80 percent in 2050." That is a target to limit global average temperature rise to 2 degrees Celsius.

Alternative fuels need more than hype to drive transportation market
This chart from the study shows how media attention skipped among numerous alternative fuel technologies between 1980 and 2013. 

The study tracked alternative fuel vehicle media attention from the New York Times, research and development funding from the U.S. Department of Energy, and prototype development by the world's 15 largest auto manufacturers between 1980 and 2013.

The study shows that public attention has jumped from one alternative fuel to the next in continuous waves: first with methanol, natural gas and plug-in electric vehicles in the late 1980s and early 1990s, then to hybrid electric vehicles, hydrogen, and biofuels in the late 1990s and early 2000s. Most recently, attention has shifted back to .

"Media, governments, and industry are all contributing to hype," said co-lead author Noel Melton of Navius Research. "It is not necessarily a bad thing, but history has shown that hype is not enough to get us to a low-carbon world."

The study said governments can avoid the cycle of hype and disappointment by conducting better technology assessment. This can allow them to set more reasonable sales targets for alternative fuel vehicles and implement the policies needed to get there.

Explore further: Government initiative needed to boost electric vehicle use

More information: Noel Melton et al. Moving beyond alternative fuel hype to decarbonize transportation, Nature Energy (2016). DOI: 10.1038/nenergy.2016.13

Related Stories

Government initiative needed to boost electric vehicle use

July 16, 2015

Canadians want electric vehicles but governments need to help support the market, according to a team of Simon Fraser University researchers. The team has found more than one third of Canadian buyers want an electric vehicle—particularly ...

China boosts fleet of electric, hybrid vehicles

March 19, 2015

Chinese authorities have announced plans to boost the number of electric, hybrid and other alternative fuel-powered vehicles used for public transportation, while sales of such cars for private use have spiked in recent months.

Alternative-fuel cars are no carbon cure-all

June 12, 2013

( —Making cars more fuel-efficient is great for reducing greenhouse gas emissions, but rather than promoting sales of electric and other alternative-fuel vehicles, policymakers should turn their focus to cutting ...

Recommended for you

Uber filed paperwork for IPO: report

December 8, 2018

Ride-share company Uber quietly filed paperwork this week for its initial public offering, the Wall Street Journal reported late Friday.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.